Hilary's Reviews
All reviews by Hilary
TOP CONTRIBUTORTOP CONTRIBUTOR
24 reviews
Awkward fit on curves
As a size 6-8 waist and 12 hips/thighs, these pants in size 12 hit adequately at the hips but were a little snug across the front of the thigh, which created a significant pooch when paired with the too-loose waistband - and low riding this type of silhouette just didn't work. Loved the material. Cute pants but not manageable on curves! A little short on 6' height but doable.
Elliot Pleat Pants
Parker
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 6
Height: 6' 0"
Weight: 175lbs
Bust: 34B
Nice material
I usually wear size 10 jeans, but having an extra curvy season and considering these jeans are over 90% cotton (meaning less stretch) I sized up. Good move - they fit me perfectly. The print and cut aren't the most flattering on my shape but whatever. These run short on me at 6' as expected; hem seems very slightly bootcut. Nice quality textile and a fun print - would order again in the same size.
Ocelot Ines Jeans
La Vie Rebecca Taylor
Size Worn: 31
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Fun with a retro feel
The chunky denim details paired with cream tweed featuring red and navy yarns had a definite 50s feel to me and reminded me of my Grandma in the best way (she was super classy). Loved wearing this piece to work where it was tidy enough to pull off as a blazer alternative. Lining is comfortable.
Contrast Trim Denim Jacket
Derek Lam 10 Crosby
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Awful against skin
Great looking, effortless blouse - received compliments, but the material was so uncomfortable against my skin on the unlined arms and at the neck. It was so scratchy I had a red mark on my neck all day that definitely wasn't flattering! Won't rent again. Would recommend wearing with long sleeved shirt underneath.
Winter Floral Knot Blouse
Jason Wu
Size Worn: 6
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Excellent textile but gaped at armholes
This top gaped significantly at the armholes on me, and felt like it was choking me a little too - but this might be due to my longer torso length. I did notice some gaping on shorter women in their review photos though. Regardless, the material is of excellent quality and the peplum hangs beautifully, true to the photo. Wouldn't rent again due to the all-day grip around my throat, but it looked great with a short navy blazer covering the side gaps above my bust.
Member Fit Notes
Twilight Floral Flare Top
Milly
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 6
Height: 6' 0"
Weight: 157lbs
Bust: 34B
Classy statement
This was an "impulse buy" when I went in to RTR to return items - it made such a statement just sitting on the shelf! Sturdy/quality construction and I received compliments on it. My wrist is about 6.75" around and I'd say that on any larger sizes it will be less flattering - the cuff just fit me without any bulging but was tight enough to stick to my skin/leave a slight mark. Would rent again.
Green Raised Logo Cuff
Tory Burch Accessories
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Not for hourglass
So gorgeous. Definitely did not fit my curves! Loved the quality of the details including the patterned front flap underside. Large was 3x too big in the waist and 1x too small in the hips on me, but this should fit more standard/straight figures beautifully. Wish I could wear it!
Red Plaid Button Skirt
Scotch & Soda
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Great quality
Loved the cut of the top half and the thickness of this knit dress, which had a quality feel to it. The Medium fit my hourglass without issue so curvier hips and pregnant wearers might find this to be a good option. The large would've been roomier for me but I didn't want to lose my waistline in the dress. At 6' with a 34" inseam this dress came to right above my knees and did restrict long strides due to the lack of a slit.
Striped Ottoman Dress
Milly
Size Worn: MR
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Dove grey with rose gold lurex
Cute sweater with cool-grey detailing at the collar and cuffs and a warm-grey body with rose gold lurex throughout the knit, resulting in a top that looks greyish-mauvey-roseish but not particularly "pink." For me it was a great piece to layer under a blazer at work to jazz things up, although I would've worn it solo as well. It does have sparkle. Due to the lurex it wasn't a little too itchy against my skin, and because of that I probably wouldn't rent again.
Fine Gauge Crewneck
White + Warren
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Love it, but short on the sides
Gorgeous blouse for work. Too short on the sides by about 2" on me - tucked in, I had a 1" gap on each side so I fudged it by wearing the back untucked and covering with a blazer. In spite of the fit issue on long torsos I'd rent again because the textile was beautiful and an unusual color to find in garments (leafy green is true to product images). Classy.
Plant Print Top
Tara Jarmon
Size Worn: 38
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Another fun Ben Amun plated piece
Fun florid links on this multicolored bracelet in harvest colors - denim blue, russet, golden topaz, bluish grey and champagne colored glass stones make this a great autumn-winter choice. Get it while it's fresh - this is a plated piece so the finish won't last forever, and the glass stones will show scuffs in time. Quality is on-par with other Ben Amun jewelry.
Multi Gem Bracelet
Ben-Amun
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Love
Big and bold! Surface finish is not as nice looking as in the RTR product photo but this is still an awesome piece.
Royal Charm Necklace
Ben-Amun
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Soft and comfortable, a little boring
This was just an "easy" jacket to wear to work - soft fabric, neutral colors, good pockets etc. That said it felt a little boring overall. I wouldn't hesitate to wear it again, but don't expect any wow-factor - this is more like an "every day, whatever" sort of piece.
Donnie Jacket
DREW
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Straight fit between waist and hips
I have hourglass waist and hips, and don't recommend this for that type of figure. As many have stated it runs large - in the waist. I sized down one size to better fit my waist and wound up without enough width for my hips, which caused pulling at the interior button and resulted a large crease/fold across my front and an awkward hang to the fabric. It's a soft material that could use a stiffer interfacing at the interior button and exterior metal O to help avoid the creasing problem on curvier hips. I might try again sizing up to my original size, and wearing this off my hips instead of trying to fit it as shown on the model. I'd recommend sticking with your original size if you have curves - if you have a straighter waist and hips, then you definitely might prefer sizing down. I'd love to know what size the model is wearing, and her measurements.
Houndstooth Maya Skirt
Tanya Taylor
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Nice color, a little inconvenient to use
I loved the weave! Due to the design of the straps, I found this tote a little obnoxious to use because they were always in the way when I needed to put larger items in the bag. When empty, if I carried it on my shoulder, the dirty/more-worn bottom surface would fold outwards which didn't look good. I still think this is a fun bag but for me I need something that works with a more fast-paced commuter lifestyle, and I wouldn't file this in that category. I think if you mostly drive around and plan on using this bag casually, and only need to carry it to/fro on your arm, that would be ideal. Note that there are two different red tones between the straps and the weave.
Red Woven Teller Tote
Elizabeth and James Accessories
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Cute and fun
I wore a long black blazer over this which toned it down a bit, but would've worn it without as well. The size 42 fit me well (usually wear a S or M top, 34-35b). Due to the boxy design and arms/sides silhouette, I recommend this for ladies who have well-toned arms for the most flattering look. Also, beware that since this is a woven cotton textile, it's prone to wrinkling and lacks stretch. Would rent again in the same size.
Bold Stripe Blouse
Philosophy di Lorenzo Serafini
Size Worn: 42
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Cute, great for work
Loved the colors and fit on this bomber which I was able to pull off as an alternative to a blazer at work. No interior lining will make the sleeves feel itchy on bare arms. Warmer than expected given the relative thinness of the material. I wore a Medium and had room to zip it up on my S/M 34-36b torso. Size down if you want a closer fit, unless you are busty. Would rent again.
Checked Bomber Jacket
J.O.A.
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Short for a 34" inseam
I'm a size 10 jeans but I sized up hoping for more length, and a guaranteed fit on my large thighs and 42" hips (plus the drawstring is great for hourglass women). The 46R certainly did fit, but only as low-riders - no way could I wear the size as high waisted. As you can see even with low riding, these pants did not reach the floor on me. I am 6' and my length is distributed pretty evenly between legs, waist and torso. Recommend for women around 5'8" -5'9" or those with a 33-34" inseam. The more hips you have the shorter they'll look. Beware that as you size up, the flare disappears and the pants appear more wide leg. I liked the patch logo but it was distracting/detracted from the overall versatility of the pants. Might rent again in a 42.
High Waisted Flare Pants
Marni
Size Worn: 46R
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Versatile, understated, classy
This is the first RTR piece I'm considering buying: the textile has a beautiful drape and thickness and feels very high quality, and the modern silhouette is super versatile. The color matches almost all of my work blazers in addition to multicolor patterns like florals and plaids. The metallic yarns are understated and glamorous at the same time. Usually wear a S or M top, ordered an M and it fit very comfortably.
Metallic Gold The Magnitude Knit
TY-LR
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Great colors, not worth retail price
I loved the drama created by the bold color combo, filigree style and visual weight. These earrings are on the heavy side but didn't cause any issues for me. I paired them with a red lace dress and a black blazer for work. A few of the glass stones were glued on crooked, and glue was visible on the backs where they attached the post component to the earring. Just noting, not worth the original retail price considering the materials used and lack of attention to detail. Still, these looked great and I would wear them again!
Multi Stone Ingenue Earrings
Erickson Beamon
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Classy top, nice versatility
At 6' with a 34" inseam, I have a long torso so the waist on this top hit me about 2 - 2.25" higher than my natural waist. While this obscured my hourglass the peplums still created a nice silhouette. Size 8 fit me well across the shoulders but I would size down to a 6 if the waist were tall enough for me. I usually wear a Small or Medium in tops. The material has a quality feel and I love that the top looks classy alone or with a jacket over it, with skirt or pants. The simplicity of the neckline and fabric make a clean canvas for long and statement necklaces. Great piece for work.
Milagro Top
Trina Turk
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B
Gorgeous tweed, loose-fit torso
Tried on the Small in store and it looked super cute but the arms were a tad tight. Ordered the Medium, the arms fit better but the torso was then too loose/relaxed of a fit for me to pull off as work appropriate (the hood was already pushing the limit). Size down if you want a closer/neater fit and don't have athletic/bigger upper arms. Otherwise true to size. The tweed has a nice sparkle and the buttons catch the light as well - looks better in real life than in the product photos. Quality issue: the Small in store had loose buttons, and the Medium I received (with tags still on) had the upper button completely falling off (dangling on 2" of thread).
Member Fit Notes
Hooded Crop Tweed Jacket
Line + Dot
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 6
Height: 6' 0"
Weight: 157lbs
Bust: 34B
Not for tall ladies
The slit is so high in the back! Admittedly I am 6' but usually can make things work with stockings. In this case I was unable to wear a slip due to the high slit, which came *exactly* to my butt cheeks (entirely inappropriate for work). Inseam 34, hips 41, waist 27, 34b. The Medium fit although I can't recommend for hippier hourglass figures since the waist becomes obscured. Love the Claire Underwood neckline! Returned without wearing.
Member Fit Notes
Black Military Sheath
Alexia Admor
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 6
Height: 6' 0"
Weight: 157lbs
Bust: 34B
Unflattering for tall hourglass
Loved how soft this was. The undersides of the arms have black fabric which doesn't show in the product photos very well. On my 6' hippy frame, this coat just didn't do me any favors - the yellow fur hit right at my widest and added visual bulk to an extreme. I'd recommend this for straighter figures, or more standard heights where the yellow fur should hit just below the hips. While the sleeve length was ok and size 12 fit (usually wear a S/M top and size 10/L bottoms) I didn't wear it!
Ona Faux Fur Patchwork Coat
Osman
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 8
Height: 6' 0"
Bust: 34B