I would buy this if it was not so expensive. It is SO flattering and surprisingly comfortable. The shoulder pads are a strange material that is bendable so you can adjust how much of a shoulder you want. Love love love!

Love the shoulder pads! They are a lot but the shirt really pops as a result. This shirt is a head turner. Love the embroidery detail in the front as well. Paired well with the denim skirt. Will rent again.

The shoulders on these were enormous - 5x bigger than the model in the photo and looked crazy on my petite frame. The material was also quite scratchy.

They are a statement- be prepared. I loved them, the fit, and the length for a long torso. My issue was the mesh/tulle used to get that peak dug into my shoulder and wasn't just uncomfortable- it hurt to wear! Maybe with some protection or padding- they are already high! It's not see through, such a high-quality, unique, gorgeous black top.

LOVED this top! Super unique and great quality. The shoulders give it some umph but not over the top. Very chic staple, would rent again

I have a wider chest/back so I think that took some of the length. I wore a high waisted jean to make sure I was covered but ended up tucking it in to make sure I was covered. I think it would fit someone perfectly that were more straight shaped.

This top is absolutely gorgeous with a beautiful structure. Unfortunately just a little small for me, would order again in a larger size.

Pretty top with a lovely constructed shoulder detail

Loved how versatile this blouse is. Quality is great and statement shoulders give a sort of gothy, classical vibe without being cheesy or costume-y. The peplum is pretty subtle and doesn’t do the preggo things some of them do. The accents throughout were a little scratchy so it’s def not a lounger but I’ve rented it 3x now so it’s a winner.

This top has major shoulders, so you just have to lean into that vibe. The peplum balances or you can tuck it into high rise jeans because the material is so thin.

Didn't realize there would be shoulder pads but loved it

This was so pretty but I was surprised to find it has a very rigid shoulder pad inside. They were a bit uncomfortable throughout the day but overall I loved the top.

The shoulder pads were a little too pointy

I give higher reviews if the item is quality, fits, and might be someone else’s cup of tea. If it’s not my “style”, that’s a matter of opinion, and not a true review of the product. Low reviews, to me, are based on product quality, fit and misrepresentation of the product on RTR. I felt like Laura Ingles in “Little House on the Prairie.” But I know this will look so cute on the right person!

Did not love it, was just ok. Tough fit

Wanted to love this top- it’s beautiful, fit perfectly, the embroidery detail and cut outs in the front are beautiful- but the shoulders made this a little Elvira or vampire? Tule fabric holds up the puffs in the shoulders - they are not “shoulder pads”

I badly wanted to make these shoulders work, but they were very awkward

Wonky fit