This sweater was adorable. It can be dressed up or down, and it worked for casual in Arizona or out in New York City. It does run a littttle small. It fit fine but if I was going to buy it, I would get the medium

A bit baggy under the armpits, but looked very good especially paired with the pants. I was not prepared for how fashionable and professional it made me appear! With I could keep it! Love this sweater. I could have done with a medium, but it may have been to tight around the arms and I do not have big arms. RTR recommended Large so I went with Large. The reviewer who said that it is too big and too small all at the same time was absolutely right. That's why I put "Just Right" for fit. There is gapping between the buttons, but that would occur no matter what size was chosen. I wish they had sewn the front placket instead of leaving it open so that it appears like a cardigan, which is what causes the gapping. It is actually a pullover! I read complaints that the fabric was stiff. It is simply a thick good quality fabric and the stiffness may come from the starching that is necessary for our rentals to look new and not worn.

Wore this with the wide leg Tibi pants also from RTR and loved it!

Nicely cut and very nice structured material. Loved the whimsical take on a staple. I often go with XS in tops and was glad I went with the S. A bit cropped on my torso but otherwise fit perfectly.

Love this faux cardigan. You can't open the bottoms, so don't be fooled. The weight is nice and thick but cool to the touch so you won't be hot. It kept its shape nicely and fit tts .

you will get tons of compliments without it being a crazy statement. super cute and unique top!

This is so cute I can't even stand it! It's tight though, and cropped. Pairs well with a pencil skirt.

Fits true to size. Isn't cropped or too long, just the right length to meet the top of my high rise jeans. I LOVE the buttons on this and the quality, it feels like a very high quality material. I am thinking about purchasing this sweater because it is so cute and comfortable, but it MIGHT be out of my price range, I'm very tempted though!

I'm obsessed with this sweater, I've rented it twice and wore it multiple times each time. It's super flatter and great quality fabric. The "buttons" are so unique and made me feel very beachy for my trip to South Carolina!

It does gap at the buttons. High quality sweater material.

Love this sweater for a Sunday around town ! Very cozy and I received tons of compliments about the unique buttons - NOTE: they're just for show - the sweater isn't a cardigan that can be worn open.

Loved this so much the first time I wore it! on the second wear it felt a little stretched and didn't look quite as polished as it did before

This runs rather small, I'm not normally an XL and still had a lot of gapping. I do have chubby upper arms and even though this is a knit o was a little uncomfortable. The quality is great, knit is nice and thick. I'd think that since the buttons aren't functional they could have stitched the front closed. Buttons get 5 stars, rest of the top gets 3

It was definitely a sweater on the smaller side. The material is thick, but it stretched enough to be comfortable. The buttons are really what makes this a statement sweater. It was so unique with the flat gemlike material. Also a crop top so I recommend pairing with high waisted pants or shorts.

This sweater is so cute, but I didn’t love the fit. The sweater gapped between buttons and bulged out under the ribs. Wish I could have worn it, but just didn’t flatter me

Beautiful sweater fits great but gaps between buttons.

I normally wear a M and wore a L in this one and it was perfect not too snug

The buttons really made this look. The fit is cropped and fitted, it basically went with everything and I wore it counless times. Note that is it not a cardigan, it's sewn together.

Loved this top. So cute for spring. Very flattering - not too tight. I'm between a M and L, and went L.

I loved this sweater! The faux buttons really made it a unique piece

This was super form fitting and flattering but too tight to wear to work sadly! The buttons don't button... it's a pull over! I'm going to wear it on a date instead.

Love the buttons!

cute, all around good fit

Very flattering and the buttons are so cute

Loved the design of the fake buttons. The material could be more soft to make it more comfortable.

Form-fitting sweater

This sweater is so fun and flattering. It's perfect for the fake spring when it's still chilly but sunny and you'd feel silly wearing a turtleneck. I have a large chest snd broad shoulders so the top button gapes a little bit otherwise so so cute

I followed previous reviews to size up for this one, given my more full bust. I still needed to pin to prevent gapping between the buttons, but once I did the sweater laid flat and was super cute. I loved the muted tones on the buttons and the knit was the perfect weight for a fall day. I do wish the buttons were real and not just sewn on, to have the option to wear this as a cardigan.

It's cute and basic. I wanted a little more but it was still nice

Tight across the bust, but fun to wear.

Absolutely loved the look of the sweater, the buttons are sooo cute and the color is a really nice pure white. The fabric of the sweater is what ruined this sweater for me, it was clingy, baggy and gapping at the buttons all at the same time and SO unflattering. I think I might try sizing down to see if that fixes the issue because I really wanted to love it!

It's cute for everyday

Loved the button details of this sweater. However wasn't in love with the fit or the fabric. There wasn't a lot of retention and the sleeves were a bit baggy on me. Didn't get a lot of use of it. If the fabric was better, this would be a winner!

this is a cute style but more cropped than shown in the picture

I usually wear a M, sometimes L in tops but went with an XL in this because I know buttoned up tops usually pull on me and I can't wear them bc there's a gap - same holds true with this top, unfortunately. I'm a 36D in VS bras and the XL gaps on me at the top in my normal bras. Such a shame because this really is such a cute shirt. The buttons are just for show.