I am consistently a size 10, and have worn a size 10 skirt from this brand that fit me great. I am not sure whether size L was recommended to me or whether I accidentally selected size L, but they were so large that I couldn't wear them. This photo shows me holding the elastic without even stretching it. The material is very flowy and soft though.

Much much much too large. Literally fell off my body

wore these shorts with a crop top as they are a little higher waisted - they were roomy and comfy and maybe a little bi for a medium. I wore them to work bc they're kind of fancier shorts and I don't think anyone cared.

Rented this with the matching top. I am consistently an 8 but am between a M and L. In this style I picked a L and should've picked the M. Due to the style of shorts it worked out there was just extra fabric.

Loves wearing these! This is actually my second time renting them because they are so comfortable to wear. I did have to add a belt to keep them up (I always have things in my pockets that pulled them down) but def recommend!

If you are rounder in the tush area, these don't have a lot of room. The waist and legs fit perfect but there wasn't enough room for the booty and gave me a camel toe look! Didn't wear!

I previously rented these in the M which was enormous so I decided to try the S. They still fell off so I guess I need an XS. (I'm not wasting another rental spot to find out!) Sizing is truly bizarre.

Size down on these or they'll slide right off.. couldn't even wear as a swim cover-up. Great fabric and print. Mine showed up with the waistline folded over so the elastic jutted out, and I couldn't get it to fully straighten out even with an iron.

Won't even stay up. Huge waist with no elastic.

Couldn't get past how unflattering these felt. Baggy in all the wrong places.

poor fit

Cute but very large for a size small. Recommend sizing down

Couldn't wear bc the small was so big, it wouldn't stay on. I know tibi is a slouchy style- but this was ridiculous. Maybe the xs would work. Definitely size down

Fit around the waist but legs were very long and very baggy, which is unusual for me. I have large thighs so most shorts are tight which is why I order a medium, however, now I wish I choose a small.

It's so hard to find a nice pair of shorts these days. These were great because they were not riding up the crotch. It's a very comfortable length. Preppy and clean cut.

I usually wear a size 6 bottom, so I chose Medium; however because of the elasticity of the shorts I should've sized down. It is super comfortable and high quality material. I wore it to Disney and it kept me cool.

The shirt and shorts were super cute together. It was very comfy and worked well with a bralette underneath. I definitely could have sized down on the top and bottom. I saw people complaining about how big the shorts were but I thought they were super comfy, but a little big.

I could wear these 1-week postpartum because of the elastic waist.

easy fit, light weight material

Second size I've tried this in and it it still hung baggy, wide and low in the crotch- also, stitching was in strange locations, a faux crotch added on? Cute shorts and might even rent again since they were so comfortable-just wish a few things were different

none

I didn't wear this because it was tight on my lower half. It was cute though!

Loose and def gets wrinkly. Cute if you won't be sitting for a long window

Massive on... I was drowning. Too bad the top isn't as generous

They were large, baggy and long; not flattering at all. I returned my M order without wearing.