Not particularly soft OR scratchy. Color was kinda dull. I wore a tank underneath so the drape was fine without pins. Overall was kinda meh. I've rented this in other colors and patterns and had better luck.

Comfortable. Can be dressed up or down. A staple for sure. I'd like to buy it

There seemed to be a lot of debate over this shirt in the reviews but I'm very glad I rented it! I might be buying it to keep it, I liked it so much. I did wear a camisole underneath since some folks mentioned trouble with it flapping open but I don't think I had that problem. I found it quite comfortable, warm, and flattering! It's also an easy warm neutral to dress up or down with the right ensemble. Great with jeans or nicer slacks and heels. I suspect the color might wash some folks out depending on skin tone, which could impact how much you enjoy this item!

The fit was perfect. I was a little concerned because my bust usually causes gappage, but the is one of the few wrap sweaters that has good coverage. The material is very soft and breathable, and it is great for work and weekend.

I loved wearing this sweater. It was comfy and cozy, though on the lighter side. I describe it as casual chic, comfy looking but good enough for a business casual or casual Friday environment. One note of caution is that the wrap is not so tight and you may have to pull it together from time to time to avoid revealing too much.

Short in the front

Fits true to size and comfortable to throw on over a tank. Recommend!

I loved this top! Was great for zoom work - not too casual, but comfortable. I would have liked a slightly larger size but was able to wear the small.

Sleeves were short, fabric unyielding, it was only okay.

It was a little tight and shorter on the arms

This fit was strange. The neckline was lovely but then all the extra material sort of falls out of the bottom of the shirt making it bunch up around the waist.

Just an average top, exactly as pictured, lower quality than I've come to expect from RTR, and it's nothing to write home about, but still a nice top. Soft, comfy, hung well.

This was a comfy sweater that was great for nursing. The crossover opening was so convenient to feed my baby. It can be dressed up or down too!

it's a wrap so there's opportunity for a potential flash but it hangs so nicely, I wasn't concerned.

Nice all purpose everyday top. The drape style is flattering and the item is cut so that it provides plenty of coverage. I gave it 4 instead of 5 stars because it was ever so slightly itchy.

I rented this for everyday. While it's comfortable and versatile, it does run smaller and I found the sleeves to be short even though I sized up. Definitely more pink in person like another reviewer stated.

I thought this would be more oatmeal/ brown colored but it turned out to be almost pink-ish with a heathered brown look to it. Not necessarily bad, just not what I thought I was getting. I think Slate & Willow tends to run a little small so I opted for an XL instead of L and was happy that I did. I'm 5'6"/ 36DD and normally wear a size 12. The XL fit well -- probably a little too much material in the chest but it hung well and was the right length for me.

I was happy with this sweater. The color is more pink in person and I was expecting it to be neutral, but I still liked it. I am usually a large, but I got the XL because usually these wrap style tops open op around my bust. This one didn't at all and I could have worn my usual size. I didn't need to wear a tank underneath. It's cute and cozy.

This sweater is soft but short in the sleeves and kept gaping open!

Cute sweater, very cozy but was too big. Would highly recommend tape or safety pins though, as it had a tendency to pop open in the middle.

Too short for my long torso.

This was really uncomfortable and itchy in the arms. Feels like the arms are lined with an odd mesh. Also, the way the bottom sits (a bit too flouncy) was too unflattering to wear. One of the few things I am sending back without even wearing once.