I loved this off the shoulder sweater for date night or a girls night out. Pairs perfectly with jeans or black pants. I will say that it moves around and up quite a bit so I had to adjust it several times, definitely not a good choice if you’re doing anything active! Otherwise a great pick!!

Great fit, cropped length and looks good with high waisted pants. Very soft, can be worn even more off the shoulder if wanted. Loved this! True red color, great for holiday.

Awesome fit! Comfy & not itchy. Runs true to size. Great dressed up or down. One of my favs!

Wore this to my holiday work dinner and got lots of compliments on it. Not sure if it was my shoulders but it did not want to stay below my shoulders so as you see in the photo it looked like a cowl neck on me and sometimes like a turtle neck. Still cute though.

My favorite thing about this sweater is how rich the red is. It’s a great body hugging fit, so size up if you are between sizes. Only 4 stars because it can be a little annoying adjusting the shoulder area but I found if you pull it down far enough it will stay out for the most part and lay pretty flat. Would rent again.

This sweater was decent! Color and material were gorgeous but the fit was strange. The shoulders would not stay down and I didn't find it flattering when it turned into a cowl neck. Probably wouldn't rent again.

As other reviews said, the shoulders did not want to stay down so I had to keep fidgeting with them. But loved the look and color. The fabric is form fitting, it will show every curve. But I loved the look and paired with printed jeans I also rented from RTR.

Like several reviews warned, this does not stay in place. Also it’s not soft at all. Fabric was not as nice as I hoped. I wore it once but I won’t get this one again.

I really liked this top but throughout the day it did become itchy for me.

I pinned the shoulders down and they still wouldn’t stay. The top itself fit well but the shoulders were hard to keep down. The material was also nice and the color vibrant.

Very thick and warm. Cute for holiday partit

Fit well, weathe was too warm to wear. Nice thick material, great cut.

Runs small

I loved this so much I bought it after wearing it 3 times in one week. Perfect for holidays and dates, indoors or out (Seattle weather), can be worn with shoulders up or down, won't stay down easily but so worth tugging it back into place... SO PRETTY! Warm but not overly so. Also wore it with tank top underneath to hide bra straps while wearing shoulders down, still looked sexy and chic.

Fits a bit small in the arms. Cute though.

Very flattering and festive while not being too flashy. V comfy as well.

I didn't wear this as an off-the-shoulder look, I think it would ride up if you moved at all. But, it doesn't need to be off-the-shoulder to be darling. This is a great sweater for January in Chicago, you can look great but not freeze.

The sweater is warm. Nice heavyweight knit. I wear a medium but the large fit perfectly. Good off the shoulder or not.

Note as the other reviews do, because of the fabric the shoulders will not stay down- it's like a wide turtleneck. The color is pretty and fabric is nice and soft

Gorgeous red color, great for a dinner you want to be warm for! Felt awesome in this top

I really liked this one! Wore it with a casual outfit and then with a more dressed up occasion. Only complaint is that you can't move your arms much at all without the neck completely coming up, more so than other off the shoulder outfits I've had

Nice top, true to size. I had to keep adjusting it but that’s to be expected with off the shoulder type sweaters. It looked cute with jeans. Not a bad rental but nothing fabulous.

Loved this sweater. Thick and soft but wouldn’t recommend for anything that involves lifting your arms! Haha doesn’t stay down.

The collar kept riding up so I never wore it out.

I've rented a few off the shoulder tops this winter and this one did not stay put as well as all of the others I have rented in the past. The color and material are great, but getting it to stay in place was impossible. I probably wouldn't rent again for that reason.

Beautiful color and good fit, but the shoulders constantly rode up and ended up as kind of in between a cow neck and a turtle neck. I have a large chest, so that might be part of the issue, but I ended up sending it back without wearing it.

If you’re a larger-chested gal, I highly recommend investing in a quality strapless bra for this piece. I didn’t like how the sweater shaped me, and didn’t end up wearing it.

Pretty color

Very snug at waist

This was a beautiful color, but it was super tight like I had been dried 1 million times. And if you wanted to lift your arms above your waist the off the shoulder shrug would fold up towards your neck.

The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is because it had a hard time staying below my shoulders

Beautiful red, quality material. I usually wear a Medium in tops and rented the l and it was still very fitted. Awkward fit in shoulders and sleeves, very warm, thick ribbed material, still soft

Very warm material. The collar slides up frequently