I loved this top and I got so many compliments on it. Classic silhouette but cute with the low V. I wore to work with jeans and a tank top underneath so it didn’t show off too much. I was worried the xs/s would be fitted or small but it was perfectly large and oversized. I like things pretty oversized on me, but if you’re small and don’t want it oversized there probably will not be a good size for you.

i really liked this top, it was different but still on trend. it is very deep-v in the front and i had to adjust a lot but overall great for a spring day!

I sized up for an oversized fit and loved the look. I can definitely be a bit pirate-y but I loved the quality of the shirt and it gave me something unique to wear besides a plane button down.

I actually liked how different it was, didn’t think it was too pirate-y. If you love a crisp shirt then this is not the one for you (even with starch and an ironing session).

Okay I could have used a steam on this shirt but I was crunched for time and so be it. My friend also had this top at home and we agreed it’s kind of pirate vibes with the wide sleeves, but I still loved it non the less. I preferred it untucked but if I had gone for the smaller size I would have like to try it tucked in as well. This was a win for me! Follow @confessionsofarentaholic for more.

I liked this top, but would have liked it even more if the sleeves weren’t SO LONG! I thought that it would be silky, but it’s a sturdy cotton material. I rented a M-L but would size down next time.

Opted for this because I loved the big collar even though the reviews said the shirt itself was huge. And it was big! I wore it once to work and had to wear a cami underneath to cover my bra. I liked it enough, but I didn’t feel the shirt was very flattering on me, being so oversized. Still, I got a lot of compliments. All in all, it was good, not great.

perfect for a dinner or to dress up to go out

Never thought a man would be into the pirate look in everyday wear

Wasn’t sure about this but loved it when it arrived.

.

Looks cute on model, but it’s big in person. Too big to tuck in and look right. It was even an xs/s.

Sized down per other reviews and still felt like I was swimming in it. Liked the concept but had trouble styling.

Shirt was much thicker and bulkier than anticipated, looked like captain jack sparrow lol couldn’t get myself to wear it

Needed to size down didnt wear

I really wanted this to work, but it just made me feel like a little lad who loves berries and cream.

This is unbelievably big, cute style, size down! Couldn’t wear

Didn’t care for this shirt. It is oversized and the sleeves which I’m sure are meant to be super long - I found to be annoying. I didn’t wear it

Ironing/steaming required. Very thick fabric which makes the tuck challenging, but so cute once set. It is lower than you may think so maybe not office appropriate. Love the extra-long sleeves and giant lapel. I received compliments while walking down the street!

This shirt is too big. The way it’s styled on RTR is definitely pinned and unrealistic

Not flattering

The shirt runs larger than expected and wrinkles easily, which makes it harder to keep looking crisp. The collar is also longer than I anticipated, which changes the overall look.

Doesn't look great on