this coat is amazing, it has a slightly boxy, oversized fit which is why i decided to order the xs and I'm glad I did - I've been wearing it all week and am very pleased - it's warm too :-)

I was expecting higher quality from Vince, one of my favorite brands...especially at the original price point. It's an easy jacket to wear, but I was cold on a 35 degree day in Boston with a cashmere turtleneck underneath. The fabric seems a bit cheap, and the faux shearling is not soft. I wore it twice...nice enough for work but casual enough for weekend. I usually wear a 4-6 and the small was roomy enough for a thick sweater. Also, this jacket is pretty short so my midsection was chilly. It has slash pockets so everything falls out, and they aren't big enough for a phone.

The jacket fit true to size. I really liked the look of it. One weird thing - the pockets were very small. You couldn't fit your hands all the way in them and you certainly couldn't put a phone in them. But other than that I really liked the jacket.

I LOVED this coat. It was super comfortable, stylish, and warm. It went with everything I owned. I had such an easy time styling this piece - both for an every day look and going out. I'm highly considering buying!

This coat was great, wore it so many times! The fit was a tad big in the sleeve length but really loved it overall

LOVE this jacket. I will be hanging on to it for awhile longer. Great fit, super cool and super warm! Wore it with leather leggings and a longer sequin top.

Very warm and cozy. Fun for dinner over a sweater or top.

it was comfy. not to warm or to light.

Loved this one, but I ended changing it for a longer one. It's very comfortable and warm and looks very chic and good quality. It's short though, so your butt will be cold ;)

Warm but not thick. Cute for everyday

Loved that I could layer with it.

It is very cute and is very warm and well made. I got many compliments on it. I didn't take a photo. I will next time I wear it.

Super comfy; I wore it all day - sort of in between a winter coat / blazer. The shearling is very soft.

This jacket was great- very versatile for day and night. It's wool with shearling collar and worked well for temps between 30-50.

Wore this rental the most. Comfy and warm for everyday wear. Also received compliments on it. Loved!

This coat runs a bit large but I love to layer in the colder months so that's just fine with me (I can fit my chunkiest knits underneath without any issues or loss in mobility). It kept me warm in chilly temps and the collar is a great statement --- I made it stand and it kept my ears and face warm in the wind. I'd definitely recommend this jacket as a casual everyday piece.

Really cute and actually warm! Slightly more cropped than it looked so it worked better with dresses than sweaters

I can't say enough great things about this jacket! Sophisticated with an edge and keeps you warm!

This coat is honestly amazing. Such great qualiy and fit and you look super polished. It's on the shorter side so you can see youre waist/rear end which is great! It's actually super warm - wore this in europe when it was 25-35 degrees and was totally fine (with scarf and hat).

I love Vince, and I really wanted this to work. Its very "cocoon" shaped and its very short! I'm short, so be prepared if you are taller than I am. If it wasn't for the length I probably would have kept it, it seems warm and the fit overall was nice.

I ordered a Small and could have easily ordered the XS with still plenty of room. As someone that likes this fitted things (totally game for a snug fitted jacket), I was initially surprised at how large this jacket is, but have warmed up to it, and now its my favorite. If I were to sum it up, its wool coat meets motorcycle jacket. Perfect for everyday wear, or a night out. FYI I would say the Small fits more like a Large.

This was brand new. It sits a little short and the top is a bit bulky. But it's a good casual jacket for everyday. I returned it because it wasn't quite cold enough daily, but I would consider renting this again when the weather changes

I'll be renting this jacket again really soon. It arrived brand new! The details and the fur are really stylish and the jacket is extremely well made. It was super warm, too! I liked that it looked dressy over a work dress and casual over a sweater and jeans. Can't recommend it enough.

I rented this on a whim. I dont want to give it back! Ive worn it everyday. Perfect for NYC fall weather. Makes any outfit look a bit edgier

So cozy and luxurious. Could have kept all winter. Fits well, looks cool, just an overall great jacket.

This jacket can be dressed up or down. I wore it to work with a red dress, like the photo. I later wore it with jeans and it was fabulous. The fabric is heavy and warm, a perfect jacket for fall. It arrived new with tags, and I hated to send it back. It runs large, so size down for a good fit.

This jacket is super cute. It's more cropped than I realized, but looks great with a pair of high waisted jeans.

This is a good coat for layering, as the body is boxy and allows room for a sweater underneath. As many mentioned, it looks best unzipped, and if you do zip it, the collar doesn't lie flat. Definitely doesn't feel like a $750 piece of outerwear, and therefore perfect for renting.

Great jacket but too boxy for my body type. It's not a fitted piece and was too large for me though I needed this size for my shoulders. Just not the right style for me.

I liked this jacket, Vince clothing does normally run a little large on me so maybe I should have sized down. It fit well standing up but sitting down was very roomy and since it's a stiff wool coat it wanted to ride up kind of like swimming with a life jacket on if that makes sense.

I would have kept this if I have unlimited pieces instead of just 4 with RTR :). Definitely a heavy coat for winter, the fabric is quite nice as I assume there had been a lot of wear already but there is no visible sign of pilling, a big + and the cut is also quite nice. It will be a good everyday coat. The sleeves are a bit long for petite.

Wasn't a great cut for me but cute overall.

I normally wear a sz small - I should have gone with an xs in this item. It goes well with everything - casual to dress up.

I really liked this coat, it's great for everyday. The collar has nice fur on it and the sleeves feel like suede (note sure what they actually are made of). I wore this with jeans for one outfit and a dress for another. Definitely a cute, under-stated coat for fall/spring.

Love the look -- would have sizes down

The material thickness meant it laid very clunky. Couldn't wear

I rented a size small and it fits more like an XL...despite being a looser style, it sort of just looks like I'm wearing the wrong size. Overall it's a cute style, but I can only come up with 1 or 2 outfits that actually work with such a boxy piece. Won't be renting again.

pockets are super shallow on this, which I don't love. It's an OK jacket overall, though.

I like my coats well fitted. This one felt big and the sleeves were too long. As always, the VINCE material was high-quality and the jacket was definitely toasty warm.

Fits TTS, but it's pretty cropped/short - best to wear with slim, high-waisted bottoms.