Rented with Rebecca Taylor Malbec Vegan Leather skirt. I ordered a size down and it fit perfectly. Nice material and drape.

The photo on the model does not do this sweater justice. It's quite rigid and really form fitting at the waist. The texture is amazing and very dramatic/design forward. I almost decided to purchase it but it's a little too warm for my work uniform day to day. I found I was always putting on a lighter sweater in the afternoon. Wonderful piece. The sleeves hang really well too.

This is the first piece I bought from RTR. It is just a solid everyday piece. The fit isn't for everybody but for my athletic body type with bigger shoulders it is flattering. It is a bit tight around the waist but I sized up and it was perfect. Might not be for everyone but I highly recommend!

I really considered keeping this but don't need any more winter clothes. It's the perfect sweater, so warm, not scratchy, the fit is ideal. It just looks expensive

Love this shirt - it's cozy, warm and flattering. It's fitted in the waist line with wide sleeves. Perfect with a scarf or poncho over it. Tough to fit inside of a fitted jacket due to the sleeves. Also looks great with a long necklace.

Great sweater - not itchy. Got 6 compliments on my way into work.

I'm bigger on top than on the bottom. This sweater accentuated all the right places. It was thick and heavy but soft, perfect on a Fall NY evening. I would buy this if it got cold enough where I live. Definitely the favorite sweater out of 3picks.

Honestly at first I wasn't sure about this sweater but it grew on me & I can't wait to wear it again. It has a dolman cut and is pretty fitted (but stretchy fabric) around the torso. Material is soft and was super easy to pair with jeans & boots. I have a larger bust and the medium fit perfectly. Size up if you want it to be looser in the torso, though.

Loved this sweater!

It was a bit tight around the mid-section. I sized up my NW size and that was a good decision. It was flattering overall.

Very cute, comfortable winter sweater. The fit is loose on top and tight around the hips, so I didn't care for how it looked with jeans because you could see the waistband. I wore out with jeggings and that looked much better. I wore my normal size and probably could have sized up for a looser fit. Since the sleeves are so loose anyway I don't think it would have looked too baggy in a L.

Really like the look of this sweater. Was more fitted in the midsection than I expected and the sleeves were a tad short but overall a good sweater and I would rent again.

I was surprised by how warm this sweater is! I love the slight nod to the ‘70s with the bell sleeves but the turtleneck is wide enough it wasn’t sitting on my neck all day! I received quite a few compliments each time I wore it but I can’t see myself loving this sweater year after year so that’s why I’m not buying it.

Fits true to size. Can't decide if it's a cowl or turtleneck. It doesn't really do it for me.

Loved! Versatile and so comfortable!!

I liked this sweater a lot. It dresses up whatever you wear it with, and it's very warm. The material is soft and comfortable. The only drawback is that because it fits snug around the hips, it tends to ride up a bit. Otherwise, a lovely sweater for work or an evening out.

It was a nice color, and an interesting fit. The bottom was tighter than expected, so had material folding over. The sleeves are large and connected to the body in a way it makes it hard to wear a jacket over it.

Really nice soft grey color. It does not get too hot so a great seater to wear in the house. The waist is fitted so its better to wear with more fitted pants at the waist.

This sweater was cute and flattering but the neck was really itchy

The waist line of this is really tight while the rest of it was really loose. Pretty strange looking.

This sweater I thought would hide my post partum tummy but it enhanced it. The sleeves are loose ans the stomach area is form fitting and not flattering if you're looking to conceal that area.

A little more cropped that in the picture, nice overall fit. True to size.

Loved the fit. Lines were very flattering

Cozy yet stylish sweater, great for work or just casual, everyday wear.

Sometimes I'm between sizes, so sized up on this. Cozy, very warm. Fun to wear.

Easy piece to wear to work! Loved the snug fit around the waist and the bell sleeves for cute detail.

Loved it so much I bought it!

Wore it several times and always got compliments. Arms are big but the waist and stomach is more fitting which I liked. It didn't seem too itchy either.

Nice. Turtle neck wasn't too tight. Arms were nice and flowy

Like others have said, the sleeves are wide (I had to be careful at dinner). While I would likely not buy this sweater, I was glad to rent it. The sleeves and overall cut were different than what I usually wear. I received compliments and it had a flattering fit.

The turtleneck falls perfectly every time. I think most body shapes can wear this sweater, however if you have a little muffin top, you might want a high waisted jegging or spanx to "smooth" out your waist as this sweater is fitted across that area.

Can dress up or down. Dolman sleeves are funky and trendy. Got so many compliments on this sweater. Thinking about buying it.

Great fit. Flattering

Tons of compliments

comfy flattering fit

Great fit - wore to work. Bottom is fitted, giving it a real dolman fit. Would definitely rent again.

Love the sweater, very comfortable.

Wore it at least 4 times I really liked the way it fit. Plus it was warm