When I bought this I thought I was only getting the midnight blue liner, so I was surprised to see that there were two eyeliners and even more surprised by the mint green color. At first glance my thought was "yea, not happening" but when I tried the green under my eye and smudged it, it was pretty great! I actually ended up being disappointed by the blue... it wasn't working well and I had to rub my eye raw to get some color out of the stick... not sure if it was my eyeshadow + the liner, but it was not awesome. But you bet I'll be using the green again.