Greylin

Fit perfect around the arms, although I don't think you could do too many layers under. I'm pretty short so it was long on me but I liked the coverage. It was fuzzier looking in person but I didn't even care considering how soft the fabric was and how surprisingly warm it was. I would definitely rent again.

Looks very nice and eveything fits under it. Hidden buttons (careful not to yank them off!) make for nice lines. Very good pockets for careying cell phones, keys, anything discretely without changing shape of coat (great for subways).

Wore this jacket for two weeks. Loved the style, size, length, color. My only issue is when I received the jacket a button was already missing and a second one fell off as I was wearing it.

I'm petite so it was a little big for me. It was not too heavy and provides enough warmth for 50C degree weather. I like the color and how versatile it is.

It was super comfy but I wore an xs and was still a little too big buttoned up. Looked great open though

True to size. Color more camel in person comapred to the pink underton displayed in the stock photo.

This does have a bulky fit but I think it still maintains a straight line thin appearance, I would not size up as there is plenty of room for sweaters underneath. The color goes with a wide variety of outfits and can be worn for work or play. Being from FL, this kept me very warm in the midst of NYC winter :)

I rented this coat for everyday wear around the holidays, but it never left the closet. I would definitely size down if you're cosidering renting this item. Otherwise, great color and textures!

Read the reviews and sized down-- that was a good choice. I got a small and I'm usually a size 10. It buttoned with extra room. There was a button missing, thats my only complaint.

The fit was fantastic. It works with both sweaters and blouses. The weight is so very light but it kept me very warm. I was surprised how light, yet effective. Lots of compliments!

The coat falls at a great length- just below the knees. The pockets seemed a little to far towards the back but it didn't bother me too much. Overall really glad wigh the purchase!

Pretty color, warm wool. Great for the cold temps!

This coat is very warm and cozy! Wore it in 10-20 degree weather and was toasty warm. It does run large and is a more bulky style.

Love this coat, very warm! The buttons come off easily, but it seems like RTR fixes those when the item is returned since several of the clasps were not originals. I rented in a large but easily could have work a medium. Plenty of room in that thing.

The coat is roomy enough to layer if neccessary, the pockets are big enough to hold gloves and the snap buttons are convenient.

The coat wad beautiful but missing a button so was not able to wear.

I love this coat! I love the length. It'sright below the knees. It's so warm and comfy.

I wore an extra small and it ran large on me. Super cozy with great pockets. They might need an XXS!

Classic and timeless. This coat goes with anything and makes any outfit look chic. The coat is soft and warm. The color is what makes it neutral that it goes with anything. I highly recomend this coat. I enjoyed wearing it during a snowy weekend in Chicago.

Big but still classy. Go a sz down if you prefer snug

Beautiful color, shaggy texture adds character, nice big pockets! Nice attention to detail with pinstripes on inside lining. Third button down doesn't quite snap close but i mostly wore it open so not too bothered by it. Dresses up whatever you're wearing...even made my pajamas look cool.

Great jacket but runs a bit on the larger side. Also long. Super warm!

The jacket is nice and loose with great pockets. But the buttons are barely sewn on. They come of ridiculously easily to where I wouldn't wear it before the event I rented it for

Looks baggy in the photo, but was better fitting than that. Great coat

Perfect camel coat. Loved it. Fit well as it's designed to be a bit oversized.

So comfortable and warm. Loved this one.

Very warm/matches everything pretty much

Super warm and comfy. Oversized fit. Rented for a trip to Chicago and it worked well for formal and casual wear.... roomy enough to layer over other jackets, but warm enough by itself. Loved that it was versatile and good quality, but I was just super disappointed about coloring. I was expecting something in the range of tan or khaki and it was more of a dark burnt orange.

This is a great jacket and super flexible to wear for work or weekend. Based on the photo and other members photos, I was expecting a khaki or beige and this was way off into the rust/pumpkin color family. I communicated with RTR that I must have received the wrong jacket because of the color and they told me it only comes in one color and I must be mistaken. I received one that was NWT so it looks like they got a new shipment of the coats in the "wrong" color.

Pros: fun yarn texture coat, my friends thought it was vintage and luxurious. Cons: runs large. There are two color variations - photo shows camel, but I (and other reviewers) received the burnt sienna. The coat runs large and loose. Note on warmth: it was fine for Chicago fall; but not very wind-resistant. Definitely layer if the temperature is hovering around the upper 40s.

Definitely not the color on the model, more of a deep burnt orange but absolutely beautiful & so comfortable

I loved this coat! I was expecting a light beige color as pictured but it was a dark rust instead. Nothing like the picture RTR provide but nonetheless it was beautiful coat. Kept me warm all day + night in NYC 40 degree weather. Definitely oversized. I wear a S-M size and got a small in this coat and it was still a bit large. I suggest downsizing. Also, RTR, you should change the picture to reflect the coats true color!

I rented this coat for a wedding weekend in NH. It was dressy enough to wear the night of the wedding, but casual enough to wear to breakfast the next day too. It was a little darker than pictured on the site but still worked with what I had planned. After reading the reviews I sized down to an XS which was perfect: I could still fit a sweater underneath but it still looked oversized, most importantly it kept me warm in 20 degree NH weather!

Loved the coat but it definitely needs explaining. I ordered the coat in a small and an XS . I received the same coat in 2 different colors (see pic). The small was the lighter camel color from the RTR pic but the XS was a darker rusty color. And they both fit me the same even though they were two different sizes which leads me to believe the darker one runs even bigger than the lighter one. The darker rusty color actually looked better with my coloring than the camel color so I only wore that one and I liked it so much I purchased it. Like another reviewer said, there's no way of knowing which color you are going to get when you order it but either way I would size down.

Great coat!

Rented this for the dropping temps in nyc. It was very warm but I was actually surprised at how big it was. I'm 5'4"/5'5" and this hit me mid calf. I also had a ton of space when I buttoned it up. I liked it but will probably go down a size next time.

It was a cute coat, wish I would of gone down a size because it is pretty oversized. Loved the collar and color.

As a 5'1" girl, it's always challenging for me to find things on RTR that work well for petite girls like me. I loved the color of the coat and really wanted this to work. I ordered a S but it was just still too large for me. The coat on the model hits a little above the knee, but on me was all the way down to mid-calf. It just looked like the coat ate me up.

I love wearing oversized materials, and this one is perfect for me. It reminds me when I used to ravage through my mom's closet. I love the medium-heavy material and layers that keeps you warm, but also allow you space to comfortably move around. The texture of the wool definitely feels and look much differently from the stock photo, but it ia still very chic and modern. I especially love the deep pockets. The buttons are easy to clip on and feels durable. Totally recommend anyone who wants something flexible to wear casually or even up at formal events, too.

I love this jacket from far away, but close up -- as others have pointed out -- you end up looking really wooly? I didn't end up liking the way the texture looked. I'm not sure if the jacket I got had just been worn a lot, making it look scruffier than it was, but it didn't give the "put together" look as I had hoped. It was really warm though.