Nailed it with the size and didn’t take these off. I am small but curvy (+ behind!). Super cute with white tank tops and Birks or mid-stars. Will rent again next summer!

Love this denim! Worn holes around. More of a grey color. Not black. Great length and perfect fit!

My outfit for the Lady Gaga concert was inspired by another RTR review - thank you to that girly for the look! I had a great time and received lots of compliments. I rewore the shorts over a bathing suit for a beach day at Tahoe. They are very short (kind of roll up due to the cut hem) and have a button fly, but are comfortable

COH is my favorite denim line. Right up there with mother. These fit true to size for me. There is not a lot of stretch so that is something to consider. High waisted, easy to wear everyday.

I'll buy these soon! Cute details, fun cut-- like the cutoff jeans (cut off from real jeans) I had in the 90s. They do fit huge though-- or I just don't know my size in Citizens (very possible). They're meant to be oversized, but this photo shows when I first tried them on. By the end of the day, they were still cute, but it was clear I could fit at least 2 sizes smaller. I think one size down would have been perfect. I have a 28" waist + 39-40" hips. These are size 27, but ideally I'd buy 26.

wore these on my bachelorette in california. loved the style and the length of the shorts but they ran a little large in the waist.

Just didn’t love more than my black Levi shorts. Very distressed which was fine. Nothing outstanding.

Great fit true to size. Comfortable and they don't ride up. All buttons though not a zipper

I wore a 32 and they zipped and I could sit but they were about as snug as they could be and still be wearable comfortably. I am currently about a 35" waist and 45" hip if that's helpful to anyone. Perfect cutoffs for summer.

Perfect fit and length

Great shorts. Really liked the high cut.

Obsessed with these shorts. 1 year postpartum and these fit amazingly. Not too short and cover the stomach perfectly (my problem area). I kept them for several rentals and ended up purchasing. Rent them! I’m 5’7 and 184. Size 14 and the 32 were perfect.

They are a little loose fitting but I like that. Comfortable and perfect length.

I adore these shorts. I own them in blue and have rented both these and the white version. They are all perfect. Honestly I should buy them I wear them so often. They fit slightly oversized so perfect to wear on a hot day or over a swim suit. Long enough they won't show any cheek action but not too long

The fit was looser on me, but I liked the oversized look! I was able to get a lot of use out of them. They were cute for class or just running around with friends. Was tempted to purchase.

Great fit. Loved them so much I had to buy them! Not too short- doesn’t show your cheeks. But not too long to be frumpy.

Soft material and just all around perfect. I will rent again in the summer!

Practically lived in these shorts while I had them!

Fits larger than expected

Perfect fit !

Great pair of casual jean shorts

Super cute but was too big in the waist unfortunately

I ordered my usual size. They fit overall but were a little tight in the waist. I like that they’re long enough in the back, even for my height (5’8”) and booty!

I have this problem with shorts often, so it’s not a surprise, but if you’re a tall girl with hips/booty, these shorts may be shorter than you expected.

I liked the rise and length of these shorts. Felt on trend, but I still felt fine wearing them in my mid 30s unlike the 100+ pairs of Jena shorts I've tried on over the years...

ran a touch large, but they were perfect for every day wear. i ride my bike all the time so they were perfect for biking to a casual date, hangout, or just a ride around the city. flattering, a little stretchy, and didn't show too much b00ty

Wish these had fit a little better and been smaller but liked the overall look of them so tried to make it work anyways. Still wore once but being that they were so baggy I didn't love the look on me. Will try to rent again in smaller size if one becomes available though.

The only 2 "issues" I had was that the right leg had no fridge and also curled up on itself and the RTR tag was scratchy on my thigh and hung out the bottom. I ended up pinning it up to the pocket.

I liked the idea of these Jean shorts, but unfortunately they were too small and VERY short. My booty was 100% showing out the bottom. The inseam feels even shorter than described. If you’re shorter or petite, these would work for you

Super cute shorts- just too big. It bunched up in the pelvic area.

Loved these, but they were too big & I didn't wear.

I ordered a size 31 and they were teeeeny no where close to buttoning. That's about how big these run and I'm an 8/10. Recommend sizing up!

Fits like small short denim shorts

These were shorter than I expected. Couldn’t do it.