Amy's Reviews
All reviews by Amy
TOP CONTRIBUTORTOP CONTRIBUTOR
131 reviews
Another Antonoff winner!
Great breathable and soft fabric, generously true to size. Size down if you want more of a baby tee Y2K look. There's a pink ruffle seam down the front matching the sleeves/hem that I didn't notice in the pictures.
Skye Mesh Top
Rachel Antonoff
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Bottom was a little tighter than I expected
Not super flattering with the pants, but an easy and elegant look. Not a particularly youthful look
Chambray Mix Stevie Tank Top
NIC + ZOE
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Comfy and light
Ellis Trouser
NIC + ZOE
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Too big to wear
I love Le Jean - bought a pair of their barrels through RTR - but these were too huge to wear. Like, I felt like a little kid wearing my mom’s pants. Size down x2 and I bet these would be very comfortable and chic.
Member Fit Notes
Jude Denim Trouser
LE JEAN
Size Worn: 30
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Lightweight!
This felt like I was barely wearing anything - in a good way! I accidentally sized up, and it was pretty loose, but the shape made it still wearable. Ruffles took a lot of ironing, but would’ve still been okay out of the bag for a more casual atmosphere.
Member Fit Notes
Aira Top
Veronica Beard
Size Worn: 10
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Feels EXPENSIVE but thicker than I thought
This is fully lined with the white poplin you see peeking out. Make it much thicker overall than I anticipated but it feels and looks so luxurious.
Member Fit Notes
Coastal Cashmere Dual Sided Mixed Media Vest Top
NAADAM
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Weirdly flattering??
These are very big but the waist/hips are somehow flattering? It was tough to cinch the bottoms like other reviews warned - but if you pull really hard, scrunch like you’re trying to thread a hoodie lace back in, and then tie a knot outside of the toggle, it works. I’d have bought these if they were at more of a clearance price.
Member Fit Notes
James Cargo Pants
Toccin
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Beware the slip’s odd fit
This was super flattering, fit like a glove, but I could not get the slip to lay flat, so it looked messy. Worked for a derby party since it was sort of a costume, but wouldn’t wear it to an actual dressy event.
Member Fit Notes
Floral Embroidered Puff Sleeve Dress
Marchesa Notte
Size Worn: 8R
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Comfortable!
I was worried this would be too old-lady frumpy. Definitely a loose fit but the sleeves helped make it chic - and they are short enough not to get in the way. Straps on the camisole are very thin, but a regular nude bra wasn’t noticeable because the holes in the lace aren’t very big.
Member Fit Notes
Smolder Top
Trina Turk
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
High fashion trad wife?
I loved this so much! Super lightweight and oddly flattering. Pockets! Wore with flat leopard gladiator sandals and felt super chic and comfortable.
Member Fit Notes
Laurel Dress
Hofmann Copenhagen
Size Worn: 40
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
I bought them!
I wish these came in other colors!!! They are so lightweight and baggy - but not HUGE like a lot of pants are these days. Wore these on 80+ degree days and was still comfortable.
Member Fit Notes
Bowie Barrel Pant
Joe's Jeans
Size Worn: 29
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Another adorable Rachel Antonoff piece!
I rented the banana split version of this a few times and this one didn’t disappoint. The color is like a bright lemon - not neon but still eye catching. TTS with just enough slouch but not oversized. Size down if you’re looking for something more fitted.
Member Fit Notes
Sardine Polo Sweater
Rachel Antonoff
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Almost bought them!
This is a very chic fit: barrel-ish but not too trendy or any bells and whistles (barrels sometimes have those really obvious dart seams). Medium thickness on the fabric, but still very soft. I came really close to buying but ultimately decided I didn’t love the length. They are meant to be above the ankle, but because I’m on the short side, it was an awkwardly in-between length.
Member Fit Notes
Lexi Mid Rise Bowed Straight Jeans
PISTOLA
Size Worn: 29
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Runs SMALL weird zipper
This was so small it was unwearable. And there's an invisible zipper up the back, which is a bizarre place with the pockets
Knack Pants
Staud
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
True to size
The bow was a bit much, I was able to cross it and then tie that in the back like a belt - just barely getting a knot though. Much more flattering and easier to layer
Royal Sea Midi Dress
FARM Rio
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
CUTE lightweight
I wouldn't say this is super soft, but it was comfortable and cute. Beware teachers: it says "67" all over it...
Embroidered Oversized Crewneck Sweater
The Great.
Size Worn: 1
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Very chic, comfortable
Cropped! I wore a tank top tucked into my pants, so you couldn't see it when I was standing, but I didn't flash any belly when reaching or sitting. Felt very chic in just black ponte pants and black sneakers
Gingham Emery Top
Alexia Admor
Size Worn: 10
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Fine - not flattering
501 90's Light Wash Featherweight Jeans
Levi's
Size Worn: 30
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Thick, but not too thick
Warm and cute!
Member Fit Notes
Navy Escargot Sweater
Terez
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 34DD
Gorgeous
I really liked wearing this. I was worried the cape would look/feel weird, but it didn’t! My only note is this would’ve been a perfect candidate for pockets, but alas there are none. If you are picky about snug necklines, this might be a little claustrophobic, but it didn’t bother me significantly.
Member Fit Notes
Lula Mini Dress
Sea New York
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
A little small but not crazy
These are a very lightweight fabric and would be see through, but they are lined with a similar fabric. Took a lot of ironing, but I liked wearing them. Wore once with a white tank top, and once as a pool coverup.
Member Fit Notes
Cartagena Skort
Ro's Garden
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Sooo soft and weirdly flattering
I bought these in a dark color from RTR, so gave these a whirl. They are just as fab! Size down (I’m normally a 29/30, bought the 28s in the darker color, rented these in 29 and they were a little too big, but wearable)
Member Fit Notes
Utility Soft Barrel Jeans
LE JEAN
Size Worn: 29
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Like an old favorite worn in sweatshirt
I wore this on a beach vacation and it was great for lounging around. It’s not fuzzy on the inside, so it’s much lighter weight than a regular sweatshirt. It’s very worn in - designed to feel like your favorite old sweatshirt - so don’t get this if you’re looking for something crisp!
Member Fit Notes
Harvey Signature Sweatshirt
Anine Bing
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Long waisted
I am very short waisted so this was a little long waisted for me, but it was still cute. Straps are adjustable via hidden buttons in the back - I wound up crisscrossing the straps and felt much more secure in it.
Member Fit Notes
Dixon Dress
Marie Oliver
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Odd fit
It’s lightweight and beautifully made but the fit is odd, even with all the ties and ways to adjust it. It’s very wide, especially at the bust. I wore it once but was tugging at it the whole time.
Member Fit Notes
Paisley Top
Hunter Bell
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Glamour!!!
This is what you’re wearing when the police come to your mansion to tell you your much older husband has died under mysterious circumstances! Please rent this, you will not be disappointed.
Member Fit Notes
Kristen Cover Up
Ramy Brook
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Cute!! Unflattering length on me
First of all, the pockets are amazing. They aren’t huge but they don’t sag when you put stuff in them. Fit my iPhone nicely without ruining the silhouette. This is probably more personal, but the length hit about 2 inches above my knee, which is a historically bad/frumpy length for me (needs to be shorter or longer). If you know what I mean, then skip this. If you don’t, definitely go for it!!
Member Fit Notes
Lola Shift Dress
Rachel Antonoff
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Print looks like your artsy Boomer aunt
I thought this would be a cooler tattoo-ish print (based on the evil eye) but it was kind of just something my artsy Boomer aunt would wear - no edge to it at all. Fit was good, not too tight and fabric felt nice.
Member Fit Notes
Nina Top Summer Convo
AFRM
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Not for wider middles
The fabric was yummy on this, and it’s TTS, but it was not flattering on my belly. Everything else was appropriately body skimming but then tight in the middle. I imagined this as a very fancy swim coverup but didn’t end up wearing.
Member Fit Notes
Samira Dress
ASTR the Label
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
I thought meh, but got lots of compliments!
I didn’t think this was particularly special, but I got a ton of compliments on it. Who knew?!
Member Fit Notes
Yellow Gingham Top
Slate & Willow
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Kind of hated at first, but ended up wearing a lot!
These felt too wide at first, but they grew on me. Skper comfortable and I wore them a lot.
Member Fit Notes
Light Blue Parker Long Shorts
AGOLDE
Size Worn: 29
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Buttons gapped
This is beautiful and has a nice weight to it, but the buttons right at my waist gapped - and there wasn’t a good way to pin it. NOT for short waisted girlies.
Member Fit Notes
Embroidered Ruffled Maxi Dress
Maje
Size Worn: 40
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
COMFY elevated casual
I just wore this around casually and felt very cool! “Oh this old thing?” Not flattering in the least, but that’s not the point.
Member Fit Notes
Striped Cotton Mini Dress
Moschino Jeans
Size Worn: 46
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Glad I got my regular size
First time I rented, I sized down based on reviews. It fit, and I wore it, but it felt too small. Got it again in my usual size and it was perfect. It’s meant to be a little slouchy!
Member Fit Notes
Split Sleeveless Polo
Rachel Antonoff
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Nice fit, didn’t love the neckline
I’m not usually a bodycon gal (I hold my weight in my belly) but this smoothed me out! I wound up wearing another dress because I didn’t love the neckline on this - it made my cleavage look weird. But overall very flattering fit!
Member Fit Notes
Sloane Sequin Dress
Dress The Population
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Finest and Funnest!
Went to a wedding where the dress code was “Wear Your Finest and Funnest”. I paired this with bright orange pumps and the Staud citron clutch from RTR. Compliments galore. I will say that the very top is a little loose (and I have a chest!) but the inner corset kept it up. I tried a size down too and the chest fit better but the corset was a little too tight. Pro tip: the zipper on the corset is not traditional. Fully unzip and zip it on the hanger before trying on so you know what you’re working with.
Member Fit Notes
Mira Sequins Dress
ML Monique Lhuillier
Size Worn: 10
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
It’s giving Trad Wife
It’s a beautiful dress - I rented it for my niece’s bat mitzvah but wound up going with another dress. It’s pretty, but I had a hard time styling it to make it a little more cool/modern.
Member Fit Notes
Boyd Dress
L.K. Bennett
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
Stretchy and comfy
Member Fit Notes
Denim Giselle Jumpsuit
FAHERTY BRAND
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
So comfy!!!
These run a little big - I got the 29 which is generally my size. It’s meant to be a baggy fit but this was just a little too big in the waist - but I wore them anyway! I ordered the 28 and they are perfect. I’ve worn them a zillion times and I do not plan on sending them back any time soon!
Member Fit Notes
Utility Barrel Jeans
LE JEAN
Size Worn: 29
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD
TINY
Do not get this unless you can size up.
Member Fit Notes
Rueda Jumpsuit
GAUGE81
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 34DD