I got a medium and it fit more like a small. It was still a cute top for the holiday!

Rented this for a Hanukkah party that I hosted. It was OK! The XS was a little chunky to tuck in with a skirt but I was able to finagle it. Minus one star because the material is stiff, scratchy, and uncomfortable. Thought about lounging in it before/after the party but it's not something you want to lay around the house in, it's something you want to change out of to relax in something more comfortable.

Rented this to wear casually for Hanukkah. It's a cute sweatshirt. Kind of boxy so I tucked it in. Not the softest material but still comfortable. Shoulders were sufficiently narrow for me which was good. Overall fun to wear.

Fun Hanukkah item. Boxy fit, I actually clipped the back together with a hair clip for the photo because otherwise it looked baggy. Got a lot of compliments on it.

I love the wider crew neck of this sweatshirt. The letters are made of some other textile which seemed to make them stand out even more against the solid blue. Only con was that the the sweatshirt lost shape around the bottom/waist as the day went along.

I wore this sweatshirt for my family Hanukkah party. I dressed it up with leather pants and booties.

Rented this sweatshirt to signal the upcoming 8 nights of lights. It's was a miracle I returned it before the end of this glorious celebration but I felt so festive it seemed selfish to keep it from other Jews (and shiksas looking to impress Jewish moms). Fuzzy warm and perfect for spinning the dreidel. I styled with skinny jeans and Sorel booties.

Perfect sweatshirt for the holidays! Fits TTS, like a normal sweatshirt. For some work week looks follow @renttherunway_teacher on Instagram!

I was a little late to renting for shelter in place, so I thought this would be fun and comfortable. Even though I'm just lounging around the apartment, I would have preferred the XS. I'm confused that others my size liked the S.

comfortable and perfect for cozy lounging.

Cute

Great Hanukkah sweatshirt. Wore it on a lazy Sunday. RTR only had a S available, which I would typically never wear in this brand, but it was fine. It fit more like a cropped sweatshirt (still a little boxy) in that size.

same

I received loads of compliments when I wore this throughout the Hanukkah season this year. That being said, it was a bit thinner than I would have preferred for the cold New England December we had. The sleeves were shorter than I would have liked, but not short enough to make it too awkward, so I still wore it. All in all it was great for my virtual Hanukkah celebration!

Wide neck and short sleeves

Stiffer and smaller than I thought it would be. The arms were a little short on me. Cute for every day.

...but it was scratchy, made me look like a box, and much shorter than it looked in the picture.

I had planned on wearing this to a Hala baking event, but it was scratchy and stuff and just not comfortable. The arms are slightly short for me as well.

Perfect for the holiday season/Hannukah and also as a bridal sweater. It is very comfortable and flattering.