Melanie 's Reviews
All reviews by Melanie
TOP CONTRIBUTORTOP CONTRIBUTOR
80 reviews
Uncomfortable
Unfortunately this was very uncomfortable. The embroidery and material of the shirt is scratchy. Feels costume-y. I am normally a 6/8 or medium/large and sized down to the 36 (4) which was oversized but probably the right fit for the style. Did not wear
Member Fit Notes
Madelyn Top
Hofmann Copenhagen
Size Worn: 36
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 160lbs
Bust: 36DD
Saggy crotch, no flexibility
If you like a flexible denim with some stretch, these are not the jean for you. Stiff, tight through the thighs and crotch, but loose in the waist so it lends to having saggy crotch and constantly trying to pull them up. Their redeeming quality is the cut - a great slim straight fit and I loved the frayed hem. I sided up 2 sizes. Typically a 29, rented a 31. 5 mo pp and 160#
Member Fit Notes
Icon Fit Jeans
Levi's
Size Worn: 31R
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 160lbs
Bust: 36DD
Three seasons dress!
Such a versatile dress! Almost missed that it was corduroy before renting but that was a pleasant surprise! I wore for church on Christmas Eve so the texture was a nice added touch that made it feel a little more elevated. Would be easy to wear through fall, winter, and spring. Pockets, kind of nursing friendly (buttons are small but functional!), and super versatile! Sleeves were a little puffier than expected but not enough to knock it for that!
Member Fit Notes
The Bonnet Dress
The Great.
Size Worn: 2
Usual Size: 8
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 160lbs
Bust: 36DD
Perfect travel jacket!
Lightweight, packable, perfect for airport travel and layering! Wore it on a trip to Maine in mid September (lows 60s) and it would have easily carried me through the fall season. I’m between a small and medium right now, went with the small, and the sleeves were a tad short. Didn’t keep me from wearing but it did keep me from purchasing. Great color for a HOC autumn too.
Member Fit Notes
Packable Quilted Jacket
Madewell
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 32DD
Honeymoonin
An all-time favorite rental! Small wasn't available so I got the XS and it fit everywhere except it was a little tight in the elastic around the arms! Would love to rent again. Great vacation dress.
Member Fit Notes
Vintage Floral Maxi
FARM Rio
Size Worn: XSR
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 32D
Didn't want to send this one back
Wore this multiple times throughout the month. So light and breezy. Perfect for a second trimester bump. I sized up to a 6 at 24 weeks & 150# (pre-preg 130# and size 2-4). Unlined and requires a strapless bra, but great throw on dress over a swimsuit or to wear around. Easy to dress up.
Member Fit Notes
Nissi Tiers Dress
Apiece Apart
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 150lbs
Bust: 32DD
Wish I could keep it!
One of my all-time favorite rentals! Wore this early on in my second trimester and it was perfect for a growing bump - I had plenty of room. Lined, easy to throw on, beautiful detailing! Perfect for spring or summer. Would love to rent again!
Member Fit Notes
Jeanne Shift
Hofmann Copenhagen
Size Worn: 36R
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 150lbs
Bust: 32DD
Disappointing
Unlined and super light weight - would be best for a swim cover up and not a dress. Pattern and colors ended up not being for me, so it was never worn.
Member Fit Notes
Wax Poetic Garden Dress
Warm
Size Worn: 1
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 32DD
Easiest t-shirt dress ever!
I normally don't find T-shirt dresses all that flattering, but this one was a winner. It's the perfect weight - not too thin to be see through. The tie dye look is super cute and trendy, and I love the colors!
Tie Dye T-Shirt Dress
Madewell
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 128lbs
Bust: 32D
Second time renting
A bit tough to pull on over the thighs/hips, and a little big in the chest. I felt myself trying to keep it pulled up. It worked well to hide a 13 week bump but I wouldn't have worn it beyond that. Otherwise, it feels like wearing pajamas! Super comfy. No zip closure...just the buttons. Silky feeling material and the bottom half is partially lined.
Member Fit Notes
Orange Printed Jumpsuit
B Collection by Bobeau
Size Worn: SR
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 32DD
I shouldn't have sized up
I sized up to a 6 (normally a 2/4) and I think I would have been fine in a 4. It runs short but that's the style, and the body part was big on me. Pattern and colors are cute, feminine cut, versatile (work, date, dinner, etc.) and luxe material!! Zipper is on the side!
Floral V-Neck Top
Jill Jill Stuart
Size Worn: 6
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 32D
It grew on me!
I'm not a big color person, but this sweater grew on me the longer I had it on. The colors are gorgeous IRL, the pattern is unique, and OMG IT IS LUXURIOUSLY SOFT!!! It felt like wearing a bath robe to work!! If for nothing else, rent it for comfort and warmth!! I'm usually a small, but always size up in sweaters and the medium in this was perfect.
Chico Sweater
Parker
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 32D
Matronly and DON'T size up!
Pros - beautiful colors and pattern, comfortable, lightweight. Cons - so matronly!! I sized up because of other reviews but should have ordered my normal size!
Printed Waffle Dress
Peter Pilotto
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 32D
No give
Cute Jeans, but no give to them at all. I ordered the 25 which is my normal size in Madewell (I'm a 26 in everything else). The waist definitely runs big and the denim is thick.
Light Indigo Perfect Vintage Jeans
Madewell
Size Worn: 25R
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 32D
Easy to wear
Easy to wear and lightweight. Perfect for fall, professional, and versatile. I loved that it was reversible but kept it on the tan side the whole time I had it
Camden Reversible Coat
Charli
Size Worn: 4
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 32D
Didn't end up wearing
This sweater is high quality and cute but I didn't end up wearing due to the fit. Ordered a medium and I felt like the horizontal stripes were not flattering.
Keanne Sweater
Saylor
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 32D
A must-rent!!!
This is definitely fitted as other reviews mentioned, but I actually found it to be more TTS than expected! I rented my normal small (I'm between a 2-4) and it was perfect! Scalloped detail is beautiful, gorgeous color and buttery soft material, high quality and warm! Only complaint is that the extra hanger spot things in the sweater stick out and are difficult to keep hidden!
Foldover Scallop Sweater
Milly
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 32D
Perfect for holiday season!
I LOVE this! It's the perfect layer for the holiday season. Easy to dress up or down! The one size runs oversized, but I loved the look and thought it fit great for a 2/4/6. Will be hanging on to this one for a while!
Tweedy Checks Sweater Coat
The Kooples
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 32D
Fun and sexy
Rented this for a rehearsal dinner and ended up wearing something a bit more conservative, but this is a winner. I got the 4 and would rent the 2 if I were to try it again, as it was a bit low cut and a tiny bit big for my personal comfort level. It does gather a bit in the middle as mentioned in another review but it's not obvious - just kind of random to have pockets in this kind of dress. Material is silky and lightweight, unlined on the top half.
Printed Bailey V-Neck Dress
A.L.C.
Size Worn: 4R
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 32D
Head-turner!!!
Wore this to my best friend's rehearsal dinner - it is classy, a little sexy, and flattering! Easy to wear and accessorize. The material is stretchy and light weight. Straps were a little big/long on me so they fell off part of the night but it didn't bother me enough to pin them.
Cardiff Sheath
cupcakes and cashmere
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Not work appropriate in length
Beautiful dress, well made, unique, great texture and material. Unfortunately it's just too short to wear to work which is what I rented it for. I'm 5'5" and the 4 fit everywhere except length.
Eclipse Pique Ruched Dress
Tibi
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Beautiful details but size up
Gorgeous details on this dress, but size up one or two sizes. If you have any arm muscles, skip it. I am usually a 2/4 and went with the 6 but it was still too tight across the chest and shoulders. Need a second set of hands to zip for sure, and it was a smidge short. Also not comfortable if wearing for a long time
Ditzy Floral Mesh Dress
Cynthia Rowley
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Couldn't live without them
Bought these! I couldn't live without them in the fall and winter. I have a really difficult time finding pants that fit just right, and these checked all the boxes. No stretch, so they retain their shape and fit all the right places. They are high quality, a true black pant, comfortable, come up just below the belly button, and hit just above the ankle so they are perfect with booties.
Member Fit Notes
Black Corduroy Alana Jeans
J BRAND
Size Worn: 26
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 36DD
Cute but not $300 cute
I liked this enough to wear it once or twice, but wasn't obsessed. Colors are pretty, required a tank underneath. Hard to believe it's a $300 sweater because the quality isn't that great.
Grey Striped Sweater
XíRENA
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Not my favorite
I think this is a great sweater for petites...I didn't love the look on me. The mismatched length at the bottom wasn't flattering on the shorter side and the line across the top emphasized my chest. As mentioned in other reviews, it runs small and snug, specifically in the neck and arms. I prefer a more traditional oversized sweater, so this was a miss.
Oversized Fringed Sweater
(nude)
Size Worn: 40
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Easy throw on top
Easy throw on top! Loose fitting, breezy, and oversized. Elastic in arms was a bit snug for me but nothing too annoying. It was perfect for an Oklahoma game day with the crimson and cream!
The Poem Shirt
The Great.
Size Worn: 1
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Felt like a million bucks!
I'm obsessed with this top. It's something I never would buy because it's such a statement, but was a blast to wear. I wore it to a Jonas Brothers concert and felt trendy and fun in it! It was pretty warm - didn't breathe well so it's best for indoor (AC) events or cool weather and it definitely needed tape or a pin to hold the top in place.
Glenda Top
STINE GOYA
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Staple shape and versatile
This is a great staple shape - I loved how easy it was to wear! The pattern and material make it versatile for the beach, the office, or happy hour. Nothing that really wows me about it, but this is a worthwhile every day rental!! It's the perfect length (maybe a smidge short) on me and I'm 5'5"/small.
Striped Lydia Dress
Hutch
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Surprisingly amazing
I had a little bit of order regret after choosing this for my unlimited shipment, but was pleasantly surprised upon arrival. This is unique, super easy to wear, and weirdly flattering?? I love it and can't wait to wear it to work! It is a bit warm - probably too warm for September in Oklahoma, but I'm going to hang on to it for a bit!!
Savanna Split Neck Dress
Tibi
Size Worn: 2R
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Feminine and classic
Too cute!! Lots of material and "flow"! Super classic and feminine. I'm between a 2 and 4, went with the 2, and it fit great. A little snug under the arms but not too bad! Also needed a helper to zip in the back!
Striped Tillis Dress
Hunter Bell
Size Worn: 2R
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Obsessed
I don't know how you couldn't love this dress. I rented for a trip to Nashville and it was a bit nicer than what our day called for, so I threw it on for some photos and then changed into a more casual outfit! The sleeves are a lot, but it's such a show stopper that It didn't even matter. I can't wait to rent it again for an event! I think a small would have fit better in the top half for me, but maybe would have been too short, so TBD on how the next attempt goes!
Damiani Dress
Alexis
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Darling!
This top is darling!! I loved the colors, pattern, and fit. The straps did slide off a bit here and there, but we were out two-stepping so that's probably why. I still loved it and would definitely rent again!
Garden Posy Top
kate spade new york
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Dainty and adorable!
Loved everything about this! Great quality material, cute little specks of color, feminine, and easy to wear!
Pink Stripe Tank Dress
Rebecca Taylor NYC
Size Worn: 2
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Not flattering
This was a risk and it did not pay off. It was unflattering, large (even though I sized down to a 2!), and had a weird side closure. It zips most of the way and then stops for a series of buttons - makes no sense to me! This went back unworn.
Confetti Floral Dress
Jason Wu
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Easy wear!
Easy wear, lightweight, partially lined! It is on the longer side so I sized down to a 2 and was glad I did! I think my normal 4 would have been too loose and too long. It's also a lot more orange IRL so fair warning there! Excited to wear it!
Sleeveless Provence Block Dress
Rebecca Taylor NYC
Size Worn: 2
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Not as casual as expected
This was a bit of a bummer because it didn't feel as casual as I expected. I suppose it could be dressed up or dressed down, but it felt more like a dressier option to me. Fit great and high quality, flattering design and pattern, but just not what I anticipated.
Skylar Midi Dress
Prose & Poetry
Size Worn: SR
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Small in hips but beautiful colors and pattern! Classy!
As other reviewers mentioned, this runs a bit small in the hips. Everywhere else fit great! The first thing I noticed was the volume in the ruffles on the front at the bottom - those are super cute, but it is straight in the back so they don't go all the way around the dress. I loved the pattern and colors. Overall this was a great rental and so classy!
Floral Flounce Hem Dress
Victoria Victoria Beckham
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Versatile and breezy
I loved how versatile this was for summer - I think I got more wears out of this rental than I have anything else!! Wore to church, work with a denim jacket, dinner with friends...it is just darling! Easy to wear, lined, and fit great! I was worried about the bust emphasizing my chest but it ended up looking great!
The Scallop Gingham Clover Dress
The Great.
Size Worn: 1R
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Beautiful but not without issues
This dress is probably one of the prettiest dresses I've rented...the colors and pattern are lovely! I immediately received compliments upon walking out the door. That being said, this does not come without issues. It is SHEER. I wasn't sure whether or not to take other reviewers seriously, but the ones who noted that it was completely see-through are right. I managed to throw on a nude slip and tuck in the straps to my strapless bra. The material is a bit thicker and the pleats help distract, but it definitely should have been made with a lining. The strap are not adjustable and while it didn't cause too much a problem for me, I imagine it would for different body types depending on bust size and shoulders!
Marine Garden Pleated Cami Dress
VINCE.
Size Worn: SR
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 135lbs
Bust: 32D
Underwhelming
This didn’t do a whole lot for me. I found it to have too much room/volume around the bottom - not worth the risk in windy oklahoma. Low cut across the front and just generally very average. This went back in the bag immediately.
Member Fit Notes
Striped Parasol Dress
Chinti & Parker
Size Worn: None
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 5"
Weight: 140lbs
Bust: 36DD