Felt great, rented the 4 the first time around (shown here) ran a bit too large but that was all that was available. The 2 was a much better fit! A great tailored piece, heavy material , well constructed .

Got this for work as a "blazer shirt" and got a ton of compliments on how cute it is. It's a little snug in the chest area if you are big busted, but overall so so cute.

The sleeves for this top were just phenomenal. The fit was really nice. It's just a great fall top. I got a lot of compliments which is great too. Take a chance and rent this top.

It's hard to find tops that fit us top heavy girls and don't look like tents, but this is very flattering. Unfortunately, I didn't check the weather when I ordered this WOOL top in the middle of a heat wave so I didn't get to wear it. Rest assured, it will be at the top of my list come fall.

The fit was true size and the top was an overall statement!

I wouldn’t rent this again because of how itchy it was.

Very flattering. Great sleeves. I might have been able to size down but not sure. The tie at waist kept it fitted looking anyway.

This is cute but I felt a little like Queen Victoria with these sleeves.

Wish it was lined but other than that it's a stunner.

Loved the top but didn’t end up wearing since it has warmed up where I live and was too heavy. Would have been great in colder weather!

This top is very flattering. I sized up to a 4 because I wear a 34D bra and sometimes shirts like this a tight in the bust. This fits great and the tie accentuates your waist. As other reviews have stated, this shirt is wool so it is warm and it could be itchy but I solved the itch-factor with a fitted tee underneath.

I love the puff sleeves. It dressed up my look a little bit but they weren't so big that they looked over the top or anything. This is a wool top so it's a little bit itchy at first, but I got used to it. There is absolutely no stretch to it so if you're on the fence about sizing, I recommend sizing up one size.

Not lined but still comfortable and looked great.

I'm a solid size 8 with bigger bust (34DD) and this fit really well. Can cinch in a waist to be quite flattering. Definitely has the big shoulders but I appreciate a statement piece!

I really liked this top. The fit was perfect and I felt very chic in it. The only reason for 4 instead of 5 stars is it was quite itchy. I didn't mind but just wish it had been lined of made from something less irritating.

This top looked great on, but it was pretty itchy and not super comfy for a full day at the office. Again, it looked great - so I'd still recommend it. But, just maybe for a night out or a meeting and not for a 10 hour day.

I could not wear this simply because the blouse was not lined and the fabric was way too irritating.

It's very oversized, very itchy. I didn't wear it as it didn't wow me and was very uncomfortably itchy.

Didn't wear it because it was too itchy.

This top also requires a full coverage top underneath because it is sooo itchy.

It was cute but it was just too small for me. Suggest to size up.

Really great statement top! Flattering cut and true to size.

I wore this to a conference and received multiple compliments on the top. It did get a bit itchy by the end of the day, but very warm and well fitting.

Super cute and flattering. A little itchy. Hard to zip and un zip on my solo trip but overall loved it.

Loved the fit. The faux wrap belt is perfect. Loved the sleeves. Perfect with jeans for work or night out.

I rented this top to wear on a trip, and I loved it so much that I wore it 6 times. It fits beautifully, and the belt is a nice touch. The shoulders are bold and make you stand out, but the muted colors bring a nice balance. I would definitely invest in this shirt!

Pro: High quality No cons!

I'm big busted so couldn't wear a bra, but it fit well enough it worked out!

Great fit!

Love, love, loved this top! It had great structure while still being comfortable and was absolutely adorable!

Great fit!!

This is a great top! I didn't end up wearing because it was too hot! Would be great for a lunch date or casual dinner. It's heavy so has to be worn in cooler weather.

Cool puff sleeves.

This was cute. The model pics don't really show how big the shoulders are- I definitely got a lot of (positive) comments. It was fun to wear to work, although yes, it was a bit itchy.

Loved the fit and look. Only challenge is that it is wool so there was a bit of scratchiness all day. Nevertheless - worth it. Really well made -- the kind of piece you put on and feel polished

The body of this fit beautifully. The material was a bit itchy, and the shoulders were very puffy (see the side view before renting!) but I thought it was fun to wear and I got a few compliments.