Could have worn a small but the medium was good for a cute French tuck and roomy casual fit. Great for tall people bc sleeves are long and torso is also a good length

I really liked this top, it was comfortable and made me feel confident. The sleeves were extra long for my long arms and the length was perfect with a pair of mid-rise jeans. I got a lot of compliments on the pattern of the top and would wear again if given the opportunity.

Everyone loved this top! It's thick enough to keep you warm, yet tucked into my pants perfectly. I don't want to return it!

Beautiful and thick material, but very clingy. Not forgiving at all.

Nice top but the large was too loose for me, I would have liked it a bit more snug.

Loved the design and the fabric. Loved the long sleeves, but I was swamped by this sweater.

Cute top for casual date night. Perfect layering piece for NYC winter. Sleeves were a little long, but looked fine with a cuff.

This top is cut so strangely. The arms were long enough (I'm tall and long-limbed so that was good), but the length was not proportional and was too short. The ribbing of the shirt also made it fall poorly. It was too stiff and thick and added lumps and weight to my frame. Wore once but do not recommend

loved color style fit for everyday casual

Not too long or too short, flattering fit, bought it

Great material- feels expensive and well made.

The material was just okay but I loved the sweater. It was very flattering.

This is so pretty and classy for work! I loved the sleeve detail and it was so flattering.

Couldn't wear

Such a lovely knit and fabric. Low cut and therefore emphasizes the chest. Sleeves run long, so I folded them slightly which worked fine because the sleeve fabric contrast still showed nicely.

I liked the print of this sweater and the tasteful V. Sleeves are a bit long, and I wish there had been less fabric - it clings to the body and I have a very ruler like torso, so it was maybe a bit big. Overall still flattering.

Not that flattering as it lumps a bit around waist where it meets the pants vs. being truly body con

It honestly looked gross in person and gross on. I don't know if it's a quality issue (overworn, improperly dry cleaned) or a make issue. It was saggy where it should cling, looked stretched out in a lot of areas, a sad color -- should have been a form fitting layering staple, but it's not.

Loved this sweater! Very flattering! Sleeves are very long for a petite, but look nice turned up!

I loved this sweater. Sleeves are really long and I had to fold them up when I washed my hands. Loved the optical illusion effect of the stripes that make the pattern. It would go great with slacks, but I wore it with jeans.

Perfect everyday light sweater. Cute, fitted and very versatile. Could have worn it a dozen times easily

The fabric and cut was very flattering, and it was super comfortable!

It fit well for small busted woman and needs a camisole. It feels very nice and helps the outfit come together adding a interest to the eye.

Definitely size down. The fit is so comfy and flattering. The fabric is a nice thick material.

Great for dinner date

I wore this a lot. Great quality and fit. Received compliments. Almost bought it but 200+ is a little rich for an everyday sweater imo.

Looks silver in the photos but it's black and white.

I received many positive comments and love the sweater!

Amazingly flattering. Wish it wasn't so expensive! I loved it so much.

Was good with jeans and dress pants

Normally an XS, but got P in this top and it was a little long and not as tight as id like.

Liked it but agree with others, it's very thick fabric that's rather rigid in a way. At the same time it's clingy and it bunches up in the wrong ways. I preferred to wear it tucked in and thought it looked best that way.

This is a very pretty and unique top, comfy and warm in the New Jersey winter but those sleeves everyone is talking about, they are So Darn Long!!!! I didn't take a picture but the top overall is very pretty. The sleeves, not so much. I wouldn't rent this one again based on the super long sleeves.

This sweater is gorgeous in person and the body fits so well, BUT the sleeves are ridiculously long! I am 5'8, and they covered my hands. It's a shame because the stripe detail on the sleeves is so pretty!

I liked the overall fit of this piece, but the sleeves were 4" too long, way out of proportion to the bodice. I folded them up and it worked, but you couldn't see the bottom two layers of stripes. It was a flattering cut but the neckline was too deep to be appropriate for the office. I wore it with a cami underneath when I wore it to the office- and by itself for a date night with the hubs:)

I love Theory but this shirt was not one of my favs. I am petite so the sleeves were REALLY long on me, kind of took away from the style when I had to roll sleeves up.

Sleeves are really long.

Loved this fabric and I really wanted to love this sweater but the sleeves are way too long. Tried giving this sweater into jeans and it bunches weird in the back. Wearing it untucked over jeans made me look much wider than I am. Not a flattering drape