I've been on a lookout for a cozy oversized knit sweater that is not heavy and doesn't have a lumpy fabric. Then I saw this Sweet Baby Jamie knit sweater on the site, et voilà! I love the bell sleeve style, the drop-shoulder design, and the soft fabric. It's very cozy and goes well with skinny jeans. The fabric is not too heavy nor too thick. It's perfect to wear when the weather drops to 40s-50s. What's more, I like that I could wear it with jeans for casual or leather pants for a dressy look.

Definitely an oversized fit- I am 5'10 and the small was quite large (which is what I was going for). I personally found the fabric a teensy bit itchy but I think most people would find it very comfortable! Love this brand!

It's a nice heavy sweater. The only downside for me is that the sleeves are pretty long. It's warm and not at all itchy.

Loved this sweater. It was a cute yet comfy sweater that was perfect for the holiday season and family gatherings

This was the first time I rented something from this designer and I'm now hooked. I find it tricky to find a thick, non-itchy, chunky sweater that fits well and doesn't look too baggy but this fit all the criteria! It's a simple, well made basic that pairs well with anything. i loved the rich chocolate brown color and wish there were more colors. I'm a size small/medium in sweaters and I have long arms and this fit really well.

This was a perfect oversized sweater, great for a cold day. The bell sleeve is great, and it's a nice brown/olive toned color. Very warm!

Great fit in the body. THe sleeves are extremely long

Super cozy and comfy! I rented it for a weekend in the mountains: wore it traveling up and back - once with jeans and once with leggings. Then when I got home, I rocked it to a Super Bowl party (with jeans) and to work on Monday (with black pants and brown ankle boots.) A little oversized but not in a bad way. Like other reviewers, I cuffed the sleeves to keep them out of my way, but I actually thought it looked cuter that way. Not super memorable, but a solid choice for weekend wear.

Super comfortable and loved the quality and color! The sleeves were a bit too long for me. Not the best fit for a short person.

Super cute! over sized look, could be dressed up or dressed down.

I will rent this again but it's not an attention grabbing sweater. It was comfortable and warm. It runs big as I usually rent a large but the medium was perfect.

I LOVED this sweater. It's soft, warm, cozy, and cute and I never wanted to take it off!

Oversized perfect sweater. Would rent again in a heartbeat, loved.

Love this top -- it's my favorite type of look - a stylish and trendy 60+ year old woman!

I was pleasantly surprised. When I originally tried it on I wasn't sure about it but ended up pulling off a cute outfit and received many compliments.

Nice quality, however the excessively long sleeves (on this and so many pieces on RTR it seems) is simply not functional. I ended rolling the sleeves up into a large cuff - which actually didn't look awful - so it made it possible to wear the sweater more comfortably for 3 wearings. It's a good rental for a warm, wearable sweater of good quality - but wasn't super special.

This was a thick, well made sweater. It worked great for the holidays with skinny jeans and booties, but is too big and boxy to wear solo. I tried it with a skirt and tights and I was just swimming in it. It was good for everyday but too expensive for it to be worn one way.

This sweater does run really large and the sleeves are very long as it has been said in other reviews, but I just cuffed the sleeves. I live in Florida so we don't have extremely cold days but we travel for work to cooler climates. I will rent this again but I will get a small.

This ran large on me - I ordered a small and expected it to be a bit loose but it was pretty baggy, the shoulders seemed broad as well. I would definitely order a size down but it was still cute enough to wear as an oversized sweater!

Rented this for the cold weather in NYC over Christmas and New Years. It was incredibly comfortable and I literally didn't want to take it off!! Got so many compliments on it as well. Is definitely an oversized fit so the sleeves are a little long - would probably need to be cuffed for a shorter person.

Ran a little big but I kind of liked that!

I received so many compliments on this sweater! It was so comfortable and stylish. Highly recommend!

Other reviewers reported that the sleeves were very long on this sweater. I folded them to make a large cuff which added detail to the sweater and took care of the length problem. Looks great with jeans or slim fitting skirt.

Perfectly soft and warm sweater. The drop shoulder and oversized fit made it flattering without overwhelming me (cuz I'm short). It was even warm enough for me to wear it as an outer layer in 40-degree weather. Paired it with the Rosetta Getty pants and tweed minis.

I probably could have gone a size smaller but loved anyway. The sleeves were a bit too long for me, but loved the look.

Definitely listen to the title: this sweater is oversized...to the max. It is very comfortable, but the small was too large to wear to work because it bordered unprofessional. I will rent again in an XS and report back!

I loved the sleeves on this sweater, but the fit of the body was not flattering. The sweater was also pretty worn and pilly when I received.

Very nice. Fit well, was warm- just nothing out of the ordinary.

I'd pick a size smaller.

Cute, comfy sweater but not spectacular

Sweater was baggy and bulky but not in a cute way. Not the most cozy either. Just wasn't flattering on my body.

I live in Chicago and live in chunky knits, turtlenecks, and coats that go past my knees. I rented this in February (ie the dead of winter) and it was WAYYYYY too warm to wear around the office. I literally changed into a T-shirt halfway through the day because I was sweating so much in this. The warmth was great for being outside in subzero wind chill (with coat) but it was just too thick and insulated for indoors. Weird. The fit didn't do me any favors either.

I didn't end up wearing this sweater. I got an XS and the sleeves were way too long as well as the length. I had to double check the size on tag to see if they have sent me a large by accident.

Sweater was cute but the sleeves came almost to my knees. I do have small and sloping shoulders which did not help - but the entire sweater was really over sized