Caitlin 's Reviews
All reviews by Caitlin
TOP CONTRIBUTORTOP CONTRIBUTOR
26 reviews
Gorgeous, stand out dress but runs VERY small
I rented this dress for a fall wedding and absolutely loved it. I got compliments all night and felt incredible in it - the colors are vibrant, the style is very flattering. However this dress runs insanely small! I am normally an 8-10 and after reading the reviews I went with the large. Somehow I was able to wear it but It barely zipped and required my poor husband to help. There is zero stretch and the bust runs really small and has some padding so I would not recommend if you're bustier.
Member Fit Notes

Alicia Midi Dress
Bronx Banco
Size Worn: LR
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Loved them so much I bought them!
These pants are fantastic! Very comfortable and flattering and easy to style for both work and the weekend. I'm normally an 8 in pants and after reading reviews sized down and got the 6. But the pants are quite stretchy to begin with and stretch quite a bit throughout the day so I bought the 4 and they are perfect. I'm short at 5'2" and they hit below mid-calf which I really like. Would totally recommend!

Camel Tailored Pants
Trina Turk
Size Worn: 6
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Flattering light summer dress!
I rented this dress for Easter and it could not have been more perfect for a sunny spring daytime event. It was pretty easy to wear and the perfect length for a maxi fit for my height. It was a pretty straight fit and had zero stretch, which I was nervous about since I have an hourglass figure but with the farting and skirt shape it was really flattering! A little tight across the chest so I would not recommend for super busty women. I also was prepared for the straps after reading reviews that said they were not adjustable - it's a simple fix with dress tape! I had no problem just taping the excess strap on the inside of the back of the dress!

Diana Maxi
Mara Hoffman
Size Worn: SR
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Probably my favorite piece I've ever rented
I wore this so many times - I absolutely loved it! Before I even looked in the mirror after trying it on I knew I wanted to keep it. It's so well made, beautifully constructed and amazingly comfortable. It also felt incredibly versatile. Although the top was a little big on my frame it fit my butt and hips really well and the elastic waist kept everything in place. Since I'm short it fell to a few inches above my ankles but with heels looked great. An absolute favorite overall.

Chrysanthemum Jumpsuit
VINCE.
Size Worn: SR
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Lightweight and stand out piece!
I rented this for my husbands MBA graduation and it was perfect for an all day outdoor event in May. The material is thick enough to keep everything smooth but it's cotton and lightweight enough for summer. There is zero stretch and it fits true to size. There is also boning in the rib cage so beware if you are larger chested. I'm short and the length hit a few inches above my ankles which was fine with heels. Overall absolutely loved it!

White Sweetheart Cropped Jumpsuit
Greylin
Size Worn: SR
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Effortless and versatile!
One of the easiest dresses to wear! It can be dressed up or down and is very flattering. I usually don't wear shapeless dresses but this was very comfy and looked great for several different occasions. It was a little short on me (5'2") than what I usually wear but wasn't inappropriate and the top fit great on my smaller shoulders. Would definitely rent again.

Robe Cocea Dress
ba&sh
Size Worn: 1
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Flattering and perfect for shorties!
This was a super fun jumpsuit I wore to a black tie optional wedding. Very flattering and well made. The fabric is very stretchy which made it easy to dance in. Bonus was that it was the perfect length for me with 3" heels, I did not have to use any fashion tape to temporarily alter it! Would definitely rent again!

Blue One Shoulder Jumpsuit
Christian Siriano
Size Worn: 8R
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Standout gorgeous quality dress!
I loved this dress! It was perfect for a black tie wedding reception and really stood out. Very flattering on my short curvy body, with the waist hitting just right. As others have said the arms are a little tight but I could still dance and move comfortably. I'm familiar with Marchesa fit and sizing and knowing the dress had 0 stretch I went up to an 8 (usually a 6) and it fit perfectly around my hips. Also the length was perfect for me as I wanted it to be a full length gown and it hit at my ankles.

Red Floral Lace Dress
Marchesa Notte
Size Worn: 8R
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Most unflattering pants I've tried
These jeans were just awful. Very small across the hips and over the thighs and ZERO stretch. They're high waisted but with no give in the hips, they're really uncomfortable.

Coal Cigarette Jeans
rag & bone JEAN
Size Worn: 29
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Easy, comfortable top
I loved wearing this versatile top! Very comfortable and easy to wear casually but looks a little nicer for work too. I loved how baggy it fit - very boxy and long in the back. I have narrow shoulders and am quite petite so the neck was a little rounder than I prefer but it was still a great everyday piece.

Margaret Sweater
Mara Hoffman
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Comfortable, fun top
This top was so comfortable to wear, easy to pair with staples, and a great option for day to night. Great step up from a basic top.

Scenic Road Top
devlin
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Fun and unique dress!
I wore this to a formal party and could not have loved it more! Ran a little large so I went with the smaller of my two rentals. Because of my height and short torso, the neckline was a bit low for me but easily fixable with dress tape. The shape was incredibly flattering and there is no stretch in the fabric. Would rent again!

White Floral Lace Ruffle Dress
Nicole Miller
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Lovely spring dress
I rented this for Easter with family and loved it! I was able to wear a 4 but could not wear a bra with it. There is zero stretch to the fabric but it's very comfortable and runs a bit large. Length was a bit long on me but I'm short! Overall it was a great choice for a spring family occasion!

Ivory Petals Dress
BB Dakota
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
One of my favorite rentals in years!
This was by far one of my favorite items I've ever worn to an event (rented or bought!). Incredibly flattering (I'm very short so sometimes jumpsuits don't hit me right waist-down) and very comfortable. The material has a lot of stretch to it and runs true to size. I had to use some hem tape for the length but everything else fit great and I could even wear a regular bra. I would HIGHLY recommend this piece for any cocktail or formal function!

Hunter Jumpsuit
Donna Morgan
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Flattering show-stopper!
This dress was so fun and easy to wear - overall very flattering! The fabric was very good quality but there is zero stretch to it. Fit was true to size but a little on the shorter size. I have smaller shoulders so the top was a little roomy but not noticeable. Overall I would highly recommend

ZigZag Leona Dress
Parker
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Fun color and perfect for dancing!
I wore this to a black tie wedding and absolutely loved it! The neckline is deep and I couldn't wear a bra but had tape that worked perfectly. The neckline also has wire in the v so it maintains structure. I'm petite and was a little worried that the straps would be too long but it was fine. The bottom is fun and flirty and perfect for dancing all night. Overall I would absolutely recommend!

Havana Dress
allison parris
Size Worn: 4
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Fun and easy to wear!
I wore this to a cocktail attire wedding and it was perfect! Very different and I received compliments all night. I'm 5'2" and wore 3" heels and had to temporarily hem the bottom inch of the pants. The material is thinner than I was expecting but easy to move around in. Overall I would definitely recommend!

Pamela Jumpsuit
Trina Turk
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Effortlessly show stopping!
This dress is so easy to wear and unbelievably gorgeous! The color is bright like it appears online and incredibly flattering. There is boning in the top half so it maintains structure. I'm 5'2" and wore 4" heels and the bottom skimmed the floor and I didn't have to tape it, luckily! The 8 was the only size available and was a bit big so I think the 6 would have been perfect but overall it ran small. I would definitely recommend!

Bonbon Gown
BCBGMAXAZRIA
Size Worn: 8P
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Perfect dress!
I rented this dress for a homecoming day event and could not have loved it more! I received so many compliments on it! The material was a fairly thick cotton and perfect for an outdoor day event in October in the south. Because it was fall and the dress is BRIGHT I wore black wedges and a black blazer to make it more seasonally appropriate and it could not have been a more perfect pick for such a fun day! It was a little tight around the chest but worked for me and hit just above my knee. The dress I received had a tear between the zipper and the fabric which caused a big problem on the day of because it would not zip. Fortunately my friends were able to maneuver it to fit and I reported it to RTR, who were so accommodating as usual! Overall would wear this dress again in a heartbeat!
Member Fit Notes

Ikat Wait to Dance Dress
MSGM
Size Worn: 42
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Perfect dress for an outdoor event!
I rented this for my college's annual homecoming event and it could not have been more perfect! It was a little short but was still fine since it has an A-line skirt. The fabric is all cotton so there is not a lot of stretch to it. One small problem that I did not foresee is that the dress is completely eyelet with not shell underneath so definitely be prepared with a camisole just in case. Overall I would definitely recommend this dress to someone.
Member Fit Notes
Against Playground Rules Dress
Opening Ceremony
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Perfect classy look!
I absolutely adored this dress! It was classic silhouette and very simple. The material has some stretch to it and is fairly thick but was not too hot for an outdoor, summer wedding. The length was great, hitting just above my knees. The back was a little large on my petit frame but because I went with the smaller size it wasn't too bad. Overall I would definitely recommend this dress!
Member Fit Notes

Derby Girl Dress
Lilly Pulitzer
Size Worn: 4
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Another win from RTR!
This dress is a fun dress, perfect for semi-casual/party events. It wasn't too long for me which was nice however the back did gap a little on my petit frame. Overall super comfy and fun and I would definitely recommend!
Member Fit Notes

Neon Lace Party Dress
Cut 25
Size Worn: 4
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Great dress, unable to wear
I rented this dress for a reunion party and was really excited about it. Unfortunately I could not wear it to the event because it was too big on top. I am short with a very petit frame so the material on top where it clasps at the neck was too wide for me and there was too much material for it to fit and stay clasped. It's a great dress but if you have narrow shoulders/ a small frame like me, I would try an alternative.
Member Fit Notes

Now We're Colorblocking Dress
camilla and marc
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Pretty cute but hard to wear.
I rented this for an event much to casual for the dress and ended up not wearing it. The dress pretty very different looking in person. The picture makes the dress look orange-ey/coral however the dress is actually a deep, crimson red and the beading was a lot darker. The material was a chiffon over a stiff, silk material and thus did not give at all so you definitely need to have the right size. Overall pretty but very different than what the picture looks like.
Member Fit Notes
Magic Carpet Ride Dress
Shoshanna
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Beautiful color and fit for the dress and the earrings looked perfect with it!
I wore this outfit for my boyfriend's Christmas formal and it was absolutely perfect! The dress hugged every inch of my figure perfectly and highlighted my hourglass figure. It definitely runs true to size, do not expect it to stretch- the fabric is pretty thick and keeps everything together but definitely will not work if it's too small. The color is gorgeous, and looks just as it does in the picture. I'm very short and the length was perfect, I also have an hourglass figure and definitely recommend it for someone who is also that shape. The look is sophisticated and classic and I would definitely recommend renting this dress. Bonus: the earrings looked perfect with it and completed the look!
Member Fit Notes

Neatly Polished Dress
Tracy Reese
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D
Disappointing and not like pic
I was really excited to get this dress for a sorority formal, themed "Mad Men." The dress however was quite a disappointment upon its arrival. The dress looked frumpy-especially the bow, which was significantly smaller in person. The neckline was not particularly flattering on me (I am short with semi-broad shoulders) and the top fit incredibly small on my top half. The material is really pretty though I just think it fits more differently than it is advertised.
Member Fit Notes
Prim and Proper Bow Dress
Milly
Size Worn: 6
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 2"
Bust: 34D