Being completely honest, this had to grow on me, but now I am obsessed. It’s a super cute statement piece and I don’t want to send it back. If you’re in between sizes, size down. I’m typically on the smaller-medium side but since It’s so boxy any bigger would have been too big.

If you want a statement jacket that everyone will ask you where it's from then this is it. Definitely does run broad in the shoulders and is oversized. Wish I had gotten a size smaller

Love this jacket. Adds to any outfit, fits just right

Great for 60* weather & fun fall vibes

Lots of compliments and was warm for 50 degree weather

Really enjoyed this rental. Definitely unique with a lot to work with. Recommend for anyone looking to spice things up!

I loved the look of it but it was just too weird of a fit. It came more than halfway up my arm when I raised my hands up in the air. It’s definitely very eccentric but it’s super comfy and warm. But I really hate short sleeves. With 28” long noodles for arms I value proper length. Such a shame cause it was so comfy. Still might keep but idk it looks so awkwardly short. It’s so comfy you could even sleep in it. For reference I am 5’7” 165lbs 32C 34”waist

The sleeves are fabulous for drying your wet hands on (wore this camping) and it was snugly and soft. But I didn't feel super cute in it (has the line-backer look going on) and it was only cute with jeans. Several pockets but none big enough for a phone.

Ok so I knew the other reviews said that this ran large, but this jacket runs super large. It was so incredibly big on me in the shoulders. Ultimately I loved the style and sleeves, but I wished it wasn't as wide in the shoulders. I'm not sure that sizing done would have helped much because the style is meant to be wide.

This looks so cute on the model and just does not work in real life. The sleeves are so incredibly short; if that’s the design then I don’t really understand what situations this jacket would work for. On top of that, the body is extremely bulky and oversized. Not flattering at all. Cute concept, bizarre execution.

This jacket became my personality. It goes with so much because of all the color in the sleeves. Layers nicely over bulky sweaters, too. It kept me warm, I got tons of compliments, and it It does make your shoulders look quite wide, so if that will make you self-conscious, maybe reconsider.

This is the best jacket I have ever worn. I wish I could buy it, simply amazing. The vibes are soooo good and I got so many compliments!! its boxy but in the best way. SO CHIC

A good warm jacket. Fun to throw over a casual outfit.

Love this jacket!! It was a little snug but fit. I would probably do a medium if I were purchasing

I read the reviews which recommended sizing down, I sized down and am glad I did. The jacket fit perfectly. It is extremely comfortable and cozy. I wore it everyday. I love the sleeves, they're actual quilts sewed on, and no it isn't a heavy jacket or would cause you to be too hot. It is actually cool and lightweight, but kept me warm in the fall.

It's so good I don't want to send it back but I've worn it so many times I must. It's memorable so I don't want to overdo it! I'll likely rent it again in the future for an out of town trip.

Knew the sizing would be risky based on the puffiness of the sleeves. It is borderline linebacker-ish but I did really love the patterns. Definitely not the most flattering tho. Could have gotten the XS if it was available.

I love oversized shapes and interesting prints. This sizing was tricky. The shoulders were really wide but the hem was kind of fitted and the sleeves were super short on me. Wrist-baring styles are cool too, but this is pretty heavy for showing a lot of wrist. My husband said I looked like Kanye! Ha.

Ok this is a VERY well made jacket hence my 4 stars. However, the fit was so comical I don't think my husband and I have ever laughed so hard. The sleeves and coat are very thick and have a stiffness to it. I have very thin arms and I looked like Violet Beauregarde from Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. Didn't wear it, looked silly. Perhaps someone with a bigger frame, stronger, etc would look better in it. Not flattering to me at all, but I appreciate the laugh.

This jacket is warm and cozy. It's stylish but borders on homely. Looks great with loose worn in jeans.

I loved this jacket but the shoulders are absolutely ENORMOUS. I have broad shoulders to begin with so maybe that's why? Not sure, but if I wore this to play football I could have tackled everyone!

It was a bit too small on me and super tight in the shoulders. Cute sleeves but a bit too boxy for me!

Like most reviews it says the shoulders are wide. And they are! Love the pattern. It's a statement piece, maybe not an everyday.

Oversized and boxy look but the arms were really short. Not my favorite fit!

I love Sea New York but woo chile - hard pass on this one. Really cute in the pics online but the fit is WEIRD. If you have shorter arms, this would work better for you. I'm pretty lanky and the sleeves hit me mid forearm. I also have a slender build - rented this in a small and I looked like a linebacker. It's both too small and too large at the same time.

I would size up next time, but was very cute for a camp themed wedding weekend!

Very boxy, if you have a smaller frame it would be better. felt like a fridge