's Reviews
All reviews by
TOP CONTRIBUTORTOP CONTRIBUTOR
39 reviews
Loved it!
The color and drape of this blouse is fantastic, and it is so comfortable! It was amazingly flattering on me, so I was glad I rented it after having some hesitation in reading other reviews. Whether this blouse works will probably depend on where the length hits you. This is one of those soft, voluminous tops that are best worn with skinny pants, and if the length hits you in the wrong spot, it might make you look larger than you are. However, I say it is worth giving a try because, if it works for you, this one is tempting enough to buy!
Member Fit Notes
Blaine Top
Ramy Brook
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Amazing bathrobe?
I will start by saying that the material on this blouse looks and feels absolutely gorgeous! I was in love with the color, and it felt amazing (if surprisingly heavy). However, after trying 15 different ways, I simply could not find a way to wear this that it didn't look like I had opted to put on a luxurious bathrobe over my clothes. Between the length and the sleeve shape, I just don't think the robe comparison can be avoided.
Member Fit Notes
Longsleeve Daisy Top
Louna
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Cute, cool, and comfortable
This blouse is perfect for a hot summer day when dressing casual but wanting to upgrade a bit. The only reason I knocked off one star is the material - it is nice enough, and comfortable enough, but looks no where near the quality one would expect from the stated retail value.
Member Fit Notes
The Whisper Shirt
The Great.
Size Worn: 3
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
So unique and fun!
This shirt is so amazing. It is unusual and will get you compliments wherever you go. I ended up trying it with a black silk, collared blouse underneath to see if there was a way to wear it to work, and sure enough, it worked great that way too! ... sort of had the effect of a feminine menswear/tie look. I highly recommend. The only things that some may not like are (1) it is fashion forward, not figure flattering and (2) it is comfortable overall but can feel a bit restrictive through the chest (which is actually helpful for wearing this as a sleeveless top without worrying about exposure or having to adjust all day)
Member Fit Notes
Racing Stripe Plaid Top
Monse
Size Worn: 14
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Beautiful and unique
I absolutely loved this coat. I did size up quite a bit, too much, and it still worked. What obviously makes this one standout is the unique color of teal and the sleeves. It looks polished and classic, yet completely different from anything else. I am glad I ordered the wrong size and that Spring was already here, or I may not have been able to resist the temptation to splurge on this one!
Member Fit Notes
Emmeline Coat
Deborah Lyons
Size Worn: 18
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
May not be earth shattering, but a great blouse nonetheless!
This is just one of those great throw-on-for-anything blouses. Unlike some of the other reviewers, I found the size to be just right. It does have fullness, but in the right way. I am short-waisted, and I do think that is helpful here. Perhaps you aren't going to land on the cover of any fashion-forward blog, but on those days that you just want to be comfortable and throw something on with a pair of jeans that looks a few steps above your everyday t-shirt or denim blouse, this is a great option.
Member Fit Notes
Millie Ruffle Blouse
Sanctuary
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
A great combo: flattering and comfortable!
These pants are so comfortable, and look really flattering and professional. They are nice and different from your run-of-the-mill black work pants. They are also very easy to dress either up or down. Unfortunately, I did not realize how fall/winter they were when ordering, and they looked pretty out-of-season for March here in Texas, so I am going to have to hope they are still around come November and try again.
Member Fit Notes
Windowpane Hans Trousers
Snider
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Good idea; wrong fit
The idea of these pants is fun, but as other reviews have mentioned, the fit just doesn't work - unless perhaps you have large calves relative to your hips and thighs. Like any legging should, they have nice stretch so as to be flexible in sizing above the knee, but suddenly they become wide and unfitted below the knee which, with the faux leather material, results in a really odd and, frankly, cheap look (like a plastic bag that stretched and didn't go back in place).
Member Fit Notes
Faux Leather Side Stripe Leggings
Josie Natori
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Has a lot of potential, but need to size down
The style and feel of this dress are really nice (hence the 4 stars), but it ran large so it became unflattering and I was unable to wear. Having an apple shape, I do tend to size up in dresses, but that was definitely a mistake here. The top is full and the material is a bit bulky, so using the tie waste to make up for the added size doesn't really work on this one. I think the best bet would be to pick the size that is on the smaller end of your lower body size, as it seems there is more flexibility at the top and the skirt really needs to be fitted. Sadly, it is going back unworn but I may try again in a size (or two) smaller.
Member Fit Notes
Black Bow Front Shirtdress
Tome
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
One of a kind!
I am strangely in love with this odd little top. First, it is super flattering on my apple body-type when worn with fitted pants - made me look like I actually had a waist and good posture (which I don't)! Second, it is extremely high quality in material and design (a nice soft suiting-type material for the main, and an interesting netting for the sleeves). Third, it manages to be both classic and completely unusual at the same time. It does run quite large (beyond the clearly intentional volume), particularly in the chest area, so I would size down next time. This one might be pretty difficult for petites to wear. I knocked off a star because the sleeves were comically long on my average length arms (and I like a long sleeve). I was able to turn them up like a cuff (and the nice suiting material lets them stay in place, so it worked), but for smaller ladies, there may be no compensating for it and the volume of the shirt could be a bit overwhelming on smaller frames.
Member Fit Notes
Mesh Belize Top
UnitedWood
Size Worn: 14
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Fabulous, unique dress
This dress is truly beautiful. Being an apple shape, straight midi or long dresses can be a problem for me, but this one just worked (I did size up). The ruffle and mixed prints looked like they might add volume but, instead, these helped create an optical illusion that drew attention away from the midsection and made the dress so flattering. Magic!
Member Fit Notes
Pink Printed Ruffle Midi Dress
Diane von Furstenberg
Size Worn: 14R
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Very unique dress!
This dress gets full marks in the unique, well made, and comfortable categories. I did not end up wearing it, but only because it looked too dressy for my casual office when worn with any of my summer sandals. I plan to re-rent in the fall when I can dress it down a bit with boots. Note: This dress has a really loose fit that is in no way sexy or body-emphasizing. It is more about when you want a fun, fashion forward look rather than an impress your significant other look.
Floral Pleat Dress
MSGM
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Close to perfect
This blouse is simply beautiful! The lace trim is amazing and hangs so well ... it's like they figured out how to turn the feeling of a wedding dress into a casual, everyday top. It does run really large, but it is purposeful and gives a nice, relaxed effect. (If you wear things fitted, skip this one, as no amount of sizing down will get you there.) I did have to knock it down for one pretty annoying flaw that kept me from even considering keeping this -- The button at the back neck is nearly impossible to button/unbutton. There was no way to do it while on without assistance. The opening is large enough to put it on and take it off buttoned but it runs a serious risk of getting makeup on the beautiful cream fabric that way. Too bad because otherwise this item is perfection!
Lace Flared Sleeve Top
See by Chloé
Size Worn: 44
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
I wish I could keep it forever!
This dress is truly fantastic. It is comfortable, the right length for a normal-height person, and so flattering. It is rare that I will wear sleeveless, but with the need to have a nice dress that I could still walk around in during summer heat on vacation, I gave it a try. This made my arms look as thin as possible (which is all I can ask - the rest is on me!) and has a great neckline. I was able to dress it up with jewelry for an evening show and dress it down with casual sandals for an everyday look. I would say it runs large, so size down, especially if you want to be able to wear it without the tie at the waist (my preference)
Renata Maxi Dress
Tory Burch
Size Worn: 12R
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Beautiful (I just rented too large)
I loved this top. The style was fun and the fabric was much softer and lighter than expected. It is so comfortable even in the extreme heat of summer. It does run very large though. I like tops loose, so I didn't think the larger size would be an issue, but due to darts at the chest, any oversizing is notable and looks odd. I will definitely rent again in a smaller size (probably down 2). If small chested, you will probably want to size down, but I think this blouse might be a really good option for those who are larger.
Blue Martine Top
Tanya Taylor
Size Worn: 14
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Loved it and bought it
I rented this for a vacation, wanting a cute comfortable dress I could walk around in the heat and wear with comfortable shoes. When I got it, I realized it was lovely and very versatile ... I have dressed it up with red pumps for work and wore with sneakers when walking around. Fit is true to size and, for a short button up dress, I had no issues with gaping either between buttons or below the bottom. Unlike so many dresses, this one is equally good and comfortable sitting or standing.
Pinstripe Pleated Shirtdress
kate spade new york
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Better if you are tall
I did not end up wearing this for three reasons. (1) It was too big (my fault in taking a risk on a larger size since it was available). (2) I thought the length on this was unflattering - if you are 5' 8" or up, it might be great. (3) I just wasn't sold on the fabric ... something seemed inexpensive looking when I put it on even though you could feel it is in fact high quality. Overall, I didn't hate it but I don't find myself excited to wear it either.
Tulip Poppy Dress
Tanya Taylor
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Gorgeous but starting to show wear
This blouse is very flattering and very different. The style is comfortable even though the material is not soft. I really loved it and would have given 5 stars and been tempted to buy, but the top has been well loved - the white had slightly grayed and the ruffle layers are delicate and mostly unfinished, so there was some sign of unraveling. Still, nothing that was too noticeable when wearing - only on close inspection. I would say this runs slightly small only because it fit in the shoulders and an XL would typically be too large for me there. The main body of the blouse has size flexibility though.
Ivory Nana Top
Alexis
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
So fun!
This blouse is really fun and surprisingly comfortable once you get past the initial odd feel of the sleeves that lasts about 5 minutes. You then realize they do stay in place and you can move your arms just fine! One of the best things about this blouse (beyond the great color and print) is you can control where you place the sleeves to strategically hide your least favorite area. One thing to note - while overall I think it is true to size, it was a little snug in the chest (and I am pretty middle of the road for my size in that area) so larger chested ladies may have some issues.
Red Floral Etta Top
SACHIN BABI
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Comfort with an edge
I really enjoyed this blouse (and yes, it is a blouse not a dress, as the lowest button on the front is maybe an inch below your navel). The fabric is soft and with a nice stretch allowing you to roll up the sleeves in hot weather and, for this type of blouse, does generally well on the wrinkle front. The color is feminine while the cut is edgy, making for a nice and unique blend. Also, I like how it looks and feels loose, making it very comfortable, yet still comes in at the waist so as to not lose all shape. Overall a hit in my book!
Rosa Shirtdress
Jil Sander Navy
Size Worn: 44
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
My favorite combo - Cute and comfortable
This is a nice, comfortable dress that is classic in style, but with a twist thanks to the print on the material. I opted to wear with leggings, even though perhaps not the best look, since I was going to be running around and getting up and down a lot on windy day. However, it is certainly long enough to be work appropriate (at least if you are average height) in normal circumstances.
Husky Print Dress
kate spade new york
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Versatile and Fabulous!
This vest is amazing in every way and super flattering. Between the color, the weight, and the style, I have already thought of 100 ways I would like to wear it every season of the year. It is interesting, yet classic enough to always be in style. I think it is true to size but the tie style provides a lot of flexibility. I rented a size larger than I needed, yet it still looked good even when worn slightly open to show the sleeveless tunic underneath. I really wish I could bring myself to buy this one!
Wrap Waist Vest
HALSTON
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Absolute perfection!
I love everything about this dress. It is simply gorgeous and generates non-stop complements. Wish I could justify the price to buy it, but it's so noticeable, you would only want to wear a few times a season. The color is the perfect shade of blue ... not too grey or denim like, but rather a pure and bright periwinkle/wedgewood blue that should be super flattering on a lot of skin tones. I would say go with your regular size or, if in between, go down. I went up, as I prefer a loose fit, but it actually ended up being too loose and, as it is cotton and brand new, it did "grow" slightly throughout the day.
Blue Gabriella Dress
Tory Burch
Size Worn: 14
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Fine, but not a wow
I rented this for the color (In Austin, anything close to burnt orange is very useful for all the UT events) and it's cute for that reason. It's also flowy and very comfortable. It's not particularly special, but sometimes you just want to wear a nice blouse without all the extras. I do wish mine had come with the tie I saw in some of the review photos. Would have added a little more to it.
Terracotta Kennedy Blouse
Free People
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Gorgeous, but flat stomach required
I was so sad I couldn't wear this dress. It is absolutely beautiful and super flattering in all areas but one ... the tummy area. It doesn't just show your tummy, it both magnifies and emphasizes it. So, alas for people like me who had a tummy even when I was overall skinny (much less how I am today) it is hard to wear. But for you flat-stomach girls out there, this is truly stunning.
Floral Rianna Dress
Alexis
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Cute and easy to wear
This blouse is a really nice, casual item that goes with everything. Is it going to blow you away and draw all kinds of attention? Probably not. But for looking nice, cute, and put together on a normal day, this works perfectly.
Samantha Eyelet Blouse
Sanctuary
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Has potential if you can get it to fit
I thought the material and make of this jumpsuit were really top notch and fun for a casual, run-around item. I knocked off a star because I just think this is the type of jumpsuit that probably would work better if you could try it on first and have it tailored, so it is difficult as a rental. I personally would prefer wearing this really loose and comfortable and, therefore, sized up. In doing so, it got saggy in the back-end and, thus, unflattering. Perhaps I will try again sometime at my proper size.
Member Fit Notes
Striped Jumpsuit
Splendid
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
It's all about the fabric
I love everything about the look of this dress and i really liked the fit. Unfortunately though, as is often the case with me with button front dresses, I had issues with buttons gaping. However, what really makes this dress is the fabric, so I just opted to wear it open over a tank as more of a long blouse/duster. Still enjoyed wearing it and still got tons of compliments .
Member Fit Notes
Printed Nantucket Red Dress
Tory Burch
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
I want to keep this one!
This top is amazing! I loved everything about it, but particularly the mix of materials and the side bow. It is very flattering on someone like me who carries their weight at the top. You do have to be willing to accept all of the issues that come with any wrap shirt (low cut, risk of falling open, adjusting tie), but these were easily fixed on this one as I think it looks even prettier left open at the top with a full tank underneath and the tie is plenty long to allow a double tie bow. Also, while I personally liked the long sleeves, I rolled them up due to Texas heat and it actually worked nicely. I am so tempted to buy this!
KoKomo Floral Top
Diane von Furstenberg
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Adorable - So sad it didn't work for me
This dress is absolutely adorable and super flattering. Ultimately, I did not wear it, but only because it felt too short/exposed when sitting for someone my age. I would have been comfortable only if I was going to be standing all day (on a wind-free day). Anticipating that from other reviews, I had ordered a size up hoping that would help, but alas it did not. It did fit like a glove though and skimmed flatteringly in all the right places, which is what makes me say this runs a little small. If you are someone able to pull off a shorter dress, you should definitely give this one a try!
Member Fit Notes
Gingham Ruffle Dress
Slate & Willow
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Nice in theory, but one detail too many for me
These jeans have great potential if (a) you are young and (b) are built very straight. They are super comfortable, nice quality, and have great stretch for a good fit. However, for me, with all of the pocket details, they were too juvenile looking and simply not flattering. The pockets on the front are long and squared, and on the back have buttoned flaps, more like you would see on cargo pants. While nothing wrong with cargo pants, I just did not think that type of pocket worked on such a super-skinny jean unless you have no hips or rear at all. They add bulk and the back pocket flaps stick up, making it awkward to wear with anything long. Also, these were oddly hot (hotter than normal jeans).
Member Fit Notes
Park Skinny Jean
Joie
Size Worn: 31
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
A fun everyday shirt
This is a really nice, comfortable everyday shirt. What makes it special is the color. I know some reviews have said mustard, but I would categorize it as more gold and it really stands out. I have fair skin with red undertones that don't work with mustard at all, but I was able to wear this. It does run large and boxy and has volume, which I personally like on my body type, but if you do not, you might need to both size down and tuck in.
Another Eternity Top
Free People
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Attention-getter
I have to admit I felt a little self-conscious wearing this at first. While I like to wear things outside of the norm, I wasn't sure if the cape look would be going a step too far for my office and I don't typically like to show my arms. In the end, however, this turned out to be a real showstopper. I received 3 compliments from the first 3 people I saw before I even made it from the parking lot into the building, and they continued all day from women and men, conservative and casual dressers alike. It really is a great statement piece! Highly recommend.
Member Fit Notes
White Cape Travis Jacket
BCBGMAXAZRIA
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Cute but strange fit
This is really cute in concept, but odd in execution so I returned it without wearing (and tags still on ... sigh). I am apple shaped without a really defined waist, so I always size up in any dress with a set waist. Even in doing so, this was snug in the arms and chest (not usually my issue) and while the waist technically fit, it was extremely short waisted on an already short waisted person. Not flattering at all. Still, i gave it three stars as, if you are lucky enough to have the right fit for this dress, the colors and style are adorable and very unique!
Pink Broderie Anglaise Dress
byTiMo
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Grows on you
When I saw this on the website, I wasn't sure, but once I wore it, I loved it! It does not photograph well (as indicated by my own photo) but is actually a really cute, comfortable casual top with interesting details in person. It is also amazingly flattering, as most shoulder showing items are not a good look for me, but the bow and size of the opening really make it work. I did knock off one star for the labor required to iron the bow. It came completely creased and crumpled and even after 15 minutes of ironing just two ribbons, I don't think I got them all. Also, it may not be as unique of a find as some other RTR items but it still got tons of compliments from others! I would say runs slightly small, as I usually would have worn a size smaller but this worked fine in the larger size.
Member Fit Notes
Meadow Lark Sweatshirt
ella moss
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
So great I bought them!
I fell in love with these instantly. Great fit and have the masterful combo of serving as a basic khaki pant that goes with everything while at the same time being completely distinctive. I usually don't look great in wide leg pants, particularly cropped, but somehow these just worked. They were so perfect, I had to make them mine forever!
Carmelina Pants
Cinq à Sept
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Most Compliments Ever!
Love, love, love!!! This blouse is exactly what RTR is made for! Everything about it was perfection - high quality, well fitting, memorable - but it is so distinctive that you would only want to wear it months apart, so hard to own. When I rented this, I thought that I would love it but that it might seem like a lot to others. I was so wrong! I got compliments from pretty much everyone I saw while wearing, including strangers coming up to me and asking where I got it. It is a statement piece to be sure! I wore with a pink tank underneath to keep down the skin exposure (too old for that) and wore with jeans for a fun, casual look,. Can't wait until enough time has passed that I can rent and wear again!
Pink Elva Lace Top
UnitedWood
Size Worn: 14
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Smocking very constricting
I ended up not wearing this, as the smocking on the high neck, chest and arms all felt very claustrophobic to me. Admittedly, I like loose, flowing things though, so it was likely a personal issue. It is cute, fits well, and looks nice on if you don't mind the feel.
Bohemian Smocking Blouse
byTiMo
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"
Perfect jacket for Spring
Great jacket that was a lot more versatile than I thought it would be. I ended up surprisingly deciding to pair it with a yellow shell and jeans for a casual day at work. Got a ton of compliments and was completely comfortable in the Texas heat. Will definitely rent again.
Pink Floral Jacket
Tara Jarmon
Size Worn: 44
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 6"