Casey's Reviews
All reviews by Casey
TOP CONTRIBUTORTOP CONTRIBUTOR
55 reviews
Adorable!
Fantastic jacket! All the other reviews are correct: it is boxy and the sleeves are short. It is still fantastic. I am a 4/6 and 5’ 4” and definitely wanted the M; size up. I wore it over overalls to run errands on the weekend (shown here) and tossed it on over a summer dress paired with boots for a casual evening out on an early fall evening. I’m not sure how long the quilted jacket trend will last, but I am here for it for as long as it’s here.
Member Fit Notes
Emil Jacket
RHODE
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 125lbs
Bust: 36B
Chest is huge!!!!!
The chest of this dress is ginormous! I ended up loaning it to a friend who is a DD and even she had room to spare. If you aren’t extremely busty, pass on this one.
Member Fit Notes
Laine Gown
Hutch
Size Worn: 8
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 125lbs
Bust: 36B
So many compliments!
This is a really great dress. Maybe not the most flattering dress you have ever worn, but definitely a head turner. I got so many compliments when I wore this to a children’s museum gala. I was working the event so I didn’t want anything that I might step on, and the M petite was perfect on my 5’ 4” frame. I needed the medium because I am a little thick around the middle. If you carry your weight elsewhere, you could definitely go down a size. The voluminous sleeves and risk of revealing side boob made it a little bit of a cumbersome choice but I would still totally wear it again.
Member Fit Notes
Versailles Gown
L'IDÉE
Size Worn: MP
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 125lbs
Bust: 36B
One Shoulder Wonder
I only have photos of me sitting or from the neck up, so you really can’t tell how fabulous this dress is. It is comfy, has pockets, and is stylish to boot!
Member Fit Notes
Ruffled One-Shoulder Midi Dress
Madewell
Size Worn: 2
Usual Size: 2
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 120lbs
Bust: 34B
Major Dorothy Draper Vibes!
I wore this on vacation at The Greenbrier and loved it. I probably could have gone down a size, but it is quite stretchy and flexible. Would also be great for a tropical vacation.
Member Fit Notes
Toucananas Tiered Maxi
FARM Rio
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 2
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 120lbs
Bust: 34B
If a disco ball was a dress!
Wore this to a charity gala that I was hosting and it did not disappoint. Got tons of compliments and, more importantly, I loved it! I’m a 4/6 (5’ 4”, 125 lbs, 34B) and absolutely needed the 6. This is the regular length and I am wearing kitten heels, so I think it runs rather short. Anyone taller than 5’ 4” should absolutely order the long. I did wear Spanx and a sticky bra since the back drops pretty low.
Member Fit Notes
Dara Gown
Badgley Mischka
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 125lbs
Bust: 34B
So much fun!
This bag is super cute and added a bright pop of color to an already bright wedding guest outfit. The biggest con is definitely that it doesn't close, leaving all your items on display and the contents vulnerable to spilling out.
Member Fit Notes
The Beautiful Bag
Susan Alexandra
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 130130lbs
Bust: 34B
A Standout Dress
First, this dress is extremely long. Even in mega heels, it was skimming the floor. I'm 5' 4" and think it is probably meant for someone 5' 7" or taller. I wouldn't say that this dress is particularly flattering, but I got tons of compliments from other guests at the wedding I attended. Other women seemed to really like it.
Member Fit Notes
Anaisa Maxi Dress
Roksanda
Size Worn: 8R
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 130130lbs
Bust: 34B
My favorite rental of all time.
I am obsessed with this dress. I have probably worn it a dozen or more times, and get compliments every single time. It does run a little big; a 40 probably would have fit a bit better. I am particularly fond of it with a belt, but maybe in a smaller size I would have liked it unbelted. So far I have had it for a month, and I am really leaning toward keeping it longer, which is something I never do. Like I said, obsessed!
Member Fit Notes
Hawaiian Collared Maxi
Stella Jean
Size Worn: 42
Usual Size: 6
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 34B
It's a lot of dress!
This dress is A LOT, but I kind of like that! I wore it on vacation at the beach ( a little heavy for super hot temps), dinner out with girlfriends, date night with my husband, and around town simply because I was trying to eke out one more wear before I returned it. Probably not for everyone, but I was a fan. It does run very large so make sure you size down.
Member Fit Notes
White Brandy Dress
Just Female
Size Worn: XSR
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 130lbs
Bust: 34B
So much potential, but...
The fit on this skirt is every bit as weird as other reviewers said it was. The top tier is too tight, and too big simultaneously (how does that even happen) and too long. I had to fold over the top 2-3 times just to make it wearable with a knotted white button down. Forget about tucking anything in; you have to hide the top layer! Just for sh*ts and giggles I belted it and tried it as a dress. I didn't wear it anywhere like this, but it kind of worked. Skip this one.!
Member Fit Notes
Printed Peasant Skirt
Tory Burch
Size Worn: SR
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 125lbs
Bust: 34B
Holly Hobby Goes Chic!
I loved the print and the poofy sleeves. The fit itself wasn't super flattering as I'm a little thick through the middle and thought it accentuated that. With that said, I wore the heck out of it while I had it and got lots of compliments, mostly because it is such an eye catching print.
Member Fit Notes
Tarahumara Maxi
CAROLINA K
Size Worn: SR
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 125lbs
Bust: 34B
The print!
I don't think this is the most flattering dress I've ever worn, but I did love the print and wore it multiple times -- to work, dinner out, party. I indicated that it ran large since the XS fit well and I am definitely not an XS.
Member Fit Notes
Dreamscape Camilla Dress
STINE GOYA
Size Worn: XSR
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 125lbs
Bust: 34B
I liked this more than other people seemed to.
Incredibly comfortable, and I thought pretty cute. No one else seemed to really agree. My husband said I looked like I was wearing a night gown. I think it would have been better at the beach than it was for running around town.
Member Fit Notes
Jeanne Shift
Hofmann Copenhagen
Size Worn: 36R
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 125lbs
Bust: 34B
Pretty forgettable.
There’s nothing wrong with this dress, but there’s also nothing super right about it either. It's a sweater dress in a somewhat unattractive camel color. I didn't hate it enough to send it back without wearing it, but I certainly didn't need to keep it any longer.
Orange Soft Knit Dress
CAARA
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 120lbs
Bust: 34B
I'm ”wild” about this sweater!
Kind of love this sweater. Wore it with orange trousers for work and distressed denim for around town...I’ll probably rock it a few more times before I send it back. If you tend to get hot, you may want to pass because this is a very heavy sweater. I gave it 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟 because even the XS could stand to be a little smaller. A good solid rental!
The Cat Cardigan
KULE
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 120lbs
Bust: 34B
I may just not be cool enough for these pants.
They run very large - I'm typically a 2, and the 0s weren't tight. If you are an actual 0, I would pass on these. Lots of people commented on these, but I'm not sure if they actually liked them or if they just hadn’t seen anything quite like them. I also found choosing shoes a little confusing. Ankle boots, when combined with these pants, seemed to chop my legs into strange proportions, so I ended up pulling out an old pair of riding boots.
Franz Faux Leather Gaucho Pants
Snider
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 2
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 120lbs
Bust: 34B
Short and boxy!
I am incredibly short-waisted and even I found this sweater unwearable. It was cropped, but not in a cool way. Pass on this one.
Esther Sweater
HEARTLOOM
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 2
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 120lbs
Bust: 34B
A good everyday sweater.
Nothing earth shattering about this one, but nothing to really complain about either. I would probably recommend passing as you likely have something pretty similar already in your closet.
The It Girl Top
Current/Elliott
Size Worn: 1
Usual Size: 2
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 115lbs
Bust: 34B
I wore the heck out of this sweater!
Super cozy and comfy! I rented it for a weekend in the mountains: wore it traveling up and back - once with jeans and once with leggings. Then when I got home, I rocked it to a Super Bowl party (with jeans) and to work on Monday (with black pants and brown ankle boots.) A little oversized but not in a bad way. Like other reviewers, I cuffed the sleeves to keep them out of my way, but I actually thought it looked cuter that way. Not super memorable, but a solid choice for weekend wear.
Brown Oversized Bell Sleeve Sweater
Sweet Baby Jamie
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 115lbs
Bust: 34B
It was fine....
This shirt is not nearly as memorable as a rose gold sequin shirt should be. I didn't hate it, but I also wasn't conflicted about sending it back.
Rose Gold Sequin Top
Nicole Miller
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 2
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 115lbs
Bust: 34B
A solid everyday dress.
It is a cute dress but is largely unmemorable. I wore it to work - I have a pretty causal work environment- and received compliments, but it isn't anything I need to own or even probably rent again. It does show every lump and bump (wore with shape wear) so I would probably recommend going up a size. Note that the stripes are navy, not black. Also, I rented it in January and I think it's more of a fall dress. I initially tried it with tights and disliked it; decided to just be chilly instead.
Multi Striped Sweater Dress
Scotch & Soda
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 110lbs
Bust: 34B
Funeral chic.
I needed a dress for a funeral and this fit the bill - conservative without feeling matronly. (Yes, I do realize that a funeral is not about me.) The dress fit like a glove and was very flattering, but the material felt a little cheap. Even so, I considered buying it because it seemed like it could be versatile. Ultimately, I sent it back because I just could come to terms with the feel of the fabric.
Black High Neck Sheath
Donna Morgan
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 110lbs
Bust: 34B
Will be super sad to send this one back.
I've been wearing this jacket on repeat since I received it several weeks ago. It's edgy without being too edgy. Moto without feeling like I am wearing a costume. Looks great with denim, skirts, dresses, leggings...pretty much anything you pair it with. I'm typically an XS but got a S so I could wear it over sweaters, etc. It's a perfect fit! I'm typically not a fan of faux/vegan leather but this one is so well done, it's hard to tell it's not the real thing. Rent this jacket, if I send it back.
Washed Leather Motorcycle Jacket
Madewell
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 110lbs
Bust: 34B
Wildly popular every time I wear it!
Loved this skirt so much I bought it. I rented it to wear to my work holiday party but have found myself wearing it on repeat - with a black turtleneck and ankle boots for the office, with a vintage tee and kicks for a concert, and (as seen here) with a camel sweater and "leather" jacket for running around town. It's pretty much a neutral. (In this photo I am wearing it with the Madewell vegan leather jacket current available through unlimited.)
Leopard Everyday Midi Skirt
Sanctuary
Size Worn: XSR
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 110lbs
Bust: 34B
Just the edge I was looking for!
This jacket is extremely cropped and probably wouldn't be my favorite under normal circumstances, but it was just the edge this skirt (Delfi Collective Lauren Skirt) needed. Got tons of compliments on the outfit all evening!
Raisin Ribbed Biker Leather Jacket
Samantha Sipos
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 110lbs
Bust: 34B
Compliments galore!
I loved this skirt. It’s so fun, and the compliments came rolling in all evening - on the street, at the event, from all the people I texted pictures to so they could see how kicka** my outfit was. Wore with the Samantha Sipos ribbed biker jacket in raisin. (Also available from Unlimited.) In retrospect, I probably would have gotten the skirt in a small as it wouldn't have been quite so snug around my waist. Definitely the kind of piece you want to rent and not own, b/c it is super memorable.
Pink Lauren Skirt
DELFI Collective
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 110lbs
Bust: 34B
Super soft!
This sweater came new with tags, which is always exciting, and it is unbelievably soft. But it's just not that special. I wore it several times -leggings and maroon tennis shoes, jeans and black boots- but am not tempted to want to make it my own. It is SUPER soft, though, so if you are one of those people who tends to avid sweaters because of the itch factor, this is definitely for you.
Red Stripe Knit Sweater
Sundry
Size Worn: 1
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 110lbs
Bust: 34B
This sweater is completely forgettable.
The fit is terrible. It is super boxy and cropped which made for terrible lines. I packed it right up and sent it back.
Navy Patchwork Sweater
Slate & Willow
Size Worn: NONE
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 110lbs
Bust: 34B
Didn't live up to expectations.
Based on the reviews, I thought I was going to love this skirt but it was just ok. It was a smidge clingy, so while the XS fit, I wish I had sized up. I didn't love the fabric, either. With that said, I got tons of compliments.
Jada Skirt
Tory Burch
Size Worn: XSR
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B
Awesome dress!
I adored this dress, although I'm not sure the color would have looked very good on me without a little end-of-summer kiss from the sun. Runs TTS, fit is flattering and forgiving (no need for shapewear), and the neckline is great (although in retrospect, may have tied it incorrectly.) So many compliments from so many people. Must rent!
Yellow Chalky Drape Trapeze Dress
Tibi
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B
So stretched out by the end of the day.
These looked great first thing in the morning after I had agonizingly steamed them. I expected wrinkling...because they are linen, but what I didn't anticipate was that the knees and butt would be so stretched out after a day of wear. (Photo taken at the end of a workday.)
Tami Pants
Flynn Skye
Size Worn: XSR
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B
These pants are super forgettable.
These pants are mostly terrible. The fabric is like yoga pants, but they get super stretched out during the day. And the buttons have some ridiculous military-ish emblem on them. Do not waste a slot on these.
Potemkin Cropped Pants
Bailey 44
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B
Nothing special.
I was underwhelmed by this dress. The print lacked vibrancy and looked a little like an old couch. It fit TTS but I felt like to horizontal band at the waist made me look a little. I wore it because it wasn't objectionable, but it just lacked any pizzazz.
Garden Port Shirtdress
Tory Burch
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B
Liked it so much I bought it.
This a great little top, looks great with white jeans. I happen to have a very short torso so it works well on me, but beware if you have a long (or even regular length) torso.
Chambray Nanhi Top
Jill Jill Stuart
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B
I wanted to love them.
I wanted to love them but in reality I just didn't. I'm quite short waisted and the high waist on these felt like they were cutting me in half. Comfort aside, they made my rush look big and flat, when it's neither. I've successfully worn high waisted pants in the past, but these were a big flop.
Vintage Flare Jean
Free People
Size Worn: 25
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B
I adore this skirt!
One of my favorite rentals to date. Freaking adorable! Wore it with a navy v-neck T-shirt and neutral flats for work but could also easily dress it up with wedges and blouse or down with a vintage T-shirt and kicks. I got so many compliments. The buttons did do the pulling thing that some people mentioned even with correct sizing, but the belt was wide enough to easily cover them. I would say that this fits TTS but might suggest sizing up if you want to minimize any pulling. Absolutely something I would rent again and may even buy.
Alibi Striped Shelby Skirt
Tanya Taylor
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B
Voluminously wonderful.
I loved these pants but didn't get an compliments on them, so perhaps other people didn't love them on me as much as I did. They are a lot on a small frame, and perhaps they looked like they were wearing me as opposed to the other way around. While I had them -and because I loved them- I wore them multiple times with multiple top (denim shirt knotted at the waist, navy v neck, cream/navy/red print vintage t) and shoe (Converse, Birkenstock's, natural wedges). Will likely rent again because even if the world didn't love them, I did.
Tan Karate Pants
Tome
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B
I was expecting to be wowed.
This dress was Ok, but definitely didn't wow me. It was wearable and fit TTS, but I was expecting more.
Jasmine Wrap Dress
Diane von Furstenberg
Size Worn: 0
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B
It was...fine.
I was pretty underwhelmed by this dress. It wasn't horrible, but it wasn't great either. Print was...fine. Fit was...fine. (Runs a little big IMO, but it's pretty forgiving.) it was...fine.
Mixed Floral Print Dress
Scotch & Soda
Size Worn: XS
Usual Size: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Weight: 107lbs
Bust: 34B