I have no complaints about these jeans. I know that I wear a size larger in Reformation pants than I do in other high street brands (madewell for example) so I knew to size up. These are incredibly comfortable and didn't lose their stretch. I also love the straight leg and thought the length was perfect

Fits true to size!! I got so many compliments on these jeans!

Really cute pants. I loved the industrial/construction vibes!

Looking at other reviews I decided to size up and I'm glad I did! Normally a size 28 and got a size 29 and they were tight (in a good way)-these make my (non existent) butt look great 10/10 would recommend

i am IN LOVE with these jeans. they fit perfectly, so comfortable with the perfect amount of stretch. i'm going to buy!

I find it hard to find high waisted jeans that fit me properly. I am pear shaped so my waist and hips are hard to fit together. My waist is 30" and my hips are 42" and I was very surprised that these fit so perfect for how straight they looked! I saw some reviews saying they were small or big but I bought my normal size and they fit perfect! I wear at least once a week!

Fit perfectly, hugged all the right places. The structure made me feel supported and were flattering to my curves.

Loved these- I'll be renting again. Perfect shape. Def on trend. Wear with leather boots

The fit on these jeans is incredible and the look is trendy but not *too* trendy for a millennial who's not totally ready to say goodbye to skinny jeans. I wear a 24-26 in Madewell and these felt comparable in a 27. I love them and got SO many compliments. Am definitely considering buying them!

Love the style, high waisted, but I did have some waist gapping. I have bigger thighs and butt, and they fit there, but waist was a bit big!

These were okay. Runs a bit tight in the waist but close enough to true to size. I personally didn't love them, so I didn't end up wearing them as they weren't what I was looking for, but they were comfortable (besides for the waist being a little tight).

Material is thicker, will keep you warm, but too thick for warm weather. Spacious around upper thigh area and hips. Nice quality. I didn't end up wearing them because they were too spaciously sized for me, despite fitting well on my waist.

I love renting jeans I wouldn't otherwise buy, like these carpenter jeans! They were cute but I'm glad I don't own them because they fit a bit odd. When I was standing they felt big around my waist and hips but when I sat down they were super uncomfortable and tight! Worked for the day I wore them but wouldn't rent again.

Great material, but the fit didn't work on me. The waist fit perfectly and it looked great from the back but bunched up near the zipper.

Very cute jeans but too tight in the waist, close enough to being true to size that I was able to wear them with an oversized sweater but they run a lot more snug than I anticipated but larger in the thighs. Cute in theory just not for my body type.

I really wanted to like these but, for me, these pants just weren't it. Ordered them for fun and ended up wearing them to both a casual work dinner and a concert. I had two sizes, a 27 (which is my usual) and a 28 (sized up based on reviews) and both were soooo tight in the waist for me, while I was swimming in fabric in the legs. I know they're not supposed to fit snugly through the legs but the overall look just didn't work on my body and it was frustrating that the waist didn't feel much bigger when I sized up. I still like the idea of these but won't get them again.

These jeans are ok. I really liked the carpenter-style, but on me, the fit was just ok.

The reviews said to size up a size, so I did but these ended up being massive. I'm usually a 28 since I have wider hips, I got a 29 and these literally were falling off me. I would get your normal size!

I wanted these jeans to work so bad! Ordered a 28R given that I'm usually a 27/28, but they were way too small. They have no stretch. I ordered a 29 and they fit better in the thighs, but were too big in the waist! Such a bummer.

I was so bummed about these, I probably needed to size up 2 sizes if I wanted them to fit. The legs fit fine - they were even a great length and I am 5'2" - but I could even zip them.

I am usually a size 8 in jeans but will size up to a 10 if it seems the jeans fit small. Sized up to a 10 and these were a mile away from being able to close. Would have had to go up to a 14 at least. Added an extra star because the length and material seemed great....definitely a huge bummer because they were completely unwearable.

The fit was cute and the pants looked nice but the strap hanging off the side was very unflattering and just didn't make sense. Would not rent again.

Literally couldn't get them over my hips. I wear a size 29 and the 30 was too small. Insane.

Did not even get close to zipping. I ordered in my usual size (27 for madewell, levi's, pac sun, etc) and had to double check the size I got sent because they were so small. Extremely disappointing.

I can wear a 6 or 28/29 in most pants. Small waist and larger butt and thighs. I feel like I got sent the wrong pants these were so bad. No room for a butt and about 8 inches from closing from the waist. Thanks for the confidence check reformation.

Really soft. Go with everything. Comfortable. Buying these!

I'm buying these. They're awesome. Wear with docs for a cool, casual look or dress them up with booties and a cute top. I'm obsessed

Love these pants!!! So comfortable while still being fitted. Straight cut works great with flats or heels!

These jeans are great. Super straight leg. High waisted. However- they do run very small. I am usually a 27R and got these in a 29R. I probably could have gotten a 28R if available. I will definitely be renting these again! Just be sure to size up 1 size!

Love the carpenter detail on these jeans! I originally rented a 27 because they felt a bit snug at first try on, and with the carpenter style being oversized can be cute. Swapped for a 26 because as I wore the 27 they loosened up a lot and became more than just oversized but straight up just too big.