Could've/should've worn an XS...I think I would have enjoyed it more. But even tough it was different and fun. Loved the blue. Wore in winter even without the sleeves, thick and warm.

This sweater runs large and because of the way it falls needs to be worn with tight skirt or leggings or you may risk looking super frumpy. Great quality and color. Looks great against black. Perfect early fall sweater.

Wore with Spanx arm tights underneath. FYI that it has an open flap in the front.

Rented but weather ended up being too warm to wear. Will try again later in the year.

The pros are that it feels good to wear. The con is that the sleeves are not longer.

Was too large

DNW; wasn't what I expected from the photos

I'm between 4-6, and the small fit well. Nice thick knit. Slightly itchy (didn't bother me at all, but might if you are sensitive). I liked this--I'd get it again.

RTR recommended medium -- I rented that, it was ok, but the small was much better. This is a boxy loose fit overall -- very forgiving -- more important to get the shoulders right than tummy or midsection.

Flattering shape. Received lots of compliments.

More substantial - quite heavy actually. Didn't think I liked the color until I put it on and just felt almost cuddled by this sweater. Tossed over long sleeve, short sleeve or a tank top, versatile

LOVED. Got lots of compliments. Easy to pair with black work pants or more casual wear on the weekends. Despite being a thicker fabric it didn't come off as too boxy. Would highly recommend.

Will try it in L instead of XL.

This is very cozy. It not a showstopper for me, but it looks professional for work. Fit is good. I like that it's long enough to cover my butt.

Beautiful thick knit. A tiny bit itchy around the neck, but generally comfortable. I was quite warm in it even though it has no sleeves. Would be great with a long tee under it. The front flap draped nicely with no real concerns about accidental exposure.

Great fit, not itchy, and a pretty color but it looked just OK on me.

I ended up not wearing this. It is a pretty color but very bulky and almost vest like. Note that it has two pieces crossed in front so you sort of need to wear something underneath it too. It might be nice if you find the right way to style it or if you are taller. At 5'1" I can't afford to add bulk to my frame so this was just too much.

I have wider shoulders and this seemed to accentuate that...which wasn't my favorite. I may have worn this if it were cooler with a shirt underneath.

Since it is sleeveless, I thought it would be lighter weight. There's a reason most heavy sweaters have sleeves. I can't think of any weather where this would be a comfortable choice.