Loved the style and fit of this skirt. I ordered the 12 but could have taken the 10 as the material is stretchy. Such a cute skirt to wear to the office. Lengths is really good for someone taller.

I'm not a pencil skirt fan, but this skirt? I can get behind it! This thing is almost yoga pant material (I'm not kidding), but looks very professional. It's super stretchy, so I never felt restricted and mostly forgot I was wearing a pencil skirt all day! I had to help set up a trade show booth and then work the booth all day in this, and I was very comfortable even with all of the movement and physical labor. There is no zipper or anything, just an elastic waist. For that reason, I'd recommend sizing down as a back up, but it otherwise runs pretty true to size. It might show panty lines, so be wary as you are choosing undergarments. At 5'9", this skirt was a perfect work length for me. It hit just above my knees and didn't ride up much when sitting. You could see the lines where I had tucked my shirt into it, but I don't think anyone really noticed. Not the highest quality garment I've gotten from RTR, but it's the only pencil skirt I want to wear and I'll be happy to have the opportunity to rent again!

Very flattering skirt. Loved the bottom.... added some flare and fun.

The fit of this skirt is fabulous! Stretchy material that still looks formal enough for most occasions. The flare at the bottom hit just at my knee. Would rent again for sure!

Love the ease of this akirt. Traveled well. Only complaint is that it bunches up as you wear it-doesnt really lie flat across the fromt.

I sized down (usually a 4) and the 2 fit fine, though it was a bit long. I had trouble finding tops to pair it with though. I think the jacket ended up making it look sophisticated, but possibly still a little frumpy given the length. Probably won't rent again.

Fits well, good length for me (5'8"), I wore it with a knotted white t-shirt to a drag show, and was perfectly dressed for the occasion. Could be easily styled for the office or for dancing...

Forgiving material

Very comfy and easy to pair with tops for work

Easy to dress up or down. All around cute and easy to wear.

great fabric with good, flattering styling- looks great with blouses and sweaters. Perfect work attire with booties or heels.

Nice material but a bit too tight to wear to work.

a nice staple piece for my work clothing rotation; nothing to make you say "wow" but solid basic

Probably could have gone a size down, which would have been true to size, but I was worried it would be too tight because I needed it for an interview. It ended up looking a little loose so if you're worried I'd go up a size just in case. Absolutely adorable and even got compliments on my interview lol. Took everything out of me not to buy it!

I love this skirt. True to size. Was more casual than expected but the fit was great

This is the item I wore the most in this month's shipment. Change your shoes to dress up for night out (strappy heels), give it a serious spin for work (pumps), and dress it down (oxfords) for a day-to-night weekend adventure.

The waist ran a bit big and rode up at times. I felt like I was pulling that down on a regular basis. On the flip side, it moves great when you walk. It also hits at a great length.

I loved it so much I bought it. Need I say more?

Great and easy fit.

Flattering fit, even for a more petite person. Runs a little big and there's no zipper (stretchy waistband) so if in between sizes, size down

This is a great take on a basic black skirt. The ruffle at the bottom makes it fun, but too memorable to wear every week, so perfect as a rental. The material is very soft and stretchy, making this very comfortable.

I loved this skirt! Comfortable and very flattering. It looks better in person than on RTR's site. Pull-on skirts sometimes look cheap or have a weird fit, but this one is the exception. I will rent again.

I gave it 5 stars because I love the skirt and would rent again, but I would definitely size down next time. The skirt pulls on (no zipper) and is a very stretchy fabric. I would have liked it to hit a little higher on my waist, so next time I will rent the 2 instead of the 4 (my usual size).

Girly cute flare, can dress up or down

overall ok, form fitting not much structure.

It's one I could see myself wearing over and over again. Both comfortable and pulled together.

Loved this little skirt. It was modest and comfortable. The waist was a little stretched out but still I would definitely rent again!

The elastic waist was stretched so did not stay on the waist

Slightly stretched out over the day, but cute style!

It's very formfitting. This is a spandex / cotton skirt.

Fits great. I wore without stockings or tights and it flows great. I think it could very easily stick to tights but I am really comfortable in it. I am 5'4" and it's a nice modest length that I am certainly comfortable wearing for work. I dressed it up with a red floral blouse and black patent shoes. Easy but perfect for a day at the office.

This is a cute skirt. The material is nice and thick. I rented the size 4 and I normally wear a 6. The 4 was a bit loose. I didn't wear this skirt as it isn't particularly flattering on my figure. The length wasn't great for me and although the flounce at the bottom is cute, it didn't do much for my figure. I'm sure it will look great on other people.

This skirt is cute and comfortable. Although the material is a stretchy, cotton-type material, it's thick enough to hide lines from a blouse or button up. I thought it still read "professional" enough for a conservative office. If you want to wear it as pictured, order a couple of sizes down. I'm normally a 4 and ordered a 2, which was still too big. It gapped around the waist, and with a shirt tucked in, it made me look heavy. I'll return and try again with a 0.

The color, style, and fit were great for a curvy frame!

This skirt runs large - the size 2 was too big for me and I've got quite a bit of thiccness. It also has a tendency to stretch throughout the day.

It fit well and was comfortable, but the fabric was too casual for me to wear it to work.

Nothing special about this skirt. Just a thick jersey-type material. Slim fit and stretchy. Just average.

While the fit was comfortable and true to size, the fabric made it a more casual skirt and I had a hard time pairing it with something dressy enough on top to wear to work. I would rent again, but would plan to wear it more with something like casual wedges or sandals and maybe a jean jacket. Cute skirt overall just not what I was looking for.

This skirt felt cheaper than I would expect from such a pricey brand. As other have noted, it slips on like a pair of yoga pants which I didn't love. It also rode up a bit when I walked. I usually wear a 2 and ordered a 0 and had room in the waist so definitely had to size down.

Wore it in the 8, since the 6 was too tight