Slate & Willow

I liked the dress because it is a really beautiful color and looks great on. However, it runs a bit small. I wore the next size up and still felt that the top was too small. The sleeves were tight and I felt like my arm movement was restricted. Also, it isn't great if you have a large chest because it has very little stretch on the top. The bottom fits well - the belt/waist hits at the best place to flatter your figure...or hide a small baby bump.

This was a sweet dress for a holiday party. It's flattering, however, it runs VERY small. I'm a pretty reliable size 4 in dresses, but the back-up size 6 just fit. I highly recommend renting up one size from your usual size and then up one size from that for the back-up.

This dress did not fit my upper body at all. If you're at all busty I'd think again. The torso was very snug and SO tight at the arms. I got the dress to fit BUT COULD NOT MOVE MY ARMS. I ended up not even wearing this dress to the event I rented it for

This dress runs runs extremely small. I usually wear a 4 or 6 and the 6 was nowhere close to fitting.

The material is very heavy but that wasn't the problem. It was a very weird fit. Extremely tight around the arms and this dress just didn't work for me unfortunately.

I loved this dress! I ordered it for a Christmas party and it was absolutely perfect. The skirt is fun and full, the bodice has lace. The sleeves were a little too tight. The bodice has a nude underlay and the arms are just lace. Overall, perfect! And I got TONS of compliments. Perfect with a black, nude, or metallic pump.

I loved how this dress looked, but it was definitely not made for someone with anything other than wafer thin arms. I have muscle tone and my arms aren't even all that big, but the sleeves were a bit tight. Uncomfortably so!

This dress was overall fairly comfortable but the lace in the arms was very tight so make sure to size up.

This dress is really pretty! I love the color and the style of the dress is great. I got this dress overnighted to me after my original rental didn't work. I sized up based on the previous reviews. However, the dress still didn't work for me. The sleeves are very tight, but so it the armpit area, so you can't lift your arms above your shoulders. Had I been going to an event that did not include dancing, I probably would have worn this. I was attending a wedding and I needed to be able to raise my arms up to dance! ;) Would definitely try this again, but size up again knowing how small it runs because it is really a pretty dress!

Perfect For a Fall Wedding - Received Many Compliments! I am a size 4 and I rented the 6 as a backup because I read that the sleeves were tight. The 4 fit me like a glove and the arms were very snug (no give to the lace at all), so I ended up wearing the 6 so the sleeves weren't as tight and the waist was not as tight (room for drinks and food!). I loved the quality of the material, it was nice and thick. The skirt was a good length and fun to dance in! The color is also a bolder color in person, which I loved. Overall, I am glad I sized up because I was able to stay comfortable all night with many drinks and cake.

This dress was beautiful, it was my husbands favorite but at 5 months pregnant the waistline was too snug for my comfort. I thought it had more of an empire cut but it was just an inch too low and cut into my baby bump. I wish I could have fit in it because the material and cut was so beautiful!

The dress is very pretty and was flattering and comfortable in the body, but the sleeves have absolutely NO give to them. For the first time in my 2+ years of RTR I had to have another size shipped to me - that's how bad the sleeves were. Thank God for RTR's fabulous customer service team!

I rented this for a wedding reception with my husband's family; his mom was adamant about having us home after our smaller, destination wedding to show us off to his extended family and her friends, so I needed to be on point. This dress was seasonally appropriate for fall and really lovely. I got a lot of compliments and felt good in it. I wore the size 4, true to my normal size, and it fit well... save for it being somewhat tight in the shoulders and bust. There's little give. I had to pull it down from time to time. Overall, I'd rent it again.

I wore a larger size than usual, and it was still tight. Not as flattering as I had hoped. I felt the pleats in the skirt, made my bottom half look bigger...but perhaps I have already gained a few holiday lbs! The arms were tight, which I had expected, I have worn this style before. But it was also tight across the back, like hard to reach forward. It worked for the night though. And I received many compliments. Overall happy with it for one night.

I rented this but decided on a different dress I rented because it was a bit more comfortable. This was a very pretty dress but like many of the other reviews said, the sleeves were extremely tight and limited my mobility in my arms, which is the main reason I didn't wear it to the party.

Runs small in the arms. The lace is not very stretchy either which made it difficult to get on and off. The zipper also had a habit of sticking right over the black belt detail. The color and design were fun and elegant, would wear again! Just size up next time.

I'm a normal, average size zero...however, this ran way to small. I would rent again in bigger size.

This dress was beautifully made, I got tons of compliments at my husbands work Christmas party. I'm wore a 6 but could have worn an 8 due to the arm sleeve size. Highly recommend going one size up for the backup!

I was unable to fit in this dress due strictly to the sleeves (my arms are big for my size??). There is absolutely NO give with the lace. This dress is a beautiful dress, and I was upset that I was unable to wear it. It would have been flattering on my hourglass figure. Receipt and return were incredibly easy and worry-free. I look forward to using RTR again in the near future!

As others have note the arms ran small, but the dress was lovely. It was beautiful for the Christmas Eve party I attended. I would recommend it!

I initially ordered this dress in my size and one size up, but when I received them, they both had holes in the underarm area. Fortunately, the excellent RTR Customer Service was able to send me replacement sizes and even allowed me to change them to 1 and 2 sizes up and I ended up wearing the dress that was 2 sizes up. Even though it was a little loose in the waist, it was much more comfortable in the arms. It was great to dance in all night and I'd definitely rent it again!

The sleeves are tight! I don't have the biggest arms, but I don't have the smallest arms either. I had to go up a size just to get my arms in the sleeves. I also needed help with the zipper in the back and the hook & eye. Otherwise, this was the perfect little dress!

Some other ladies posted that the dress ran small, so I went a size larger. But even at a size larger, the sleeves were painfully tight. Granted, I have muscular/larger arms... so maybe I should have sized up twice. Just be aware. Otherwise it was a cute dress!

I loved this dress! I wore it to a holiday party for my SO's work. The dress was a little snug. The sleeves were very tight on the guns! I wore a 4 but would have probably felt more comfortable in a 6. I would recommend going a size up for your back up dress.

Sigh. I had such high hopes for this dress. It's more of a deep cranberry than the photo shows, which is super pretty, and the skirt is like that thicker foam-esque material, which is also super pretty. Unfortunately it's not cut right for me. I have somewhat muscular arms from yoga and I couldn't even get the sleeves on past my elbow for the size 4. I had to squeeze them into the size 6, which meant I couldn't lift my arms, but then the waist of the 6 was too big, and the thick material of the skirt made me look pregnant. Not what I was going for as a single girl at a wedding. Didn't end up wearing it and had to go buy something else - not a great experience overall.

This is a beautiful dress but be advised, the arms are extremely tight. Unless you have super thin arms, I would suggest another style of dress.

This dress is beautiful, but unfortunately I couldn't wear it. Lace on the arms is fairly tight (wouldn't be able to lift arms up much) but doable, skirt is lovely and falls nicely away from body, but the black band around the middle was soooo tight! The size 2 fit everywhere except here...could barely even zip past this and once I did the bad cut into my ribs way too much to consider wearing. I tried to rush order the size 4 but it was unavailable so I wore my back-up style (which I loved). This could be a great pick if you're very small-framed!

Loved the fit! got so many compliments. very classy!

I almost always wear a 0 from RTR but the arms on this were TIGHT. I couldn't even get them over my biceps, so I was glad I had ordered the 2 for my backup size. The 2 fit perfectly. The dress was a gorgeous cranberry color in person, which was ideal for the holidays. I highly recommend this - one of my favorite rentals!

This is a beautiful dress. I ordered a size up because I read the reviews about the arms and the 6 would have fit me, but the arms were incredibly small. They have no stretch whatsoever, so if you have muscular arms or any extra tricep padding, this isn't the dress for you.

The dress ran a little smaller than I expected (the sleeves were a little tighter that I would have liked) but overall it was lovely. I received a million compliments that night. Plus it was so fun to twirl in the bouncy, empire-waisted skirt!

Dress is very elegant and fits true to size. It was a little snug at the bust, but I could still wear it no problem. I recommend!!

The waist was true to size. It fit me perfectly, very form fitting. I loved the material of the skirt, as it was a bit heavier than I expected, making it feel and look more expensive. The color was lovely as well. A very deep burgundy red, with blue tones as opposed to orange, perfect for a holiday party. The only drawback, as others have mentioned, was the sleeves. The lace looked lovely, but there is absolutely no stretch at all, and even with a very slender arm, it is very difficult to put on, and impossible to raise your arms above your head once the dress is on. The rest of the dress was so lovely, that I managed to still love it throughout the party. I just had my husband reach for things for me. Overall, I would recommend, if you don't plan to dance too wildly in it.

I received tons of compliments. It felt great and moved well on dance floor. I felt it ran true to size. The lacy on the top fits snug but didn't feel tight.

First of all I absolutely loved that dress, the fabric is so soft and the cut is flattering. The down sides are that the sleeves and chest areas are extremely tight. There was limited motion in the arms because of how tight it was. I read the reviews and went with everyone's advice ordered the dress a size bigger and the backup dress was two sizes bigger. I am normally an 8 but ended up wearing the 12 for comfort. I would recommend this dress for anyone!!

I went with the other reviews and ordered a size up. The arms were slightly tight - but not distracting. The dress was very flattering when standing up. But when sitting down, the black waistline didn't have any give so it was very tight and didn't allow the dress to lay as nicely. The red wasn't as bright in person as it is in the pictures, but was still a nice color.

I normally wear a size 2, read that the sleeves run tight and ordered a 4 and i couldnt even get the sleeves all the way on. unless you have very very thin arms order 2 sizes up. Its a shame i didnt even get to wear this.

I am glad I ordered a size up. The sleeves are tight and I had to wear a size bigger to actually move my arms. The dress is very comfortable and I got compliments on it.

This is definitely a beautiful dress, however, beware that the sleeves are tiny. There is absolutely no stretch as the sleeves are lace. I am a size 10/12, and had no chance with the size 10, the dress fit great in the waist and bust on the size 12, however, the sleeves were still a bit tight. The color is really beautiful, and the picture displays it very well. I wore this on a date with my boyfriend, and was very happy in it!

The arms were tight and the zipper was very tricky. I was afraid it wouldn't zip! Overall it was a great dress