I will definitely rent this again, with the skirt. I wore ultra high rise jeans with it, Madewell 10”, and if I raised my arms it showed my stomach. The arm length was perfect, which is hard to find for me.

Love the heavy material and the puffed sleeves. It worked well as a last-minute Indian outfit for Diwali with the matching skirt.

I got a M in the skirt and a L in the top because I read the sleeves were a bit shorter. It fit perfectly! And I like that the top was a little looser and more drapey with the more snug skirt. The skirt is such a high quality, thick fabric. Very flattering!

I loved this sweater more than I thought i would. It is soft and really warm. It's the prefect cozy, stylish sweater. I would rent again and even consider buying.

Rented the matching skirt, and the overall look was perfect for multiple casual events on a chilly day! The sweater is thick and stretchy, is true to size. The medium is what normally fits, but the large was available, and it was a bit large! The oversized look still worked though.

The set fits perfectly. It's warm, ha great shape, and an interesting cut out at the back of the neck (can't be seen unless someone is up close).

I rented this and the matching skirt. I rented a size up and still found it a tiny bit small, so size up. It's very cropped, if not with the matching skirt then would wear with high waisted pants

Cut and color are nice - good staple tho it is cropped. Has a horizontal cut opening just below collar on back of neck which is just silly, but it doesn't show (doesn't come open when wearing) so doesn't matter.

True to size I am short waisted so can usually do crops with high/mid waist. Too short of a crop for my age. Otherwise great fit

The length of the arms and overall fit me perfectly (I'm 5'1). The sweater is super chic, looks well-made and the material isn't itchy at all. Loved it.

I am obsessed with this set. Fit super well. So soft and cozy and random and stylish. Yessssss!!!!

This top is really cute and great quality. I didn't realize it was a crop sweater when I rented it but that was fine. My issue was the sleeves were way too short on my arms. I do have extremely long arms though. Should work fine on someone who is not as lanky as me.

This fit me snuggly but I love a sweater that fits me well in all the right places. I ordered a size smaller than I would typically because I look bulky in oversized clothing and I was not disappointed. I love the sleeves on this piece, they add a little bit of character and compliment my shape well.

It have a nice weight to it and it is so warm that I can keep my jacket open even when it is around freezing temperature. Only downside is it is a very cropped style so unless you have very high waisted pants it will show some midriff. Material is high quality wool so it takes a few days to air dry.

Looks like a basic sweater online, and it definitely is simple, but beautiful. The quality is amazing, and it looked great with jeans for casual wear, trousers for work, and a silk skirt. I was surprised at how much I ended up loving this one. I would rent again and try out the full set.

I usually wear a small to medium in tops and I'm glad I got the medium in this. It's soft, warm, and the perfect length for high waisted jeans. The sleeves keep it from being boring (and were long enough!!) and the overall shape was very flattering on me. I was afraid it might be boring, but it was subtle, stylish, and versatile.

Great fit and fun sweater. Super comfortable. This is the second time I’ve rented this sweater and I will definitely do it again.

This sweater was incredibly warm and had some cute details: a work-appropriate back of the neck cutout, poofy sleeves, and a slightly cropped length that wasn't so short as to be revealing.

It is very short, I wore it with high waisted jeans, and still showed a little skin. It is pretty thick so keeps you warm. The sleeves were 3/4 length on me.

perfect navy

The sweater is definitely more cropped but super cute with high-waisted jeans. The sleeves were a little short so if you want it to fit bigger SIZE UP! It is kinda thick so more of a winter sweater but I loved it.

Very cropped!

Wore this a few times before the bottom started to stretch, very flattering though

This sweater is warm, comfortable and versatile. The slit neck makes it a little more special than your average sweater. Be warned that the sleeves are short - I have shorter arms, and they were well above my wrist.

I'm almost always a medium in tops, but this one was extremely small on me. Otherwise it was a nice sweater and I probably would've worn it if it fit.

Really cute and fit body great just very short sleeves looked a little awk

Was a bit shorter than expected, so I was not able to wear

Im a petite person and this sweater was super small on me especially around my bust. I would definitely size up.

This sweater made me feel like I was choking. I couldn't wear it. I sized up from a small to a medium, but it was still awkwardly small.

I usually wear an xs is sweaters, and this one could barely fit my 8-year-old niece. It was also cropped, which isn't apparent in the photos.

In the picture - it appears that this top is tucked in. I am petite at 5'2". This is cropped and unable to be tucked in a very short person. It was misrepresented in picture. I am 42 and definitely would not wear a cropped belly showing shirt.

Very chic with subtle details, definitely a staple.

It was a great cropped sweater with a good weight for everyday wear! Definitely recommend!

While this sweater looks like one of the more basic offerings, it is actually beautifully constructed and very flattering. It is cropped and looks great with jeans or a skirt pairing. The sleeves have a slight balloon feature which looks so good. I got so many complements--it was so fab!