I think this should be one of my fall staples. Love the thickness, love the cut and I love how effortless it looks.

This sweater is sooooo cute. But if u want it to go over your hips and u wear a sizse 8 pant or above size up at least one size. I'm a small on top normally but this didn't work because of the tight bottom. Otherwise the cut was fabulous and the fabric was comfortable. I would rent it again in a different size.

Listen, unless you have no hips, it doesn't fit like it does on the model. Hard fact. But, it's still cute, unique, and relatively comfortable. I enjoyed it so much, I bought it. Removed a star for not being photographed...realistically.

Recommend sizing up it is more form fitting on the bottom and doesn't have give.

Didn't drape right on me. Need to size up to M.

Very small for a size large. Photo made this seem very drapey and loose, in reality it was too tight at the bottom to fit over my hips and definitely did not go "off shoulder". Kinda bummed.

Tight around waist and rides up.

I wish this sweater had more stretch to it. If it did, I would totally buy it. It ended up feeling very restrictive and the waist kept riding up. I should have sized up.

Could not get this on - opening at bottom barely went over my shoulders .... was weird on my waist or hips

I was not able to wear this sweater. The shape and fit of it was nothing like the image. The waist and neck openings were very small so the neck but not drape off shoulder and the angled part that should drape over your hip was stuck at the waist

Runs small. Normally wear a small or medium and probably could have gotten a large. But still super cute. I'll keep it for a couple wears!

Arms are a bit tight, but the tight size in the hips and the off the shoulder look was great - loved it!

Loved this so much I bought it! The bottom does fit snug (not at all like the pic). But for tall girls, that means it fits well through the waist & gives some shape. Husband loved it!!

Versatile, worn to work with a pencil skirt then worn to dinner with jeans and boots.

I've worn this a zillion times (still have it). It looks really great with leggings or skinny jeans. It hits at just the right spot to make your tush look great. It's also incredibly comfortable (don't need to wear a bra). Can be a little restricting when lifting your arms so if you are planning on dancing or high-giving a bunch, may not be the best option.

Casual and subtly sexy, this top is great. I've rented it in navy and black now and have worn it on multiple occasions. Highly recommend. Arms and bottom are a bit tight, but otherwise fits true to size.

I immediately rented this again. Loved it with jeans or leggings.

it was good

So yes, the bottom of the shirt is snug. And if you get it pulled down below your rump the full effect of the sweater is beautiful. I didn't have full range of my arm when you put the shirt on right...but it did look great. Next time I'll size up!

Great neckline but a little tight in the arms and the hips but overall loved the look

Looks great with jeans.

I loved the fit and the look of this sweater, but didn't get any pictures, as I was layered up with jackets most of the day. It fits very tight throughout the arms and has a super small opening at the hips, so if you're between a small and a medium I would recommend sizing up!

the fit is weird and it doesn't fall the way it does on the shoulder naturally, you have to keep pulling it down on that side and its pretty fitted around the hips but overall I liked how it looked on me so I just put up with the bit of weirdness.

I actually really loved this sweater. The neckline was sexy but sophisticated. My problem was the same problem everyone else had. It doesn't fit at all like it does in the picture. There's a thick heavy seam that runs through the bottoms that doesn't allow it move below your hips. Again, I actually liked the way it DID fit, it just didn't fit like that. It's like that model is an XS and she's wearing an XL.

For a top that looks roomy and comfortable, it ran quite small. I would have preferred to size up to get the slouchy look in the photo.

The sweater is very cute, but fit much tighter on the bottom than expected. In the picture the sweater extends down to her thigh mine sat on my hips. It wasn't necessarily bad, just not what I expected.

It runs small so go with your regular size or a size up even though it's an oversized sweater. It was very flattering to my curvy figure. I should have gone with a L though because I wanted a more one shoulder look. Best with heels if you're short so to not look overwhelmed. I'm going to try the navy in L next.

I've worn this 3x now to various parties, first with black faux leather leggings and then 2x with jeans. The first time, I did my best to wear it like in the model's picture (ie., sleeves and body pulled all the way down). I have narrow hips and really had to pull to get the tight waist over my hips. With the sleeves down, it's impossible to raise your arms to hug someone or to put on a winter jacket. So the next time I gave up on pulling both down and was much happier with the functionality and feel: the top's waist was around my waist and the sleeves were like 3/4 sleeves. The off-the-shoulder did not stay off the shoulder for more than 10 minutes at a time... was constantly readjusting it. And one side had a huge 12" slit that showed bare skin when your arm is partially raised, and your side breast when arm is raised higher. Wearing something under it other than a NuBra (which I did) or strapless bra is not possible given the neckline/off the shoulder feature. The material is nice and soft however and it is a trendy look. I'll probably wear it one more time before sending it back.

Loved the look of this and when you had it adjusted just so it looked fab (and very flattering!) but... once on you can't move one arm above waist height and god knows how you are supposed to keep it on your shoulder... wanted to love it but just found myself adjusting non stop. Plus... I like having use of both of my arms...

Cute sweater. But not as long as imagined and felt snugger fit than imagined how it's supposed to look.

I think it runs like a medium but I like my sweaters a size up. I'm hourglass shaped, so the bottom fit my waist a little awkwardly.

Ribbed knit that doesn't stretch.

Very cute. Need to get a bigger size for it to fit comfortably

I really wanted to love this sweater and may have if I'd order one size larger. It fits very tight in the bottom. I struggled to pull the bottom over my hips and I normally wear a small in tops. There's zero stretch.

It's a unique cut, that's for sure. I loved the style and fit of it. It was perfect for photos, but I must say, due to the cut of the sleeves - you cannot raise your hands above your head. (Reason for the 3 stars rating.) The baggy sleeves are connected too low on the body of the sweater. Beautiful? Yes! Practical? No. Still, I'm glad I rented it.

I thought the sweater was super cute, and wish it was a bit more functional. Like the other reviews said, it's a bit snug around the hips - but this didn't bother me much. I wore a M (like I usually do), and it did fall off the shoulder. But, if I ever lifted my arms, the sweater would move around and just look loose and unflattering... I could try sizing up to see if the shoulder would stay put, but then I worry the rest of it would look too oversized. I probably won't rent this again, sadly...

Although I did enjoy how this top fit me, it did not fit as pictured. Runs small therefore it did not go off the shoulder. I still think it was a cute look but don't expect it to look as pictured.

Cute but runs very small around the hips. Also, shoulder opening is tight.

If you want a loose fit, especially at the bottom...this sweater fits very small. It hugged my hips and didn't have the loose, comfortable fit shown on the model.

The bottom is super tight and it's hard to lift your arms. I thought it would be more tunic or softer.