Warned by previous reviews I bought the Small and I'm glad I did. I'm a short-waisted 8 and the fit is perfect around the chest (where it fits most closely). Length is just above the knee. This is a real work-horse of a dress; wear it alone, with a short cardigan, over a crisp white button-down, with patterned tights. Lovely durable wool with a natural stretch and a soft finish (not at all itchy). It is sort of trapeze-cut, i.e. wider at waist, widest at hem. Not figure-hugging and arguably not flattering but I'm going to find it very useful and have already received lots of compliments on it.

Definitely on the large side- I am 5'7 and 125 and this was a bit baggy (size XS)

Simple. Clean. Easy. The wool is an ideal all-season weight. Knee length. I wore it to work with an even longer, tissue weight cashmere sweater, then added the long Theory best to head downtown to meet my partner. The only cons? I somehow managed to rent a large instead of a medium. And a shadow of a smudge from a previous wearing. Boo, but likely only noticeable to me. Still. I had considered purchasing, but not in this condition.

Could go from work to out.

Loved this dress. Paired it with a white button down underneath and a long necklace. Comfortable and does not wrinkle. Wore it all day into dinner and drinks. Lots of compliments!

The fabric is thick with some stretch, I received new with tags when I bought on final sale. I am usually a 10/L and the M fit with plenty of room. So flowy it's almost dorky, but I was looking for a really easy dress like this to throw on and be comfy but still professional. There is a thick seam down each side on the front and back and extra fabric that poofs out to the left and right of them. The length was between mid-thigh and knee-length on me (5'6"). It would look better on a taller person I think.

Very boxy cut, as you would expect, so the small fit perfectly (I am usually a medium and sometimes a large). I am 5'6" and 140 so all you tiny ladies would be swimming in this dress.

This look was a miss for me. I wore it to work and it was just really too large. It was fine for one day but I wouldnt rent again.

This dress was a little ragged -- the neckline was slightly frayed. But the material is nice and warm. It's not wonderfully shaped, I got the XS though I'm between a 4 and a 6 in dresses and it still was pretty loose. I didn't love how it fit around the underarms. But overall a simple shift dress, no major complaints, and it looked great under a jacket with tights. I probably won't rent again because there's more interesting stuff out there but it was totally functional.

This dress looked nice on the hanger. It was gigantic so I was unable to wear it. Even the arm holes were huge.