Jay Godfrey

Out of Your League Dress

$50 to buy
$395 retail

This style is currently unavailable.

Shop all dresses

Stylist Notes

Show up in style with this one shoulder belted dress from Jay Godfrey. Go for a monochromatic look with Kendra Scott's Green Stone Bib Necklace and finish your look with the Kate Spade's Flicker Gold Monette Clutch.

Size & Fit

This dress runs true to size. We recommend going one size up for backup (see following fit notes for exceptions). Sized 0-12.

BUST: Great for any cup size - fitted at bust so fuller busted women should consider sizing up
WAIST: Fitted - fitted at natural waist; belt is adjustable and removable
HIPS: Not fitted - skirt may be more fitted on curvier women
LENGTH: Mid-thigh length - (on a 5'5" model)

UNDERGARMENTS: Should be worn with a strapless bra
FABRIC: Fabric has no stretch
GREAT FOR: All body types

Model's height is 5'10''.

Product Details

Green and black stretch crepe. One shoulder neckline. Removable belt at waist with stitching detail. Hook-and-eye closure. Hidden side zip. 35'' from shoulder to hem. Imported.

Share
50 reviews
Fit
Large
(6)
True to Size
(39)
Small
(5)
Size worn:
10
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 8
Height: 5' 0"
Age: 39
Bust size: 38D
Body type: Petite
March 7, 2012
Pretty but never worn
I ordered this for a cocktail party (sizes 8 & 10). I normally wear a size 8 but with a 36D cup. The dress looked and felt great but I could not zip the 8 or the 10 over my bust.
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 4
Height: 5' 5"
Age: 44
Body type: Athletic
Weight: 137lbs
March 18, 2012
Had several girlfriends tell me dress was "amazing!"
Dress fit really well. Definitely on the short side, a bit shorter than I expected. But it got a ton of compliments. Necklace looked amazing with it.
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
4
Overall fit:
Large
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 4
Height: 5' 7"
Age: 46
Bust size: 36A
Body type: Pear
Weight: 144lbs
March 21, 2012
Loved it!
I had to wear the backup size in the smaller size as I am very small chested. Even so, it was a bit large in the bust. I'm a bit pear shaped so the a-line skirt was ideal. Pretty short in a size 4 but it got rave reviews! Very comfortable and easy to wear. The skirt has some stretch in it so I think it's pretty forgiving.
Size worn:
4
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 5"
Age: 35
Bust size: 34C
Body type: Athletic
Weight: 122lbs
April 27, 2012
Great dress
I was super comfortable in this dress and having a larger bust and smaller waist, it was a perfect fit. I recieved a lot of compliments because it was so unique and fit great!
Top Contributor
Size worn:
0
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usually wears: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Age: 31
Bust size: 32A
Body type: Petite
Weight: 110lbs
May 9, 2012
always having something new to wear:)
I wore this dress to a wedding and I got a lot of compliments on it. It is not as short as it appears in the picture, so it was definitely wedding appropriate. The green was not as vibrant as in the photo and the strings that hold up the dress on hangers kept slipping out, which was pretty annoying. I would recommend taping the strings. Other than that, it was pretty!
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 0
Height: 5' 4"
Age: 37
Bust size: 32B
Body type: Pear
June 28, 2012
Great dress for girl's night
Wore this dress to my friend's bachelorette party. It fit very well. A little short, but it worked for a girl's night out. I ended up not wearing the belt because I wore a necklace that looked a little much when I had the belt on. I just tucked the top over the bottom a little so you wouldn't see the belt loops.
Top Contributor
Size worn:
0
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usually wears: 0
Height: 5' 3"
Age: 31
Bust size: 32C
Body type: Petite
Weight: 125lbs
August 20, 2012
Classy Yet Cute Party Dress
I rented this for my dad's wedding rehearsal dinner and it was a hit! I wore a strapless bra with it and it fit perfectly. It's a great dress that is a perfect combination between classy and cute/trendy.
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 5"
Age: 36
Bust size: 36D
Body type: Athletic
Weight: 145lbs
August 29, 2012
Very flattering!
This was 1 of 2 dresses for my 1st RTR experience for a bach party w/e. Got a TON of compliments on this dress, and the bow (that at first I didn't think I was going to like) ended up looking really cute once I saw it on! The dress is super comfy, especially for a night of drinking (in other words, won't see a bloated beer belly b/c of the a-line :-) Great dress!
View photos (1)
Size worn:
0
Overall fit:
Large
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 2
Height: 5' 3"
Bust size: 34C
Body type: Petite
Weight: 120lbs
September 11, 2012
loved it!
;)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Other
Usually wears: 2
Height: 5' 5"
Age: 33
Bust size: 34B
Body type: Athletic
Weight: 130lbs
October 1, 2012
So appropriate....
I'm a teacher and I wore this to chaperone a cruise around Manhattan with the senior class. I thought this dress was an appropriate length with just a little bit of trendy to it. It was a hit with the seniors and the other chaperones and none of the administrators had an issue with the bare shoulder. I also coach softball at the school so I loved the little belt. It looked like a cute little play on the stitches of a softball. Fit great. Great color. Totally comfortable and not too short on me.
View photos (1)
Size worn:
8
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usually wears: 8
Height: 5' 4"
Age: 42
Body type: Full Bust
October 11, 2012
seriously received tons of compliments on this dress!
it is short, so very self-conscious while dancing with my daughters, but very comfortable to wear!
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
4
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usually wears: 4
Height: 5' 9"
Age: 30
Bust size: 34A
Body type: Athletic
Weight: 130lbs
December 10, 2012
Good dress. Not a winner.
The dress fit well in the waist and the length was perfect. However, the top of the dress was a little loose around the sleeve and fabric made the dress look loose (even though it was the right size).
Top Contributor
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 2
Height: 5' 1"
Age: 34
Bust size: 32B
Body type: Petite
Weight: 105lbs
December 17, 2012
I wanted to love this dress, but the stitching in the bust made it too inappropriate
This is certainly a pretty dress, but the look was NOT cute on me, due to some very awkward stitching in the bust. I rented it for my husband's work party and, turns out, it was NSFW! I tried maneuvering the dress, wearing a different bra, smoothing out the crease -- nothing worked. So, sadly, I couldn't wear it. Love RTR, though, as I got a refund on the dress and the purse that I had rented to match it. I didn't check the size 0 to see if it had the same problem, but the picture shows me in the size 2. Weird nip aside, I probably would have gotten a 2 and a 4 if I were ordering again. Was a tad tight.
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
Large
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 8
Height: 5' 8"
Age: 37
Bust size: 34B
Body type: Hourglass
Weight: 155lbs
December 18, 2012
I rocked my college reunion with this hot number.
This dress was more than I expected. It does a little large if you have a small chest. My only complaint was that the side of the dress without the strap kept falling down. It was a minor annoyance. With my height the dress was short, but not inappropriate. Had to be careful when I sat down! I would definitely rent this again for a more casual event where I wanted to stand out.
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
0
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 0
Height: 5' 3"
Age: 32
Bust size: 32C
Body type: Petite
Weight: 105lbs
December 21, 2012
Perfect for a holiday work event!
I wore this dress for my husband's holiday work party - figured it was conservative enough while still being interesting and flattering. I'm petite and the dress felt short, but I think that was more due to the A-line bottom than the actual length. The white belt is perfect - it makes the dress look complete while also being functional and alllowing you to cinch in the waist/make the dress fit even better. The dress made it through a rainstorm on the way to the party and still looked fine for the rest of the night...wish I could say the same for my hair!
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
8
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 8
Height: 5' 0"
Age: 35
Body type: Petite
January 10, 2013
Wore this on a night out in Vegas with the matching necklace - LOVED IT
The dress is super cute and different. I think the belt makes it sexy and with the suggested earrings and necklace I felt like a fashionista :)
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usually wears: 2
Height: 5' 5"
Age: 30
Bust size: 34A
Body type: Athletic
Weight: 120lbs
January 27, 2013
Feeling confident reading in front of all the guests at the wedding during the service
This dress fit great and it was perfect for the Labor Day wedding...I received so many compliments throughout the night. The dress fit like a glove, but it was not restricting by any means. It was nice and light too, which was great because it was very hot the day of the wedding. I wore the dress with nude heels and a chunky gold necklace.
Top Contributor
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 4"
Age: 27
Bust size: 34D+
Body type: Hourglass
Weight: 140lbs
April 7, 2013
Loved this dress...not a fan of the belt it came with, so I found my own to use.
I wore this dress for my bachelorette party in Chicago...I could not have been happier with it!!! So gorgeous!!! I wore a size 6, and I was surprised to find the top was a little big (which is shocking since I am pretty busty up top). I also wasn't a huge fan of the belt that the dress came with, so I added my own! I could not have been happier! I would highly recommend this cute little number any day!
View photos (1)
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 7"
Age: 26
Bust size: 34C
Body type: Hourglass
Weight: 150lbs
April 9, 2013
Ready to look SKINNY SKINNY SKINNY!
This was the cutest dress I have ever worn! I got complements all night, and it makes your waist look tiny! Both women AND men gave me compliments! I wish I had the money to buy this one.
Top Contributor
Size worn:
8
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Vacation
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 3"
Age: 40
Bust size: 34D
Body type: Pear
Weight: 137lbs
May 10, 2013
Didn't end up wearing.
Cute dress, but I did not end up wearing it. It kept on riding up while I was walking around and I didn't want to have to constant,y be pulling it down throughout the night, so I did t wear. It was also a little baggy in the chest, but tight in my tummy.
Size worn:
10
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 10
Height: 5' 8"
Age: 36
Bust size: 36C
Body type: Pear
Weight: 170lbs
December 16, 2013
Loved it!!
Great dress!! It is pretty short so I had to be cautious not to lean forward. Other than that, the fit was good and I felt great in it!!
View photos (1)
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 7"
Age: 31
Bust size: 36D
Body type: Full Bust
Weight: 135lbs
April 11, 2014
I switched the belt for a black patent leather belt.
Fit really well and very flattering.
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
Small
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 10
Height: 5' 1"
Age: 26
Bust size: 34D
Body type: Full Bust
Weight: 165lbs
January 1, 2014
Wore this to a New Years Eve Party on the LV Strip. It was PERFECT!
It was a bit tight around the bust and the waist but overall incredibly comfortable. I tried it with a couple of other belts but the one it came with worked best.
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
12
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 12
Height: 5' 5"
Age: 37
Bust size: 36D
Body type: Hourglass
Weight: 157lbs
January 19, 2014
felt like a million bucks. great rental
rented two sizes the ten fit but the zipper was stuck so I had to were the 12. little loose up top but some fashion tape and a white sport coat hid any bagginess. very short.
Top Contributor
Size worn:
None
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Formal Affair
Usually wears: 4
Height: 5' 3"
Age: 25
Bust size: 34D
Body type: Hourglass
Weight: 120lbs
March 12, 2014
Good dress!
Didn't end up wearing this but it fit fairly true to size. I wasn't a huge fan of the belt that came with it but it is still a great dress!
Top Contributor
Size worn:
8
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Date
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 8"
Age: 30
Bust size: 34D
Body type: Hourglass
Weight: 150lbs
May 6, 2014
Very short
The size 6 fit fine but was obscenely short so I wore the size 8, which was still quite short. My boyfriend did not mind this at all. It was a very cute and comfortable dress but I would not wear it again because it was so short that I had to be careful while dancing. Maybe it was just because I have long legs though.
Top Contributor
Size worn:
0
Overall fit:
Large
Rented for:
Wedding
Usually wears: 0
Height: 5' 3"
Age: 31
Bust size: 32A
Body type: Petite
Weight: 105lbs
May 15, 2014
Big in the bust
Loved the dress, the color was really nice however the bust was very big.
Top Contributor
Size worn:
4
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 4
Height: 5' 6"
Bust size: 34B
Body type: Athletic
Weight: 125lbs
June 7, 2014
I felt classy and sexy at the same time
The dress looks exactly like in the photos, except that the green is a lil brighter. I usually wear size 4 and that's the size I ended up wearing, dress was a lil big on the chest area for me but fitting as an overall was good. I loved the contrast of the white belt and the length of the dress, it's short as I wanted it. I would totally recommend this dress for a party.
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
None
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 4
Height: 5' 6"
Age: 38
Bust size: 34C
Body type: Hourglass
Weight: 129lbs
August 12, 2014
Underwhelmed.
I had been eyeing this dress for a while so figured I'd try it. It was in perfectly fine condition but overall I felt it was kinda "meh." Didn't really do anything for me. The belt was way yuckier than in pictures but could easily be swapped out with another or just go without.
Top Contributor
Size worn:
8
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Date
Usually wears: 8
Height: 5' 3"
Age: 48
Bust size: 36D
Body type: Petite
Weight: 140lbs
August 12, 2014
Loved this dress!
Great dress. Wore it for a special dinner date. Green color stood out. Skirt is super short so be careful when moving about.
Top Contributor
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Age: 33
Bust size: 34D
Body type: Petite
Weight: 132lbs
September 23, 2014
Wore this dress for my birthday party, it was perfect!
Got tons of compliments. Very comfy and cute. Also flattering!
View photos (2)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
NONE
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Wedding
Usually wears: 4
Height: 5' 1"
Age: 32
Bust size: 36DD
Body type: Petite
Weight: 125lbs
October 9, 2014
Adorable..didn't wear it though
I really loved this dress it fit great even in the chest area. Didn't have an issue with the shoulder strap as I normally do bc I'm petite...just wasn't formal enough for me to wear to a wedding.
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
Large
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 0"
Age: 39
Bust size: 32D
Body type: Hourglass
Weight: 130lbs
December 15, 2014
This dress made me look and feel great!
This dress was perfect for my birthday party. Its just the right amount of sass and class. Note to potential renters: This is a short dress. I am only 5ft and it still hit above my mid thigh. It was also a little big on top, but nothing a little bit of fashion tape couldn't fix. I loved it! Thank you!
View photos (2)
Size worn:
None
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 2
Height: 5' 3"
Age: 27
Bust size: 34D
Body type: Athletic
Weight: 120lbs
March 25, 2016
Cute, just not my style.
This dress is really cute, but I just didn't like it as much in person as I thought I would. It fit really well (true to size) and the fabric is great quality. Just wasn't my style!
Top Contributor
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 10
Height: 5' 9"
Age: 32
Body type: Athletic
Weight: 160lbs
March 26, 2012
I felt like the perfect bachelorette! Ready to party, yet still very classy! Super fun dress for an unforgettable night!
I wore this dress for my bachelorette party on St. Patrick's Day. I loved it! The fit was great, although it was a little short (I am 5'9" but was wearing 4" heels). I probably would not have worn it for anything other than a bachelorette party because of the length. It was perfect for the night though and I received several compliments! All of my bridesmaids and even strangers now know about RTR!
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
10
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Date
Usually wears: 10
Height: 5' 5"
Age: 30
Bust size: 36B
Body type: Hourglass
April 5, 2012
Wearing the perfect dress for a perfect night!
I rented this dress for a trip to Atlanta to see my boyfriend. This was my first rental from rtr and it was great. I also rented the necklace that is recommended and I have to say that it really made the dress!The overall fit of the dress was great, although the top was a little big. Overall I got compliments on my dress and I didn't want to take it off!
View photos (1)
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Vacation
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 5"
Age: 33
Bust size: 34A
Body type: Pear
Weight: 134lbs
September 12, 2012
This was a perfect dress for a girl's night out!
The black material is a little clingy. The belt was the perfect addition to the dress! It is shorter than I expected.
View photos (1)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Party
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 5"
Age: 28
Bust size: 34C
Body type: Hourglass
Weight: 140lbs
April 8, 2013
Loved It!
This was a fun dress I wore to my cousin's engagement party. I got so many compliments the whole night. I would recommend it!
View photos (2)
Top Contributor
Size worn:
6
Overall fit:
True to Size
Rented for:
Other
Usually wears: 6
Height: 5' 2"
Age: 39
Bust size: 34B
Body type: Pear
Weight: 127lbs
November 26, 2013
Flattering & fun
I wore this out for dinner & drinks on my birthday. I ordered the 6 and 8, and ended up wearing the 6. The 6 was a little shorter than I am usually comfortable with, but since I was wearing black tights and the top fit my small chest much better than the 8, I went with the 6. It was flattering and comfortable, and I got lots of compliments. Four stars instead of five because I don't think it's absolutely the most best fitting style for a short girl like me (my torso is probably a little too short), but I enjoyed it.
View photos (1)
Size worn:
2
Overall fit:
Large
Rented for:
Wedding
Usually wears: 4
Height: 5' 3"
Age: 25
Bust size: 34B
Body type: Petite
Weight: 120lbs
July 9, 2014
Fit wasn't right
I am usually between a 2 and a 4; I wore the 2 and it was still quite baggy in the chest (I'm a 34B). It's a pretty dress, but the fit just wasn't right. I didn't feel super confident in this dress.
View photos (1)
See more reviews:
1 / 2

NEW! Add your favorites to a shortlist to organize for upcoming occasions.

Click a <3 to start!

×

We created a shortlist for

Click the <3 to save your favorites

×