All pros no cons. This is the best coat ever! It is so versatile! I wore it in freezing New Hampshire and wasn't cold at all! If I had the money and didn't live in sunny Los Angeles I would definitely purchase this beauty!!! (Also want to emphasize how much I love the attached button vest and hood!!!)

I live in MN and wore this to an evening work function on a 10 degree, windy night. It was very warm without being bulky and a little something more than your average black coat.

Obviously a very warm coat! Looks cute open or closed. I wore this several times this month on chilly and snowy days over layers. Hood is an added bonus for warmth. Wouldn't wear this in weather over 45-50 degrees.

No cons! Love it.

I really like this coat. I wore every day I had it. No compliments from others, as it's kind of basic, But I got a lot of joy out of it, so that's what matters. The hood is one of those good deep hoods. In my picture I tried to show the coat " within" the coat, which was helpful for quick trips when I didn't have the coat all the way up zipped up I could just snap those. That part is cropped like a sweatshirt with basic snaps.

Rented this as a trial since my current coat doesn't fit well over a sweater. Overall it's nice, very warm and holds shape well. Would be great in a different color. I usually don't like zipper pockets since they can cut up your hands, but reveling soft cuffs are great and this hasn't been a problem. Will hold onto it for another month.

Love this brand out of Montreal - great winter coats

I seriously love everything about this coat - the inner layer is super soft and warm and the cut of the wool outer layer is wonderfully flattering - even with layers underneath. Make sure you have a lint roller handy though. The only downside is that it does pick up a good amount of lint. But so worth it!

Really beautiful ! Goes with everything and can be worn casually and for more formal occasions . Was the only jacket i needed in Ireland. Got lots of compliments and is very much an smart , and classy coat.

I have been looking for this style for so long - I actually had to buy it that's how in love I am. The extra under layer is great for those in between days at the end of the winter (I'm a Bostonian so you never know what you will get). The hood is super cute and great for windy days. It was warm, stylish, and a great twist on the wool style coat. Must rent for winter season.

Rented this for a rainy weekend in Napa. Worked with boots + denim and also wore with over a dress at night. Tons of compliments on this one!

Basic enough to wear over and over, but also interesting enough not to be boring. The fit with the slight flare from the waist is so flattering. I love this coat. I am considering buying it.

This is a great everyday coat for work. It looks elegant with nicer outfits, and casual outfits as well. Very warm and comfortable.

Great fitting jacket, flattering, warm and comfortable

This coat was fabulous and warm. There is an extra layer of thermal button up on the inside Other coats I have rented from RTR have been super fashionable, but not warm at all. I liked this so much I purchased it.

Jacket is super duper warm and comfortable. True to size. Will rent again.

I LOVE this coat. I have long arms (especially for someone not so tall) and this coat fit perfectly. I wanted something a bit between day and nighttime for a weekend in NYC and this was perfect. Great coat, warm, but not too bulky.

I absolutely loved this jacket and wore it for about a week straight in winter in MN (so you know it has to be warm). I loved the style, sleeve length was perfect, and it's just an overall very well made jacket. Will definitely rent again.

I wore this on a 20degF day, with 3 layers of clothing, i was warm and toasty without being too bulky. The snap on vest makes it very unique. I got several compliments. The hood is a good size and not overwhelming. It picks up lint though, but nothing a lint remover can't handle.

I'd had my eye on this coat for a while and it finally became avail in my unlimited plan so I snagged it. I love it. It is warm without being unflattering, and I like the small puffer details at the sleeves and the attached vest inside. I do wish the arms were a tidge longer, but I'm very tall so that's a common issue for me. I will keep it a bit longer. Might even buy it.

worn this to Sundance Film Festival in Park City, it was PERFECT. Nice fit over bulky sweater and scarf

I love the vest inside coat look that is very popular right now, and this coat does that perfectly. Nice pockets, great big hood. It's pretty warm and versatile. Overall a nice winter coat.

Fit was tailored, not bulky. Great winter coat.

Such a flattering, warm jacket. It works well for work and everyday. The only complaint is the black fabric picks up every hint of lint, so I had to lint roll daily to get rid of pet hair. I rented it for about two weeks and intend to rent again in the future.

I wore this on a December vacation to London and Amsterdam - it was perfect for the trip. I'd say it runs slightly large as it fit me great even with sweater underneath and I'm typically between med & large sizes. Looks great, definitely elevated my vacay style!

I usually wear a medium so I wasn't sure this was going to fit but I wanted to try it out - was a little snug but still fit, even with bulky sweaters underneath. This jacket is SO warm and has a vest-like thing underneath that you button up before zipping the outer section. Planning to keep it all winter.

So cute. Warm and stylish. Wore it on vacation in Portland. It was chilly and drizzling but I felt cute and warm. The hood was helpful too when the temperature dropped.

Comfortable, sleek, warm, stylish. I want to buy it.

I loved this coat. Beautifully made! I enjoyed wearing it. It fit well although not over anything bulky, which is why said it runs a bit small. I received many compliments and it was perfect for the fall and early winter. The liner cuffs and inner jacket make it really cozy.

Warm enough for 50's . Gorgeous coat .

I LOVED this jacket! It's the perfect mix of casual and sophisticated. Nice and warm and great length. If I could afford it, I'd buy it! I will rent again.

Very flattering and get a lot of compliments when I wear it.

This coat is sleek with a sprinkling of magic. I loved the different textures and the hood! It's warm but doesn't provide much movement if you're going to be active in it!

Fits perfectly, warm and cozy. Great for everyday. The black does show some lint.

I rented this just to see what it would look like on. I loved it, but it would be far to warm for our mild winters. Would be great for a weekend in NYC.

I didn’t realize that the built in puffer coat on the inside had it’s own front snaps so to close the entire jacket you had to snap up the puffer part and then zip up the wool coat. The coat was warm and looked nice dressed up or dressed down.

I sized up based on previous reviews but found it to be way too big. I was swimming in it.

Love the jacket, I normally wear a size 6, and the medium was way too big!

I rented this coat as an in between coat for when the temp was not too cold out. I expected the coat to look more high end. The fabric is kind of wrinkled and does not lay well. Disappointed.