4.5
40 Reviews

Includes written reviews and customer fit feedback.

Most members say this item
Runs True to Size
Fit Summary
Runs Small (9)
True to Size (27)
Runs Large (3)
Member Photos (0)

So cute!

I wore this dress for an anniversary dinner. I got so many compliments on the dress! I felt cute and girly and like a cupcake in the best way. I wore with the sleeves down for a less poofy look.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 4


AudrienneTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 2"

118 lbs

Straight & Narrow

34B

34 yrs

Browse Audrienne's reviews (83)

My cousins Oregon coast wedding was incredible

Her theme was “the thing you never have the opportunity to wear” and this dress has been on my hearts since the beginning. Its moment was glorious, I think.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XL

Usual Size: 14


SarahIncentivized

Size 14

5' 7"

190 lbs

Hourglass

36D

37 yrs

Browse Sarah's reviews (119)

Wore for a photo shoot

And it was AMAZING. Poofy, short, adorable, and gave me boobs like Elizabeth Bennett in Pride and Prejudice

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XXS

Usual Size: 0


AndiTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 6"

115 lbs

Straight & narrow

32C

32 yrs

Browse Andi's reviews (7)

Such a fun dress!

The small was a little tight in the chest, but the medium was too big, so made the small the small work.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 6


LisaTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 4"

143 lbs

Athletic

34D

43 yrs

Browse Lisa's reviews (139)

Love it!

Th is dress is one of my favorite rentals. Fresh, feminine and flirty. Some reviewers think it is a young look, but I think it's great for any age. Styling make the difference! Highly recommend!!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XXL

Usual Size: 14


KimTop Contributor

Size 14

5' 6"

200 lbs

Hourglass

38D

57 yrs

Browse Kim's reviews (23)

Wore it to a premiere and everyone loved it!

I styled it for a horror movie premiere and everyone loved it!!! The only note is that it was too small in the bust, but that’s my fault because I took an XXS as it was the only size available at the time I needed it. I love Selkie dresses so much and this was a moment!!! Thank you RTR for helping me wear statement outfits in a sustainable way as someone who always has an event to go to 🤎🤎

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: XXS

Usual Size: 4


SheilaTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 8"

122 lbs

Straight & narrow

32A

27 yrs

Browse Sheila's reviews (10)

Tons of compliments- you’ll definitely stand out

Wore this to a black tie optional event with my boyfriend who also likes to be a little different, and have zero regrets! Bought a size Large cuz I have a wide rib cage, even though my chest is small. It was comfy! So many people complimented me. I’m pretty tall, 5’7” and it’s not too short on me. I think a platform shoe is the best option to balance the volume up top personally. Wore with black tights & a pearl headband & gave Bridgerton vibes.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: L

Usual Size: 8


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 7"

175 lbs

Athletic

34B

26 yrs

Browse RTR Member's reviews (1)

So much fun

Love Selkie, so much fun but be prepared to stand out.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XL

Usual Size: 12


IdaniaTop Contributor

Size 12

5' 3"

178 lbs

Hourglass

38B

37 yrs

Browse Idania's reviews (148)

Fun, on trend baby doll dress

Gosh, this is a dress that I would never buy, but I sure as heck would rent it. Such a fun silhouette, and I loved the neutral colors and the plaid. Extremely striking, I got compliments everywhere I went. I am 54, and it was a tad short, so I just wore biker shorts underneath. fun, fun, fun!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 2


SandraTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 4"

120 lbs

Hourglass

34C

46 yrs

Browse Sandra's reviews (149)

Too cute

Felt so girly, wore to a holiday party and got so many compliments. Wear the dress!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XL

Usual Size: 12


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 12

5' 10"

Pear

36D

37 yrs

Browse RTR Member's reviews (13)

Obsessed!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 4


SarahTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 6"

Athletic

34B

38 yrs

Browse Sarah's reviews (67)

Cute!

I could have sized down so it was a little tighter across the chest. But it was cute and comfortable - wore it to a “creative black tie” benefit, then out dancing where it was fun to twirl in.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: XXL

Usual Size: 12


TracieTop Contributor

Size 12

5' 6"

170 lbs

Full Bust

38G

48 yrs

Browse Tracie's reviews (29)

Babydoll on steroids

The cuteness factor of this dress is off the charts.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XXL

Usual Size: 12


DanetteTop Contributor

Size 12

5' 6"

190 lbs

Hourglass

36C

52 yrs

Browse Danette's reviews (302)

Fun and cute!

This is the third Selkie dress I’ve rented, this time for a drag show, I loved it so much! The bodice is slightly see-through, I used breast tape to avoid a bra showing and it worked out great. I always get so so so many compliments in the puff dresses, definitely worth a rental.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 6


EmilyTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 3"

130 lbs

Petite

34B

26 yrs

Browse Emily's reviews (123)

LOVE but a little itchy

I love this dress so much! It is literally perfect, fit in all the right places. The arms and waist seam are just a little bit itchy so it was quite a relief to take it off, but I felt like my best self in this! Got tons of compliments too!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XXS

Usual Size: 0


ClareTop Contributor

Size 0

5' 2"

105 lbs

Hourglass

32B

27 yrs

Browse Clare's reviews (63)

Party Perfection

Perfect for a birthday party and go so many compliments. I'm a 38 DD and while I could fit my bust in it was a tad tight so would recommend if in my size to go up.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: L

Usual Size: 10


Whitney raquelTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 6"

178 lbs

Hourglass

38DD

33 yrs

Browse Whitney raquel's reviews (10)

Perfection

This is the perfect holiday dress that adds a dash of whimsy to any event you wear this to. Absolutely loved it!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: M

Usual Size: 10


StephanyTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 3"

164 lbs

Hourglass

36D

33 yrs

Browse Stephany's reviews (94)

Classic Selkie

The perfect short dress with DRAMA! Classic Selkie fit. Elastic on the arms so it can best fit you!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 4


CarolineTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 3"

125 lbs

Athletic

34C

25 yrs

Browse Caroline's reviews (179)

Amazing dress

Got so many compliments!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: M

Usual Size: 4


KathleenTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 7"

131 lbs

Straight & narrow

36B

36 yrs

Browse Kathleen's reviews (28)

Catholic school girl for Halloween party

These selkie dresses are so adorable and I wanted to costumeify this one to go as a catholic school girl to a Halloween party and it worked out super well. So cute with hints of sexiness.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 4


ErikaTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 5"

133 lbs

Hourglass

34D

26 yrs

Browse Erika's reviews (533)

House Party MVP

Wore this to a house party where I was the oldest in the room by 10 years. Honestly skyrocketed my confidence. Everyone was obsessed with the dress and I honestly wish I could wear it everyday. I usually don’t go for silhouettes this playful, but TRUST me when I say you need to rent this at least once. I felt like a Barbie doll. ALSO it’s not as short as it looks. I though I’d have to wear shorts underneath it and was pleasantly surprised .

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XXS

Usual Size: 2


KineshaTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 6"

129 lbs

Athletic

32B

34 yrs

Browse Kinesha's reviews (157)

Quite the look!

A really cute dress. I wore it to a bday party and had lots of fun with this playful look. It’s a little tight or fits just right if you have a larger bust. Very short so wear darker tights or shorts underneath.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XL

Usual Size: 10


JessicaTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 7"

183 lbs

Full Bust

36DD

39 yrs

Browse Jessica's reviews (28)

Flirty

Little too much for a bridal shower so didn’t wear it out, longer than expected

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 6


KaitlinTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 7"

128 lbs

Straight & narrow

39 yrs

Browse Kaitlin's reviews (1)

Fun but VERY young

Cute dress but I would not recommend for anyone over the age of 25… It fit nicely but made me feel painfully old. Toddlers in Tiaras vibes, unfortunately

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XS

Usual Size: 4


CamilliaTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 5"

125 lbs

Hourglass

32D

31 yrs

Browse Camillia's reviews (263)

Too short

Cute for a celebration but dress is very short

Member Fit Notes

Runs small
Too short

Size Worn: XS

Usual Size: 6


TiffanyTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 5"

140 lbs

Athletic

34B

36 yrs

Browse Tiffany's reviews (22)

Loved it

The chest area will fit tightly if you have a larger chest. I would advize sizing up for that reason if you have a larger chest but the rest fit very true to size.

Member Fit Notes

Runs small
small in Chest
Just right in Arms & Shoulders
Just right in Waist
Just right in Hips
Just right in Length

Size Worn: XL

Usual Size: 14


DanielaTop Contributor

Size 14

5' 2"

185 lbs

Hourglass

38DD

21 yrs

Browse Daniela's reviews (27)

So fun!!

Wore this to a concert and got so many compliments! Of course it's short, so paired it with black tights! Love!!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 4


AmyTop Contributor

Size 4

5' 6"

134 lbs

Athletic

32D

25 yrs

Browse Amy's reviews (18)

So fun

Felt elegant yet fun.

Size Worn: XXS

Usual Size: 2


JoannaTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 8"

118 lbs

Pear

32DD

34 yrs

Browse Joanna's reviews (42)

CUTE but obviously...

This dress is so cute, but jokingly I called it my pennywise outfit because the pattern feels oddly clown

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: M

Usual Size: 8


MinheeTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 4"

130 lbs

Athletic

34B

32 yrs

Browse Minhee's reviews (7)

Such a fun look

Really unique fit… best dressed guest for sure

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XS

Usual Size: 2


BeccaTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 5"

130 lbs

Athletic

22 yrs

Browse Becca's reviews (2)

Wrong size

Was not able to wear. Super cute but ordered the wrong size. Needed a small.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: XS

Usual Size: 6


SolangeTop Contributor

Size 6

5' 4"

136 lbs

Hourglass

32C

53 yrs

Browse Solange's reviews (52)

Fit everywhere but the boobs

The dress itself would have fit fine but my boobs were too big for the M - the large was too big everywhere. Was just kind of a miss. If you're over a B cup I wouldn't get this.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: M

Usual Size: 10


ChristinaTop Contributor

Size 10

5' 2"

165 lbs

Petite

34C

29 yrs

Browse Christina's reviews (21)

Didn't wear

Sadly way too small for anyone with a bust. Super bummed.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: XXL

Usual Size: 16


LynseyTop Contributor

Size 16

5' 5"

Full Bust

36DDD/E

35 yrs

Browse Lynsey's reviews (13)

A large small

I usually oscillate between a xs and a small. This was closer to a medium. It was very cute but I had to pin it to my bra. Order down!

Member Fit Notes

Runs big

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 2


SarahTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 5"

Hourglass

34 yrs

Browse Sarah's reviews (38)

I couldn’t stop twirling in it.

I wore this for a photo shoot. I wanted to feel flirty and girly while still sticking to darker colors and this dress was perfect. I could not stop twirling and twisting from side to side. It was a little tight in the bust area, but nothing that ruined the look.

Member Fit Notes

True to Size

Size Worn: XL

Usual Size: 16


NinaTop Contributor

Size 16

5' 2"

209 lbs

Pear

40DD

29 yrs

Browse Nina's reviews (8)

cute but bulky

it fits big. im normally a small/medium and i could have gone with xxl/xs

Member Fit Notes

Runs Large

Size Worn: S

Usual Size: 2


RTR MemberTop Contributor

Size 2

5' 0"

110 lbs

Petite

34C

Browse RTR Member's reviews (3)

Too small

Member Fit Notes

Runs small

Size Worn: M

Usual Size: 8


JessicaTop Contributor

Size 8

5' 5"

145 lbs

43 yrs

Browse Jessica's reviews (19)

Cute Dress

The fit was basically perfect, though the fabric is polyester and the texture was a bit crunchy. Short, floofy, and flattering!

Member Fit Notes

True to Size
Just right in Chest
Just right in Arms & Shoulders
Just right in Waist
Just right in Hips
Just right in Length

Size Worn: XL

Usual Size: 16


Brittany Top Contributor

Size 16

5' 0"

175 lbs

Hourglass

33 yrs

Browse Brittany 's reviews (14)

Fail

Didn’t fit and the style wouldn’t have worked anyway.

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: XXL

Usual Size: 18


AntoinetteTop Contributor

Size 18

5' 1"

235 lbs

Apple

42DD

37 yrs

Browse Antoinette's reviews (10)

If you have boobs, it will not fit correctly

Member Fit Notes

Runs Small

Size Worn: XXL

Usual Size: 16


GiTop Contributor

Size 16

5' 7"

235 lbs

Hourglass

41 yrs

Browse Gi's reviews (8)

Here to brighten up your inbox.

Emails are the fastest way to learn about new styles, sales, and more.

By clicking submit, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.