Katie's Reviews
All reviews by Katie
TOP CONTRIBUTORTOP CONTRIBUTOR
120 reviews
Huge
I'm usually a size 4/6 and rented this in my 3rd trimester of pregnancy and it was so big. It fit my bump well but was loose overall, making it not very flattering. I'm not sure how someone could possibly wear it not pregnant
Member Fit Notes
Antibes Stripe Maxi
Rixo
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Cute with a baby bump
Rented in my 2nd trimester (sized up 1) and loved it. Not too short for daytime, even at 5’9
Member Fit Notes
Cely Mini Dress
Rixo x RTR
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Chest was weird
I wanted to love this, especially for maternity pictures. But the fit through the top was weird. The straps were pretty short an the smocking fell in an odd place that shortened my waist and was generally not flattering
Member Fit Notes
Smocked Tie Front Dress
Rosetta Getty x RTR
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Good for maternity
Wore for work and errands in my second trimester. Nothing special but it’s comfortable and versatile
Member Fit Notes
Boho Midi Dress
Marine Layer
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Runs small for maternity
I’m usually a size 4-6 and am early 2nd trimester so I ordered a small. They fit but were more snug in the hips that I expected and definitely would not fit much further into pregnancy
Member Fit Notes
Drapey Denim Pull On Pants
HATCH
Size Worn: 1
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Size down
Runs really big. I'm usually a 4-6 and am pregnant so I ordered a medium. They were comfy but huge
Wide Leg Drawcord Pant
Hunter
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Loved it
One of my favorites - would buy if it came on a darker wash. I wore this a ton both open and closed.
Member Fit Notes
Vesna Denim Jacket
Claudie Pierlot
Size Worn: 38
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Hated it
I thought this would be a versatile item I could wear for date night and the office. It ended up being neither - too matronly for date night, and too formal for the office. I also found it to be quite loose fitting in a way that was not flattering
Member Fit Notes
Isabel Dress
Derek Lam 10 Crosby
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Versatile
Cute and versatile - I wore this with athleisure, and also to the office. If between sizes, size down
Member Fit Notes
Tan Cargo Jacket
3.1 Phillip Lim
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Fitted top, huge bottoms
I rented this 2 years ago in a size 38 and found it ran slightly small through the torso. This time I rented it in a 40 and the torso area fit well, but the bottom section was large and extremely unflattering
Member Fit Notes
Logo Denim Jumpsuit
Sandro
Size Worn: 40
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Casual material
I rented rhis for the office and expected it to be blousier. It was stiff, boxy, and the material felt casual
Member Fit Notes
Rory Top
Hunter Bell
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Meh
I rented this because I needed more breastfeeding friendly dresses that I could wear on the weekends or to work. I liked the cut of the top half of this dress - the v neck was flattering but not too low for the office. I didn’t really like the bottom half - it was pretty sheer and I thought the tiering added weight through the hips. Wouldn’t rent again
Member Fit Notes
Ellery Floral Dress
Splendid
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Fun and flattering
Wore this for a summer bachelorette party and it was super fun and flattering. I’m 5’9 and it was a good party length without being ridiculously short. I also found the chest to be flattering without a bra. I’m a 4/6 with a DD cup and the Medium fit like a glove
Member Fit Notes
Sueno Long Sleeve Mini Dress
The Wolf Gang
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Sizing was off
I ordered 1 size up and they were too big in the waist - not unwearably big, but enough excess in the waist/stomach that I found them unflattering. The thighs and butt fit perfectly though, and I loved the length. So maybe rent your true size if you have super long skinny legs, and otherwise pass on these
Member Fit Notes
Scottie Wide-Leg Jeans
L'agence
Size Worn: 28
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Lots of compliments
Rented for a girls trip and ended up keeping through a few shipments because I kept getting compliments on these. They look a bit more polished than cutoffs and are TTS and flattering. I wish they were about 2 inches longer but I’m 5’9
Member Fit Notes
Pleated Short
7 For All Mankind
Size Worn: 27
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Very flattering
If between sizes, size up. I’m usually a 4/6 and the medium fit like a glove. I wish the pattern were more versatile (it’s very summery and daytimey) but I will rent again next summer. Form fitting but flattering and no bra needed
Member Fit Notes
Aurella Dress
Solid & Striped
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Runs really big
I’m usually a 4/6 - typically would rent a 6 in something like this since I’m a DD and breastfeeding. I ordered a 2 in this based on reviews and it was still roomy, even in the chest. I thought the extra volume made it unflattering, especially through the hips. Size down 2
Member Fit Notes
Flare Denim Midi Dress
Madewell
Size Worn: 2
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Unflattering and sheer
Ran big and was generally super unflattering on me. Adds a lot of volume around the waist and hips while flattening the butt. Also sheer, which worked over a bathing suit but was limiting
Member Fit Notes
Nitsan Parachute Trousers
Cinq à Sept
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Great for breastfeeding moms
Member Fit Notes
Button Front Utility Mini Dress
Derek Lam 10 Crosby x RTR
Size Worn: 6
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
One of my faves
One of my fave rentals ever. Love the color, super flattering cut, and super comfortable. Great length for tall girls and looked cute with sneakers, boots, or a heel
Member Fit Notes
Cutout Tie Waist Midi Dress
Derek Lam 10 Crosby x RTR
Size Worn: 42
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Great closet staple
Considered buying this one. Perfect oversized fit without being too boxy. Wore it with a mini dress on date night but would also be great for work.
Member Fit Notes
Agnes Denim Blazer
AFRM
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Don't size up
I sized up 1 based on other reviews and they were too big. I found them to be TTS. I liked the medium wash since most barrel leg jeans I've found are light wash, but they were generally unflattering. That may have been the sizing though -- overall, I didn't like them enough to re-rent in the proper size
Member Fit Notes
In Your Face Barrel Jeans
BLANKNYC
Size Worn: 28
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Cute preppy option
Wore this for a country club event and it was super cute and flattering. I wish it were long enough for work
Member Fit Notes
Striped Shirt Mini Dress
Maje
Size Worn: 38
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Totally sheer
I rented this for an event and it had 0 reviews so I knew it was risky. Unfortunately it was completely sheer. I wore it as a pool coverup and it was cute but otherwise unwearable
Member Fit Notes
Yellow Gianluca Dress
Ciao Lucia
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Perfect cocktail option
Flattering and sexy without being too much for a rehearsal/cocktail event. It's definitely thick and warm so might be too much for a summer event. I found it to run big (in a 4-6 and the small had room)
Member Fit Notes
Riley Dress
RHODE
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
So flattering
Wore this for a Palm Springs wedding. So flattering and the tie back makes it adjustable for any chest size. Did not need a bra or pasties because it was thick enough
Member Fit Notes
Talitha Dress
ASTR the Label
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Rented several times
These run TTS or slightly big. Flattering baggy jean if you’re tall. Perfect balance of loose through the leg but fitted enough on the butt to be flattering.
Member Fit Notes
Superwide-Leg Jeans
Madewell
Size Worn: 27
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Flattering but matronly
This was super flattering, but a lot more matronly than I expected. I ended up opting for something else because it didn’t feel age appropriate, even as a 31yo. My husband called it a ‘mother of the groom’ dress with I agree with.
Member Fit Notes
Rafaela Maxi
Black Halo
Size Worn: 6R
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Great staple jacket
Great black jacket that looks and feels high end. Took off one star because the pockets aren't really functional, which was annoying
Member Fit Notes
Hybrid Tweed Moto Jacket With Leather Details
3.1 Phillip Lim
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Itchy
I found this to be very itchy and generally unflattering. I didn't expect it to be super flattering (it's an oversized sweater) but it hit right at the hip in a way that looked especially bulky
Member Fit Notes
Flag Sweater
Tommy Hilfiger
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Cute but massive
Really cozy and easy to throw on over activewear to look a bit more put together than a sweatshirt. It's massive though. I'm 5'9 and the XXS was really oversized on me, making it impossible to dress up or wear with anything other than leggings
Member Fit Notes
Chunky Cable Knit Sweater
WEWOREWHAT
Size Worn: XXS-XS
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
If between sizes, size up
I'm a 4-6 and usually get a small in sweaters but I got a medium in this based on availability. The medium fit well, and a small would've been too tight in the chest
Member Fit Notes
Crew Neck Cardigan With Black Piping
Eudon Choi x RTR
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Size up 1
Member Fit Notes
Minka Cargo
AGOLDE
Size Worn: 28
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Great athleisure
Great way to dress up athletic wear a bit. Wore this a ton
Member Fit Notes
Dove Faux Shearling Vest
Sandy Liang
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Repeat rental
I've rented this multiple winters now. It's cute and festive but neutral. I think it runs small - I'm a 4/6 and find the large to have the perfect slightly oversized fit
Member Fit Notes
Wool Logo Cardigan
GANNI
Size Worn: L
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Very oversized
Cute and versatile but very oversized and boxy - if between sizes, size down
Member Fit Notes
Classic Bomber Jacket
Great Jones
Size Worn: S
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Not for tall girls
Wore this to the office in my third trimester. It was okay but at 5,9, it hit at a weird place on the leg that made my legs look shorter
Member Fit Notes
The Gemma Dress
Pietro Brunelli Milano
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Good staple for late pregnancy
Great staple for the end of pregnancy when bump is super prominent. Wore this with leggings to the gym and on errands; also dressed it up for the office
Member Fit Notes
Black Diana Maternity Turtleneck
soon maternity
Size Worn: M
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Size up
Very cute, flattering, and comfortable in 1 size up
Member Fit Notes
Mara Jeans
AGOLDE
Size Worn: 28
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D
Great for tall girls
TTS and the perfect length for me at 5’9. Was able to wear these with sneakers or a small heel
Member Fit Notes
Hepburn Wide Leg Light Wash Jeans
DL1961
Size Worn: 27
Usual Size: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Bust: 34D