Carolyn's Reviews
All reviews by Carolyn
TOP CONTRIBUTORTOP CONTRIBUTOR
69 reviews
Soooooo small
Thank goodness I sized up to a L (I’m a solid medium) - but prob could have gone up to extra large. Agree with what others have said about zero stretch. I had to squirm my way into this and I have a short torso and it barely covers my chest. Also totally flattened my size dd breasts. The high rise cut is also super weird. Why is it so high? No one wants to see that
Member Fit Notes
Rosette Lace Bodysuit
Ronny Kobo
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
This is huge
I thought I sized down by getting a M bc I’m in between sizes but I really do think I would have needed an xs to make this work. It’s falling off my waist and is way too long for a shortie like me. I have to hike it up to my chest. Bummer because it’s super pretty
Member Fit Notes
Sweet Escape Maxi Skirt
Lioness
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Great new years dress
I got this new with tags when I rented it. I only wore it to my living room but it was so flattering and pretty - wish I had a gala or something to wear it to! Also easy to wear without a bra. Perfect for new years or a winter gala or wedding!
Member Fit Notes
Silver Tulle Midi Dress
Theia
Size Worn: 10
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Great skater type dress
A little big (but I sized up based on reviews of the brand). So pretty and well made and flattering I almost kept it. Thicker material but it’s nice because it smooths everything out
Member Fit Notes
Kristen Mini Dress
Agua Bendita x RTR
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Not for ladies with boobies
I made it work but man this is not made with anyone who has anything larger than a c cup. Cut so low on the sides and zero support so i felt like they were just falling out all night (especially if you’ve had kids and/or nursed like I have). But it’s so pretty and I appreciate they got petite lengths
Member Fit Notes
Darmy Maxi Dress
Agua Bendita x RTR
Size Worn: LP
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Loved it
This was so flattering and easy to wear. I didn’t find it too long or frumpy even at my height. I kept it
Member Fit Notes
Strap Bow Detail Denim Midi Dress
Moon River
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Omg. The Goldilocks of sweaters
Is this the best sweater I’ve ever rented from rent the runway? I think so! Is it the prettiest? Probably not, but omg is this is so soft. So cozy. I want to live in it forever. The material is a buttery dream and I don’t think I’ll ever be able to wear a wool sweater ever again? If you’re sensitive to animal fibers like I am, this is just the absolute best. Not too hot, not too cold. The best. I don’t think yall are getting this one back. It is dry clean only which is my only hesitation to keeping it
Member Fit Notes
Plaid Knit Polo Sweater
Untitled in Motion
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Bust: 36DDD/E
Wore Napa wine tasting
Wore to wine tasting in Napa. Much tighter than expected I should have sized up. Was hard to button (read - a whole workout) but wore shape wear to get it closed. But really cute. I did rent again later in a larger size
Member Fit Notes
Lovesick Dress
Favorite Daughter
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 144lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Cute but runs large
So cute but runs really large in the bust (and I have a large bust!). Had to pull it up all night. Great for a summer wedding
Member Fit Notes
Merlin Dress
Shoshanna
Size Worn: 10
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 144lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Lovely
I should have kept this. Wore it to the French laundry. Light airy and still elegant. Reminded me of flamenco dance dress.
Member Fit Notes
Shireen Dress
Rixo
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 144lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Barbie vibes
Was a bit tight but I was at my heaviest when I rented this. Still looked great and I felt beautiful even though I was struggling with body image and got a ton of compliments. Was perfect for summer of Barbie
Member Fit Notes
Across Gown
ELLIATT
Size Worn: MR
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 144lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Flowy and perfect adjustable bust
My second time renting this. I just adore this dress. Great for a rehearsal dinner night in Mexico
Member Fit Notes
Quinn Dress
DELFI Collective
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 144lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Sunset vibes
I wore this in Mexico while very early pregnant with my second (about 13 ish weeks). Sized up and I’m glad I did. I got so many compliments and matched the sunset. A bit long but I’m short.
Member Fit Notes
Emmett Pleated Gown
AMUR
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 144lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
This jumpsuit is fab and I wish I kept it
You'll need a friend to help zip you up, but this is one of the best black jumpsuits I've rented. Flattering and comfortable. I wore it to Osteria Francescana in Italy, got loads of compliments, and met Massimo Bottura while wearing it, so it's absolutely fab. Rent!
Black Off The Shoulder Jumpsuit
Susana Monaco
Size Worn: 8R
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 128lbs
Bust: 34D
Loved this dress for vacation
Versatile dress for vacation and beautiful print. I got it New with tags which is always an added plus. I will say I have a fairly large chest and found this to be gaping and huge in the chest, and had to wear a cami underneath. Weird because normally reformation runs super small on me (and sometimes I have to size up to the 10). But otherwise completely adored.
Kacey Dress
Reformation
Size Worn: 8R
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 128lbs
Bust: 34D
In theory this dress is super cute but it is so unforgiving
I loved the shape (esp the flared bottom) of this dress and even the color (perfect for fall) but this dress will show every lump and bump of your body. Shapewear MAY help, but as my mom put it "even your triangle" is showing. Wear at your own risk or wear two sets of spanx. Would have loved to wear it but didn't feel like being self conscious the whole night.
Verla Midi Dress
Solace London
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 128lbs
Bust: 34D
Weird fit but fun dress
So this dress was enormous on me (so much extra fabric on the back) but small in the chest at the same time (???) where the buttons were popping open. Not sure how that's possible. It comes with a little drawstring waist making it easy to finch down and make it look not so huge. Fun print.
Navy Giraffe Print Shirt Dress
Slate & Willow
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 128lbs
Bust: 34D
It's - alright.
It's cute but wasn't expecting the back to be so open - it ties in the back so it's tough to wear any bra w this and the dress is pretty thin and has zero support. I wore this on a colder night and threw on a chunky cardigan over it, which was super cute, but idk how I would have worn this without it (bc of how exposed the back is). True to size.
Pretty Wild Mini Dress
MINKPINK
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 128lbs
Bust: 34D
Adore this dress
I adore this dress. Debating keeping it. The material is super soft and the dress is flattering (hides any problem areas) and can be worn all day. The best part - it has pockets. Perfect for work. Adore.
Classic Ponte Fiorella Dress
kate spade new york
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 128lbs
Bust: 34D
Itchiest coat ever
First off, it was enormous. I'm short and this was way too long and looked super baggy. Second, the second I touched it, it irritated my skin. I know it's wool but wow, I've never felt a coat this itchy. I couldn't wear it for more then 3 seconds. Had to send it back with the tag still on. Wish it could have worked but it just wasn't for me.
Camden Reversible Coat
Charli
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 128lbs
Bust: 34D
it's ok
it's pretty - i'll give it that. the print is different and really nice for summer. however, i will never for the life of me understand why so many of these dresses gape so crazy much in the bust, making them inappropriate for anyone with boobs (especially at work). i had to use TWO safety pins to pin this down so my boobs weren't out for everyone to see. length/sleeves are work appropriate, but beware if you have boobs. you'll have to pin it.
Member Fit Notes
Floral Faux Wrap Dress
Adrianna Papell
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
wore this for work looks like a pj
this looks like a pj when you first put it on (horrifying when i was late to work and realized i had nothing else to wear) but i belted it and dressed it up with nicer shoes/ jewelry and it's actually really fun (AND COMFY) w the sleeves. will prob rent again. was big on me. maybe i'm finally losing the weight i promised i would lose.
Member Fit Notes
Bell Sleeve Twist Front Shirt Dress
Derek Lam 10 Crosby
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Súper cute but wrinkle super easily
I loved these pants and would have bought them if they were not linen. At almost 30 years old - I still haven't figured linen out. You pretty much need to wear these only if you are planning on not sitting at all. By my first bathroom break at work, the top had completely wrinkled and looked unflattering. I so wish they didn't do this because they are so cute and comfy otherwise. In addition, because they are so thin, they will show EVERY LUMP AND BUMP on your body. This includes any shirt you want to tuck in (I couldn't get rid of the crease showing the bottom of my shirt no matter how many times I tired). I almost wore spanx but then decided I didn't care enough to be that uncomfortable in hot NYC. Wear at your own risk and I'd say this is ideal for an outing where you anticipate standing the majority of the time. Cute but not practical.
Tami Pants
Flynn Skye
Size Worn: MR
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 128lbs
Bust: 34D
So many compliments
I got a ton of compliments when I wore this to work yesterday. Pair w/ high waited pants b/c if not it'll look awkward (b/c it's sheer except for the midsection). I was tempted to buy it and didn't and now I'm regretting it slightly. Definitely recommend and a unique and happy color!
Member Fit Notes
Smocked Waist Top
Great Jones
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Super cute but runs small
This is super cute but runs small - hard to get on. I rarely if ever wear a large but had a feeling to size up with this one and I'm glad I did ( especially if you have a larger bust). I love it and am tempted to buy. May hold on to it to wear this weekend too - it's almost TOO cute for work!
Member Fit Notes
Yaya Jumpsuit
Waverly Grey
Size Worn: LR
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
i wanted to love it but too low cut
i really wanted to love this dress. it's super cute, an adorable color. however, it was way too low cut for me, to the point that you would see my bra if i bent over, leaving nothing to the imagination. i'm a 34D so these things tend to be harder for me but if you have a smaller chest/ aren't made uncomfortable by people staring at your chest then maybe it's for you.
Member Fit Notes
Clementine Bonne Mini Dress
Auguste
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
runs huge
very baggy and then short in the front. would make a good cover up. i wore it to work when no one was around, wasn't very flattering. but summery enough/the color of the season
Member Fit Notes
Mustard Floral Top
Louna
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
This dress is enormous
Runs large is an understatement. I couldn't even cinch the dress down and there were at least 6 inches of fabric that stuck out from the side of my rib. I'm not sure what kind of sizing this is but I'm pretty for it's for a giant. I sized down based off the other reviews to a small (2-4) but it hon early fit me like something sized 14. I'm between a 6-8. I would need an XXS in this to make it work. Unbelievable sizing
Cinched Midi Dress
Co
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 128lbs
Bust: 34D
LOVE THIS
I feel fabulous in this jumpsuit. It's comfy and flattering and works well on a petite (which is tough!). Can wear for work (I'm wearing it with a blazer and sneakers - looks fab) and for brunch on the weekend. I may end up purchasing. I'm between a 6 and an 8 and the 8 fit me perfectly. I didn't experience the too large on top issue others mentioned (I'm a 34D) and didn't experience it being too tight on the butt / thighs (and I usually have this issue). Rent it!
Member Fit Notes
Avery Jumpsuit
cupcakes and cashmere
Size Worn: 8R
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
I forgot what real jeans felt like
These are TRUE jeans. As in 0 stretch, as other reviews have mentioned. I forgot what that's felt like because I've been wearing jeans with stretch for like 15 years now! The pros: the color is great and perfect for spring, I love the high waist. The cons: These are a straight fit and they are baggy around the ankles. Not flattering for petites/short girls. The thighs were too tight for me and I could barely walk (but the jeans did stretch out throughout the day) but the waist was too large. I probably won't rent these again. I wish RTR had more petite sizes!
Member Fit Notes
Yellow Riley Jeans
AGOLDE
Size Worn: 28R
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
LOVE THIS DRESS
I would have bought it if it weren't so expensive. Definitely renting again, runs a teensy bit large (I'm between a 6 and an 8 and usually get 8' to be safe, but I prob could have gotten away with a 6). The straps are long and not adjustable, but I pinned them down with safety pins (as I often do). LOVED IT.
Member Fit Notes
Black Camille Midi Dress
Rachel Zoe
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Wanted to love it but too big for me!
I'm in between a size 6 and 8, and usually get an 8 to be safe (bc there are so many brands on here that urn so small). Unfortunately this was huge everywhere and looked like a tent on me so I might try again next time with a smaller size. Other than that super cute :)
Member Fit Notes
Eyelet Gingham Dress
Draper James
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Runs TTS
I often size up to be safe, and this was a little big on me. Should have gotten my regular size. Other than that super comfy and flowy. I would have bought it.
Member Fit Notes
Stargazer Asymmetric Skirt
Tory Burch
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
runs huge
This was enormous. I think I found it on a wear to work list, and the top button on this basically hit my belly button. Comfy, but the waist is constantly falling down and just looks weird. Size down.
Member Fit Notes
Black Leaf Print Jumpsuit
N Natori
Size Worn: MR
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Small and no stretch
Lol. Holy crap these are small. I normally wear size 4 jeans/pants and I could not get these over my thighs or close. I rented equivalent size 6. Think I would need at least an 8 if not a 10. If you have any butt or thighs beware. No stretch whatsoever. Wish they worked because the color and style were super cute
Member Fit Notes
Auburn Flared Jeans
See by Chloé
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Laughably small again
I could not get this to close on me and I'm a true size medium - I thought the top would be stretchy enough but it's not and there was a gap of about ten inches so there was no way this was closing. If you have any boobs at all size way up
Fillmore Dress
Amanda Uprichard
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 34D
Ugh. I'm short and the torso is too short on this.
I'm 5'1" and this was laughably short on me - it's not like I have a long torso either. My boobs are basically popping out of the top too and holy camel toe. (And it's digging in my butt too). Wish it could work because it's comfy - I'm gonna wear it with something on top because I don't have anything else to wear today but beware lol. I don't even think sizing up will fix how short the torso is.
Member Fit Notes
Justine Crinkle Jumpsuit
Flynn Skye
Size Worn: MR
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 1"
Weight: 138lbs
Bust: 36DDD/E
Liked them so much I bought them
I'm using RTR now to buy myself pants basically. These fit the bill. At first I thought they were too small for my thighs but they stretch. Sits higher on the waist which I love and are super soft. Also love the color. Darker than gray but lighter than black.
Grey High Rise Skinny Jeans
Mott & Bow
Size Worn: 28
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 1"
Bust: 34D
Wore for a casual day at work
Very soft. Not the most flattering because it's pretty body but I expected that. The print is cute. Would rent again.
Electric Love Sweatshirt
Wildfox
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 1"
Bust: 34D
Great work dress, professional and cool at the same time
Wish I could have kept it. Runs slightly small but not so much so that I couldn't wear it. I also feel like it helped smooth me out in the midsection which was an added perk. Great for a meeting!
Caviar Peyton Dress
John + Jenn
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 1"
Bust: 34D