Awesome sweater. Was a bit big and I have long arms. So would have tried a medium rather than a large. But overall was a great style. Versatile with the convertible sleeve. Classic fashion.

Loved this sweater and received many compliments. The fabric is light and perfect for transitional weather.

It’s exactly as pictured. Dress it up or down. It’s super cute and unique.

The sleeve-as-a-scarf detail is fun. The sweater is comfortable and light. Fit is generous.

This shirt is so cool. Do you don't have to wear it with one sleeve. The wrap around your neck is the other sleeve. At first it feels weird but then it really makes the shirt work. It's lightweight. Perfect for an indoor setting. It felt the large was a tad oversized but it works for the look. Definitely needs to be tucked in unless you are going for that cool comfy look. Will wear again!

The minute I walked in the room, my husband asked if I forgot to put my arm in my sleeve LOL. The wrap around the neck literally is a sleeve, and you could in theory put your arm through it. So in that sense it's a little weird, but it definitely got people talking, if that's what you're after. The fabric itself is extremely cozy and it's a beautiful olive color.

This is a loose fit, but it is soft and comfortable. Not too thick and not too thin. My only complaint is that the extra sleeve that wraps around doesn't stay well, so I used a hair clip to hold it in place.

The stem is a little weird

I love that the sleeve is convertible. I wore this top all day doing "normal" stuff and then went to the opera. Taking the sleeve off was so chic, lots of compliments.

unusual piece, nicely made and fun

I wore it sleeve on, and wrapped around the neck. Fun shirt to tweak to the temperature and a lush color.

I love how weird this sweater is. The fit was great, it was comfortable, and it will definitely confuse people. 10/10 would wear it again.

Wore for a GNO!

Easy to wear - dress up or down!

,

I thought the neck thing was for an arm, until I went to review this.

Very nice sweater but just ok. Easy fit

I generally like brighter colors but the unique design makes it fun to wear. Fit was comfortable and easy but a bit looser than I would like it. I will certainly rent it again but possibly size down.

I liked it but it didn’t really seem like anything special after I got it. It’s pretty casual, I was hoping to dress it up with some leather pants but I just didn’t love it that much. It was comfy though. Decided to wear another piece instead

Not sure if I missed this in the description, but there really are two arms in this design. What they show on the model as a "scarf" is really the other arm... sooo I wore it really as a sweater that has a big opening for my armpit :)! Loved the color/fabric and overall fit -- looked great.

The arm detail is interesting

Fun top, great fabric. I probably should have gotten the medium, the large was a bit too large (and I normally wear a medium)... this seems to be TTS. I would def rent again.

This sweater is fun and unusual! I wore it to a casual dinner party with some wide leg pants and boots. The material is comfortable and lightweight. The color is a bit drab so I jazzed it up with a fun bracelet and statement ring. The semi-detached sleeve has a few options: wear as a sleeve with a cut out at arm pit, draped over arm, or like a scarf. I chose the scarf look, but wore as a sleeve when outside in the cold. Overall a fun top that had some compliments. Will rent again!

Nice fit and fabric. I thought the sleeve neck detail would be super long and exaggerated and make for an avant-garde look, but...it pretty much just looked like a sleeve around my neck! It was a more basic look than I'd hoped, though my husband did say "did you got dressed wrong?" which made it worth it.

The arm thing is strange. I couldn't pull it off.

Photos are deceptive. It's really a two sleeved sweater with a nursing-hole-like arm that you can remove if you want to look silly. I did not wear this.

Just ok

The thing that is tossed around the neck that appears to be a scarf is actually a sleeve. This is so weird and unattractive.

The picture is deceiving. There is a sleeve on the one side that looks sleeveless. I was a little disapointed.

This is just ok. Fits TTS. The neck and one arm thing is weird. Wore it like a regular seater but armpit was cold so put on a Tshirt underneath. Weird concept. Not flattering really. Just boring.

Not a huge fan of the neck/ sleeve that is wrapped around. It’s literally your arm sleeve thrown around your neck. Husband thinks it’s weird too

The sleeve cutout just seems to show off your armpit. I love Tibi but this was such a miss.