I ended up liking this, but I expected it to be thicker, warmer based in other reviews. The lining was a little crooked as well.

A bit different from my usual style. Loved the plaid and faux wrap. The waist was a bit too big though.

Enjoyed this. I'm tall and it came mid calf.

Loved this skirt and got a lot of compliments. It's often hard to find good a-line midis that have minimal volume, and I appreciated that with the drape effect in the front and pattern, the cut kept it sleek when it could have been frumpy. This fits pretty true to size, maybe runs big. I have wide hips and a really small waist so even a-line cuts can cling to my hips/thighs and droop on my waist. Only gave it a 4 because the gauzy material is a little too thin and wrinkle and pill prone.

This skirt ran a little large for me. I'm usually a size 4, which is the size I ordered in this. But the waist felt large, and the skirt fell to my natural hips instead of my waist, which is where I thought it should sit. At least it looked much better higher. The material is very thin and feels cheap. The length wasn't great for my petite height, but that happens a lot for me (I'm 5'3"). I also thought the skirt was grey and black, but it's actually grey and navy. No biggie, just FYI.

The fabric is almost flannely. Runs a little big- in waist and through hips. Perfect for fall! There IS a thin brown stripe running through the plaid pattern. Would look cute with riding boots and a chunky sweater. it does wrinkle a little easily and i pinned the front flap closed so it would hang correctly.

Wore this with a sweater and boots for a great fall look

This was a pretty skirt for work, paired with a fitted brown sweater and brown suede boots.

Comfortable easy skirt, looked great with a fuzzy sweater and some boots for work

The fir was not right for my body type

I didn’t end up wearing this one. The fit was so so and the material was oddly thin given its a cooler weather flannel fabric.

This skirt is ok. Definitely fits big, not very flattering

Stylish and comfortable. Perfect for a cozy chic look at work or on the weekends. Wore with heeled boots and sneakers -- both looked great.

I did not realize this was a blue skirt and not black. Still super cute and comfy. I would suggest either a tan or navy blouse or sweater.

Great quality material and perfect fit at my natural waist. Looks really cute with a chunky sweater and boots!

I will definitely rent again. Perfect skirt. Good with sneakers or boots.

I love Vince, because I know the fabrics are always going to be amazing. This was super soft and flattering. Paired up with a cashmere sweater and sleek combat boots.

Would be great for an office day or weekend brunch

Fits great on my pear-shaped hips. Hits about mid-calf on me.

Fit well. easy fabric.

Cute skirt but I didn't wear it - too large in the waist (I'm usually size 24 in jeans for reference).

Cute but forgettable for a holiday dinner. Fit fine, although you can sort of see the liner through the slit in the middle. Overly dry cleaned now so looks a little worn.

Nice soft fabric. Lovely style. Too snug in waist. May rent at another time

This is a nice soft skirt and easy to wear. I wish it was a little more slimming, but otherwise good. Fits mostly true to a Vince 4, the size I typically wear in most brands, if not ever so slightly big.

Super cute skirt and very light weight and comfy, unfortunately it is bunched up in the mid section and makes my stomach look bigger than it is. I didn't end up wearing this piece.

Fun skirt idea, but runs VERY large. Pattern looked cute with cream sweater but size down so you still get a shape

I hoped this skirt would be more fit-and-flare. On me, the waist was ok, then it was sort of baggy, then draped strangely over my hips. Not super flattering.