Deborah's Reviews
All reviews by Deborah
TOP CONTRIBUTORTOP CONTRIBUTOR
49 reviews
Extraordinary yoga pants... but still just yoga pants
OK, so these are very comfy, no doubt about that. The fabric is an ultrasuede, so definitely has a nice feel to it that is more elevated than your average yoga pants. And because of that, you can in fact wear them for work - but note they are definitely on the casual end of business casual. With that said, these are just OK. They are definitely a little on the short side - I'd probably not order them if I was 5'6"+ (and I am). They fit snugly even when sized up, so you just have to accept that your shape is how they are going to show. Wearable and comfy, but to me these are just a nicer version of joggers for going to the grocery store in.
Member Fit Notes
Abbey Legging
Sanctuary
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 160lbs
Bust: 36D
I liked this dress well enough, but it's a pretty lukewarm relationship
Pros - dress is very comfortable, nice long sleeves, the pattern is flattering despite the horizontal elements, and the skirt shape is unusual for a sweater dress. I'm not sure I'd call these Cons, but otherwise I just found this dress quite boring. It's "what you see is what you get." It was hard to style outside of just wearing it as is to the office. Here you can see I tried to make it a little less corporate by adding in some brown, but I still don't love it - maybe putting a shirt or dickie under so there's a collar against the crew neck would help. Overall it's fine, and would be very useful if you needed a modest, comfortable dress, but doesn't really feel particularly luxe or fashionable.
Member Fit Notes
Terence Knit Dress
Tanya Taylor
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 160lbs
Bust: 36D
I only wish I lived in a climate that needed coats regularly, because this WOULD be the one
I rented this to wear on a trip to the Pacific Northwest in January, and it was absolutely PERFECT. Extremely comfortable, warm and cozy while not being restrictive or heavy, versatile enough to wear hiking and to nice meals! The flannel fleece lining is super comfy so it was even perfect to wear like a bathrobe around the house. While it's brown, this is a very nice brown... has like a coppery cast to it. Because of the dual zipper, you can adjust it to have open at the top or bottom or fully closed. If you need a puffer coat, this is a fantastic choice!
Member Fit Notes
Light Hooded Puffer
T.W.I.N.
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 160lbs
Bust: 36D
LOVE THESE - comfy, slightly unusual, great shape, very flattering
I think I might comfortably have gone down a size, but also because of the flat front/side zip it is very forgiving. Fabric is an un-stretchy denim. The color of these is fantastic - they are still casual jeans, but the brown color and the shape make them a little more upscale if you want to wear more as a trouser. Super versatile. Note there are no belt loops.
Member Fit Notes
Side Zip Wide Leg Jean
Joe's Jeans
Size Worn: 31
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 160lbs
Bust: 36D
Really versatile piece that is both comfortable, classy and has a bit of edge
I loved this dress and got a lot of use out of it! Works great with ankle or knee boots, can accessorize a zillion ways (scarf, belt, open like a duster over pants), and super comfortable. Nice long sleeves if you have long arms!! I think I would have gone with a L rather than XL, but the ribbing makes it very forgiving either way. It shrank in a bit on me because of the ribbing, but if you had it a little small it would also expand and sit comfortably - so a great versatility if you are between sizes or unsure. Tan color is also quite forgiving and creates lots of optionality around accessorizing, and I could see it working well into Spring.
Member Fit Notes
Camel Variegated Rib Knit Leather Combo Dress
Toccin
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 160lbs
Bust: 36D
Exactly like the picture - fun 80s style with pop of color
It's intended to be roomy, so if you want it to be somewhat more fitted size down - but otherwise I found it very true to size. Nice long sleeves and soft, not scratchy. Bright, true red. You can wear the sweater long (as in the listing pic) or roll the hem up underneath so it has more of a slouchy effect. It's relatively thick, but not so thick you couldn't do a front tuck comfortably. Got a lot of use out of and definitely love this piece!
Member Fit Notes
Deep V-Neck Pull Over
Scotch & Soda
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 160lbs
Bust: 36D
This fabric is far too stiff for the design, making you look like a football player in pads
This shirt is awful, can't be redeemed. If it was in a silkier/drapier fabric, it could work fine - but the combo of a thick/stiff cotton, ultra gathered design with RAGLAN sleeves (what were they thinking??), and large flat cuffs just make sure that it is going to hang weirdly and stand out from your body in the most unflattering way possible, without hope of being tucked or folder in a way that creates any shape other than Big Box. The pic in the catalog must have been steamed to limpness to hang the way it does. Nope.
Member Fit Notes
Chloe Blouse
A.L.C.
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Worth the wait!
I had this on my "notify me" list forever, and it finally came available to coincide with a rental order. YAY! It's everything I was hoping it would be - I dressed it up a bit for work, or can style casually with denim and topsiders. The fabric is a light cotton (and has pink and blue flowers on a white background) so it tends a bit more toward a spring/summer feel, but because of the muted colors it was fine for Autumn. I have wide shoulders so got the XL and liked the fit overall - it's not blousey so it's not too puffy or oversized. Very flexible shirtdress that you can style many different ways, and very comfortable to boot. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Michelle Cheetah Reflections Dress
Caballero
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Very Fun! Husband loves it
I am not a football girlie, but my husband follows the Eagles so I was excited to see this with the other team offerings just made available! It's very soft lining so super comfy, and overall it's lightweight despite the light insulated lining. Very fun. I got the XL because I wanted the "boyfriend slouch" in this, but my husband commented I might even have gone a size down - so I would say it's true to size, and up to you if you want it baggy or more feminine. The color in the posted picture looks more aqua, but the jacket itself is correct Eagles green. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Eagles Bomber Jacket
Terez
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Versatile and well fitted, slit makes for interest but it's not too high
I wore this skirt a lot - the wash is really light (almost a gray/blue) so it's a different denim effect than typical blue or black. My office allows jeans, and I found it easy to dress up for business casual OR to make it a casual weekend errand go to. It does fit a bit slim around the hips, but it's not constraining, and the gentle A-line cut is very flattering. The slit in both front and back makes it really comfortable as well and relieves some of the stiffness of a heavy denim skirt. Comes with a skinny self belt that is sewed in at the back, so if I owned it I would probably remove that to allow other accessory options - but gives it an easy way to finish during rentals. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
A-Line Denim Skirt
3.1 Phillip Lim
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Perfect shape with a hint of rock and roll
I loved these jeans and wore them styled many different ways (here is my snakeskin shirt and shoes... don't judge for the half tuck, I was trying something!). These are really great shape that is comfortable all the way around and fit well through waist, hips and things. I would have loved a tall but these were fine with flats for 5'8". The fabric is a bit heavy/stiff, but honestly these were new-with-tag when they came to me so they may soften up just a bit! The real treat is the eyelets all the way down the side and around the pockets - it's just a hint of flash and edge, but not so much that it drives the overall style or YOU need to veer toward edgy styling to be comfortable. A very mature take on Rock and Roll. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Sailor Scoop Eyelet Jeans
Rolla's
Size Worn: 31
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Had no idea what to expect, but this shirt is literally everything
Took on vacation so no pics, but I wore this EVERYWHERE. It's a layered net, which makes it very stretchy and comfortable, perfect to wear alone or as a layer. The colors are both neutral and swirly, so it can go with pretty much anything - you could add something in a print to make it funky, or wear one or two of the colors to make it more conservative. The turtleneck can be rolled to whatever height and since it's net it's not bulky even if you have it rolled down to basically a crewneck. Was concerned that the stretch net would emphasize body issues, but the double layer makes it feel a bit like shapewear underneath (not uncomfortable, it's just taking the edge off any rolls!) and the top layer skims over. Love this shirt. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Collo Alto Top
Fuzzi
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Versatile, but I found this skirt very uncomfortable
Sorry, no pic - wore on vacation and was having too much fun to remember! That said, I did not love this skirt though I think it worked well enough and might be up someone else's alley. I found the fabric stiff and heavy - so apart from the bulk in my suitcase, it made it very uncomfortable and felt particularly constrictive in the waist/hips due to the high-rise. The shape was nice, though I would describe it as a bit of a pencil skirt with a flare, so slim through the thighs - not really great for walking around in all day. The color and style make it quite versatile - can be dressed up or down. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Melanie Skirt
Joe's Jeans
Size Worn: 31
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Very pretty, and neutral tones don't feel like "too much" despite the size
Wore to a wedding with the cheetah dress (in Colorado, coincidentally!). Larger and heavier than I usually wear so it was a bit of a stretch for me, but overall they were comfortable and chic.
Member Fit Notes
Colorado Earrings
Gas Bijoux
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
THE most versatile - and comfortable - dress
I wore this 1000 times so I had to pick the picture that showed its versatility, but I actually selected to wear for a wedding. And got so.many.compliments. While incredibly simple, this dress is a beautiful silk that hangs perfectly, and lets you move on the dancefloor. The fabric is thin so you can layer sweaters over it, or put a belt on and turn it into more of a shirt dress look. I actually kept this for several cycles it's so amazing. I'm really not even a print person - especially big prints - but the color scheme is all neutrals so it's not crazy. Well worth it!! My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Jaguar Dress
Silk Laundry
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Rented as my "WHY NOT" piece, and now I'm in love
OMG - what a surprise this piece is. I liked the colors and funkiness, but truly feared this was going to be either too tight (it seems to look a bit fitted) or some weird artsy puffy coat. It's actually now one of my absolute favorite items. It fits PERFECTLY - skims everything, adds a bit of shaping at the waist and the neck - but is unbelievably comfortable. There's a bit of stretch in the fabric, but it's not tight and you can wear things with sleeves. It can dress up or down, as it has a casual feel from the blues and the quilting, but the leather trim and buttons elevate it. Worth the experiment!! My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Quilted Faux Leather Trim Jacket
NIC + ZOE
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Great jeans, but recommend sizing down
These are really great jeans - soft, and "not thick" (but I wouldn't describe them as "thin"), they hang very nicely and sooooo comfortable. They are a mid-wash but the styling is still work appropriate if your office allows jeans. I didn't love the button fly, but that's my personal preference - why add the bulk there? I wish they came in talls, but they were fine for flats as a somewhat taller woman. They are WAY larger than any other jeans I've ever worn in this size, and even if you want a boyfriend-y slouch they are just too much. I have a pic - with a belt! - styled up in the Nic + Zoe Quilted Blue Jacket, but wanted to post an image here of the oversize waist so you can see what I mean. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Annina High Rise Wide Leg Jeans
Citizens of Humanity
Size Worn: 31
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Fun, perfect waist length, can button or unbutton!
I loved this - wore it on a Colorado vacation, so unfortunately was having too much fun to get a picture, but it's exactly what you see. Nice thick, quality wool, the colors are very flexible (jeans, black, white, different colors of tan - it went with everything). Great for layering or on its own.
Member Fit Notes
Mavie Cardigan
Rails
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Pretty and so, so comfortable
I really enjoyed this dress, it's very comfortable and easy to wear. The print is fabulous, and so well laid out for balance throughout the entire pattern placement. I typically don't go for prints, but this one is funky and fun. It's cool and light, but has a liner layer that makes it one stop wearing. I couldn't give it 5 stars because I think it can be a bit super-casual, you have to be conscious of not letting it come off as a housedress. For example, the string tie belt really doesn't create a ton of definition - so it keeps the shirtdress from looking like a sack, but it's not particularly styled with just that belt. Re: agreeing to postpone, the answer is “yes, we can agree to for contractual purposes” BUT there are fiduciary pressures that Charter will have to deal with: eg, pressure to close to capture cash for their shareholders, risk of something happening that prevents closing, analyst reporting complications, etc. It’s not atypical to push it back a few weeks to get to a convenient accounting cutover at month-end, but also probably not a 3 month window available to them.
Member Fit Notes
Valerie Dress
CAROLINA K
Size Worn: L-XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Very boxy and the dual layer hangs super weirdly
OK - so I wanted a boxy jacket and sized up, which was way too much. That's on me! But I mention it because this torso and sleeves are cut large anyway so if you want a drapey blazer I'd probably still go one size down. At any rate, I did not like this jacket at all - the sleeves are extremely long because of the contrast trim (I have gorilla arms and generally have a very hard time finding sleeves that are long enough... this still went almost to my knuckles - though easy enough to style by pushing up). To me the worst was the way the front panels laid with the trim insert inside. It makes the tan top layer poofy/pillowy, rather than a sleek structured layer over the cream interior. It's just super heavy and draggy. I will give it points for being comfortable, but overall this was not a great piece and I prefer the Veronica Beard options. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Kelly Blazer
Favorite Daughter
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Really pretty, light and comfortable
The fabric makes this! With a beautiful contrast trim on sleeves and button strip, it's perfectly framed and the way the pattern is cut aligns perfectly with all the parts of the shirt. It's very soft, light fabric so easy to wear and could easily fit in a jacket/sweater too without being bulky. Very comfortable generally and can dress casually or for work outfits. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Placed Print Button Up Shirt
Derek Lam 10 Crosby x RTR
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Very pretty - delicate details are understated and elegant, yet cover the whole top
This shirt is very pretty, and the light cotton fabric makes it super comfortable either as a layer under a jacket, tucked in to pants, or where you want full coverage with breathability. The lace design is sewn on across the entire top (including the back!) and sleeves, and the shoulder puff is feminine but not costumey. For a similar style, the Vanessa Bruno bell top has a lot of these features - and personally I liked the fancier lace and the drapey knit (and torso length) of that other shirt better, but some of the reviews for that found the Vanessa Bruno too boxy in the torso - this shirt has a more fitted torso so you may prefer that aspect. Great, versatile piece! My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Gabby Top
ba&sh
Size Worn: 3
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Nice trouser that feels like jeans, got compliments, but I'm on the fence. Heavy fabric & structure
I liked these pants, but can't say I'm in love with them - and I wish I could say why! The wide leg is very well designed from the waist to the floor, and the length is absolutely perfect for 5'8" in flats. The color is black and completely unfaded, despite the denim fabric. My hesitation may well be that they are super structured/heavy fabric, so the pleat at the front has maybe a bit too much stiffness - perhaps would be better if the pleat was ironed flat so it comes off a little smoother. Nice fitting, high waist. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Pleated Denim Trouser
Joe's Jeans
Size Worn: 31
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Photographs well, but it's just... it has a life of its own. Not as casual as it appears.
I really, really want to love this skirt - it's a neat combo of casual tan denim-like fabric and a structured, pleated print with something of a sheen. The flat front with the side/back pleating should be really flattering. And to be clear - I did get compliments on it; it shows up well as a statement piece. But I found that there is something really awkward about it. The gingham print part of the fabric is a heavy polyester (it's what holds the pleats) - it's actually black but works well with navy. At any rate, I just found the shape of the skirt off - it doesn't HANG; the pleats aren't big/soft enough. So the pleats add a bit of cross-bulk. It made for a nice feminine shape, and maybe if it was longer (and had some weight to pull it down) I'd feel better about it?? I was really torn on this one - should have been really versatile but I found it hard to wear and feel comfortable in. I had already sized down and would probably size down again - was comfy in the waist even already downsized once but I feel like that might have helped with the sense of bulk around the front placket to side pleat transition. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Decland Skirt
Tanya Taylor
Size Worn: 10
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Fantastic piece - versatile, comfortable, adds shape without constriction
I loved this top and wore it 1000 ways, from casual to work to dinners out. It literally goes with anything. The shape is amazing - the knit is heavy duty (but not sweater thick), and it has a gentle peplum shape at the hip that adds great waist definition without bulk. The notch at the bottom is perfect to add a bit of structural detail but hits below the beltline so it's not fussy to wear. I felt like it gaped/stretch a bit at the bust, but solved by wearing a dark cami under - if I owned this, I would just stitch it up to about the second button and wear it without buttons to there (they are hard to work anyway). The stretch really solves for that issue and the dark navy is very forgiving. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Peplum Vest
Ted Baker London
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Really pretty, several compliments - wanted to love, but couldn't
This shirt is really neat - the detailing on it is fantastic, from the shank buttons up and down the split sleeves to the pintucking on shoulders and front placket. It's on the roomy size (downright boxy), and the shoulder construction with a raglan style doesn't restrict movement. With that said, the fabric is very thick and stiff, so add that to the boxy torso and the pintucked front and it's bulky to tuck in. Would probably be better if sized down, but overall I felt fussy in this all day. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Poplin Split Sleeve Tuxedo Shirt
Prabal Gurung x RTR
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
High versatile, has a French tomboy feel that is both feminine and masculine
I wore this to a Board of Directors dinner where the dress code was "summer business casual" - was a perfect fit as the feminine dressiness of the ruffled high/low skirt, the masculine shirt dress style, and the business sense in the blue and white striping hit all the right notes. The fabric is outstanding: quality dye that goes through the fabric, exactly the right weight to hold shape but not be stiff. I gave it 4 instead of 5 stars because it's not as long as it looks in the picture and it's a bit tight across the shoulders. I would recommend sizing up for a little more room to work with the wrap. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Julia Stripe Wrap Dress
kate spade new york
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Felt like an Edwardian princess everywhere
I LOVED this dress - I ended up wearing this every chance I got, even just to putter around the house feeling fancy. But it's comfortable and fresh too! The sleeves have an adjustable elastic so they can be more like wings or gathered puff sleeves, and the lace is really pretty, with great pin-tuck details everywhere. Enjoyed it by itself, layered over dresses and shirts, with light shirts tied over the top of it, with sandals, with heels, with cute tennies. Super versatile. Might recommend sizing up so you get the good drape. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Embroidered Ruffled Maxi Dress
Maje
Size Worn: 42
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
ENORMOUS - but nice shape
These are wiiiiiiiide leg, wide everything - I loved the deep color and the leg styling overall, but ultimately these are very stiff and structured, and the waist is at least 3" bigger than I expected. The button fly was kind of a fun surprise, but when added to the bulk and heaviness of the jeans I just didn't love them. Nice and long for tall girls (hit right at the floor but didn't drag for 5'8"). Definitely size down if you are going to try these. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Dame Jean in Pendulum
AGOLDE
Size Worn: 31
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Love these, a bit of panache but super comfy
Darn it, I forgot to get a photo of these! I really liked these, they were great for work. I think they could work well for a brunch as well, although a bit too trouser-y for very casual use. The fabric was great - nice drape, very thick (but still pliable) so no show through, the detail at the waist with the tuck & waistband gold pins is very nice and understated while creating great definition. My only criticism is they were just a tad short, even for flats, at my height (5'8"). Nice thick hem if you are looking to buy and have tailored though. Overall, would rent again, especially in fall. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Olive Pleated Pants
Eudon Choi x RTR
Size Worn: 10
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Very pretty but I couldn't use
I was really excited about this top, but unfortunately did not feel comfortable wearing it. I've given it 3 stars however because it's really nice for the right person! I found that the gathering at the waist was too shortwaisted for someone my height, and the slit is too deep (even with the button closure) for someone busty. I think it would be great on someone super slender OR if you are shorter (if busty, definitely size up). Fabric is gorgeous and drapey, the sleeves weren't too poofy. If in doubt, go larger so you get the benefit of the drape. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Tomina Satin Top
Zadig & Voltaire
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Beyond cropped if you are over 5'2"
I gave this 2 instead of 1 star because it's absolutely gorgeous - the fabric is stunning, the collar design is fantastic, the cut around the shoulders is so comfy and feminine. AND YET. I couldn't wear it anywhere but around the house when I was alone. This isn't just cropped, it is an empire waist on me at 5'8". Like JUST at the bra-line, and that's not even reaching for an upper cabinet. If you have a gorgeous midriff or the shortest torso, this is 5 stars. Otherwise it just made me sad. Why they couldn't have put a few more inches at the bottom I do not know. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Micah Top
Tanya Taylor
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
LOVE this jacket, perfect soft comfy
This jacket is so comfortable, loose but not boxy, has just a hint of pizzazz with the two tones (but subtle enough to keep it really neutral), can actually wear sleeves under it AND shoulders have movement, has versatility for both casual and super professional applications. It's not showy but it's classy. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Braeton Dickey Jacket
Veronica Beard
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Made due, they are fine, didn't love
So overall I came to appreciate these pants a little, but never loved them. Pros - they are really comfortable, the stretch is just right and the wide legs hold a nice shape. Cons - the hip/butt area is REALLY slim (I guess it's in the name) so they make for an unflattering shape around the hip/leg connection... if you're super slim and straight no worries, but they just emphasize all the bumps in the wrong way and I was only comfortable wearing them with a long shirt or jacket. Less important cons are the leg shape (they are more barrel than palazzo - kind of have a curve on the inner seam) and the AWFUL front pockets (which I've seen be cuter but not when this part is so tight... they only add to emphasizing your leg crease). Overall I was able to use, but don't love. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Le Slim Palazzo Modernist Pocket Jeans
FRAME
Size Worn: 31
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36D
Looks good in concept, but sooooo uncomfortable
The other reviews are spot on - this fits very small, and the sleeves are extremely tight. I sized up and it's still only really possible to wear with a sleeveless outfit. Beyond just the snug cut, the fabric has zero yield - the denim structure means there's just no give in the shoulders. So it looks fine if you are standing with your arms straight down, but any movement whatsoever is uncomfortable. I really only put on so I could get a picture for this review, it was too uncomfortable to wear anywhere. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Wayne Jacket
L'agence
Size Worn: XL
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36C
So many compliments - comfy, flattering, yet eye catching
I love this top - it's got a ton of detail with all the ties, the gathered neckline, and the fabric is top notch (quality particularly shows in the well placed prints relative to the pattern parts). Very comfy and works for both casual and work. I downgraded from 5 stars only because I found it a little bit more cropped than I would like for my height. Wasn't unwearable but I was definitely aware that I was showing skin if I raised my arm. Solved with a high waisted pant, but still was in the back of my mind all day! My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Serafina Top
Fifteen Twenty
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36C
LOVE THESE - perfect smooth fit, runs a little large
These are amazing - extremely well fitting, with just a hint of pleating on the front but otherwise a very elongating, smooth wide leg style. The quality is awesome, and the side seams are chef's kiss - they add an elongating detail AND allow the pockets to be slightly forward so they are both functional and lay flat. Great and versatile color. They run a little large - I normally wear a 12 but only the 10 was available so I took the risk - perfect fit. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Marfa Trousers
Tanya Taylor
Size Worn: 10R
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36C
Fantastic piece, but really needs a slim straight body
This vest is amazing - really well cut, the waistcoat style is awesome, the colors are very flexible, and the fabric is super comfortable with a little stretch. It's an incredibly nice piece. I had to downrate it a little for me as it's just not compatible with a bigger bust - between the slim fit and the pattern and the stretchiness of the fabric and the high neckline, it just emphasized any gape or attempt to wear it as anything other than an open layer. I really like this piece and highly recommend, but it is unexpectedly body conscious. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Checkered Lois Vest
Veronica Beard
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36C
Felt like I was in a Charlie's Angel episode from the 70s
For me this was a no, but I can definitely see how it would be a great piece for someone else. Pros - super comfy (I mostly wore this as a lounger around the house), I love that the top has buttons so it's just wrapping at the waist (full wrap tops can make you look too busty). Cons to me were - jersey fabric (even though it's super high quality), no pockets, the print is super retro (in fairness, that's why I rented - to experiment with prints), and the color is too dark (maybe would be better in fall/winter though). It's too short for someone 5'8" - I had to leave the french cuffs down to get the right arm length, and the pants are just highwaters that swish because of the jersey fabric. I didn't love but someone else may be braver - to me, I just felt like it was very costume-y. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Michele Jumpsuit
Diane von Furstenberg
Size Worn: LR
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36C
Versatile and comfortable
Really nice piece to add structure and texture. The color is perfect (blues, white, and fine gold accent woven in), and the stretch makes it comfortable even though it's quite fitted. Went great with jeans, a dress, work and casual styling. Would definitely rent again! Only drawback for me is that it is a little snug fitting, so sleeveless or thin fabric sleeves required. My rating approach: (5=LOVE LOVE; 4=Will rent again, a couple of details I would change; 3=Works but meh; 2=Won't rent again, but may work in some cases; 1=This should be burned). I am on RTR to try new styles and find sizes for my post-menopausal weight/body shape.
Member Fit Notes
Ryland Dickey Jacket
Veronica Beard
Size Worn: 12
Usual Size: 12
Height: 5' 8"
Weight: 170lbs
Bust: 36C