I can't gush enough about how amazing this jacket is. I love it and had to keep it. Fits great, a bit boxy, oversized but can be cuffed or tossed over your shoulders. Wore it every day dressed up and down makes anything instantly put together

Wanted to keep this. Love the weight of this jacket/coat — perfect for cool spring and fall days.

This Jacket had an adorable fit and shape. For fall I like the light gray color and length. It is not a heavy coat but it is warm.

I like that it runs big. Easy to wear with any and everything. So chic, effortless, and elegant.

Definitely oversized - I'm 5'9" and was swimming in a small. The sleeves are very wide and don't taper at the end. If that's the style you're looking for, though, then there are some pros! Very soft and kept me plenty warm in 50° weather

This was my first choice to rent for an October work trip to London and it was the perfect item - I wore it every day. It is totally unlined so it is not super warm but is great for temps in the 40s-60s where you want something nice over your outfit and don't want to be cold. It was warm enough in the 40s with a scarf, and it wasn't too bad even at 65 degrees unbuttoned. Quality is beautiful - heathery gray felted wool in a very lightweight weave, beautiful rounded cut, four easy snaps to button and unbutton and it looks nice both ways, deep pockets. Cons: over some things the round neck isn't as elegant as a regular folded-down collar would be. Fit: it has a roomy cut, in both sleeves and body. I often prefer a small to an XS in a jacket to be sure there is space for larger clothing underneath and because I like a larger look, but I definitely would not recommend sizing up for this one. Your size, or the size down if you are between sizes, should be fine and going up a size will probably be too large.

Super comfy, just a bit oversized, great neutral gray perfect for fall. Love the length and the pockets.

Size down even one more than your normally would when told to size down. Nice lightweight coat.

When you want to look like the models but you're 5'2"... This is a beautiful coat but it was comically large on my petite frame. It covered my hands and went below my knees.

I got many compliments on this at work! I wore it as a coat but you could pull it off as a long shacket or blazer. Super light but kept me warm- perfect for late fall in PA. Wish I could have kept it!

Also making a Montreal trip. Tidy. Understated. Ideal.

Fits true to size. Nice piece

I didn't wear it because it looks too big on me. But it's warm and great quality! I would love it if size down.

Perfect it. Loved it

n/a

I wore this over a colorful grey and blue dress and also with a pair of white jeans and boots. Very well made and elegant. Boxy style. I felt a bit like I was in a futuristic movie.

Not as cute as the model photos

Too large including extra long sleeves

Large fit, not terribly flattering. Wouldn't rent again.

This coat is quite thin - didn't feel like very high quality. I liked the oversized look but I only wore it unbuttoned.

Cut within an inch of itself, the way Theory coats often are. Substantial. Tidy. Effortless. Fun. I wore it to fourteen hours of family meetings, then as a coat the next morning, with plans to wear it to breakfast this weekend.

The fabric is just the right weight for a spring coat. It's some kind of felted wool though, so not great if you're in a heavy rainy clime. I wish it weren't so danged expensive to begin with otherwise I would have bought it. But the cut is gorgeous, it travels VERY well (flew all over the US in this one) and can be easily warmed up with a scarf. Others said it ran large, which I suppose it does, but makes it perfect for layering. Fits over a work suit and doesn't look strange. Love it.

Runs large. Soft material

Looks best thrown over the shoulders as a statement piece, could look bulky at times, runs big.

The coat is pretty shapeless but I really liked the modern look. Wore it to work multiple times and got compliments. Friend told me I looked Parisian

So when I first put it on I wasn't really that thrilled. I should of gotten a medium. I'm 5'5" 145 and wear a 6-8. However, I have never had so many people stop me to comment on something I was wearing. Complete strangers going Gaga over this coat! I mean literally every day I was out!!

Jacket is warm and soft. It's a bit big throughout, but good for cold weather.

Fits large but still flattering. Sleeves are bracelet length which is perfect.

It runs large and looked very big on me but they didn't have a small

Warms up nicely! But it was too big, not just as an oversized coat, but overall.

Roomy and boxy cut, can wear up to pretty thick sweaters underneath. It has a clean and simple shape.

I love the idea of this coat and imagine that if I'd selected the size Sm that it would be perfect. As the style is already a bit oversized and the cut intentionally boxy, I'm kind of swimming in a medium which, when buttons, looks great, but when unbuttoned has kind of an oversized artist smock look. The fabric is luscious, though, and it legit feels like I'm wearing a blanket scarf coat.

Nice color and fabric but style is very boxy. Definitely order a size down.

Large fit especially the sleeves.

Beautiful coat but runs very large

Even the small is very oversized and baggy

Too big. I would need XXS and am usually M in jackets. (Ordered M)

I've love Theory clothes because they are flattering, fitted, and conservative. This coat is a shapeless sack. I got a size S but it was huge. Like, did-they-mislabel-it huge? Sent it back immediately. Not sure what's up with this coat. Two stars because the fabric is really nice.

This jacket overall did not fit me right even when I attempted to pair it with very high heels. I just couldn't make it work