Love these jeans! They fit me perfectly. I expected them to be a deeper shade of black but still like them! They are high waisted so they pair well with crop tops.

I'm usually a 27R in reformation jeans, and these are definitely more form fitted than normal, but in a very good way. I often have a bit of room at the waste in 27R, but these really feel tailored to me so I love the fit. They don't feel too tight at all, but if you are unsure, error on the size up.

Jeans were a little on the tight side material wise, and kind of flattened your backside. Regardless, super cute jeans that you can pair with almost anything.

Love these jeans. They are very structured, so they keep everything in place :p. They do run small, I would size up at least one size. I usually wear a 26 and these are definitely snug. I like the rise and the button fly, but I know that's not for everyone. Great length for petites!

Very stretchy and comfortable

These were just okay. I sized up 2 sizes from a 27 to a 29 because of the reviews and I'm glad I did - anything smaller would not have fit, especially through the hips. The fabric doesn't have a lot of give either. I found them to be stiff and not super flattering. I did like the high waist.

Wanted a new black jean so I thought I'd try these organic ones. I got my normal jean size-6-and could not even button them up. Oh and they are button fly not zip-so not my favorite. Also they are supposed to be cropped but they go to my ankle. Sad it didn't work out-oh well

Went up 2 sizes, like other reviewers suggested, and still had a hard time getting them to go all the way up my thighs. I have a more rectangle/athletic build, and these still fit weirdly tight in the butt & upper thigh--couldn't go up another size b/c the waist was also a little loose. This cut *might* be good for apple or inverted-triangle body types, but would not recommend for pear, hourglass, or other rectangle women out there. Would recommend sizing up regardless!

Runs extremely small. I will size up at least 2x.

Cute pants, quality denim and wash, easy to button up even with 6 fly buttons, but slim cut through hips that means they slide down. Larger waist did not help the sliding and bunched right in the crotch.

I followed others advice & sized up 2x. Could have probably gone with 1, but better to be safe. The fabric was heavy with some give but felt stiff. Flattened out my butt. I wore 1x. Not awful but plenty of better black jeans out there for petites.

too tight

as someone with thighs that have shape, i couldn't even get my legs into these. hello, body dysmorphia! giving 2 stars because they photograph well and were cute jeans, just not meant for me!

Let me preface by saying I wear a 25R in other Ref jeans. I literally could barely get these over my ANKLES much less my thighs. Definitely order at least two sizes up.

These jeans were very rigid and ran small

Small with no stretch. Sized up and was still not enough

disappointed I couldn't even put these on

Runs extremely small

N/A

I sized up after reading the reviews. I am typically s 27, I rented a 29 and I still didn't even bother trying to get them buttoned. The jeans were so stiff and there were only buttons no zipper which made the fact that they were so tight even worse.

I LOVE these jeans so much I just might buy them! They fit so well and they look great on just about anyone. Highly recommend!

They run large, so I'd recommend sizing down. I'm 5'6, 115, and usually between a 27/28 waist. I rented 27R and they were loose. (And the app suggested the 28s as my best fit!!)

These jeans are adorable! perfect skinny jeans. They were not as cropped on me as the girl in the photo and I am 5'6 but it doesn't matter. They are super skinny and cute!

Super cute high waisted black denim pants. There is very little elastic in these jeans, I've been wearing 25 in other denim and the 26 felt perfect standing up, but tight sitting at work all day. Would suggest sizing up. Otherwise highly recommend

I usually wear a size 0/XS and the 24R was just a little too tight for me. Considered trying the 25R, but I worry it will be too big.

These are great everyday jeans. However, they do fade with wear and stretch out.

I own lots of reformation jeans and the 25 usually fits me perfectly, but these were way too tight. I believe this is due to too much wear. I would recommend going a size up if you rent these!

I usually LOVE reformation jeans, for some reason these just didn’t do it for me. The actual jeans are beautiful, they looked brand new. I personally just didn’t like the fit on me. I usually wear a size 24 in jeans, but I got the 25 and I’m happy I did! I wouldn’t buy these, but I’m glad I rented them.

They were too small. I tried to pull them on & they wouldn't even go up. I hoped the size 31 would fit but I must be bigger than I thought.

I loved the jean's high quality, but fit was just ok. I like my jeans to really hug my calves, and these did not. Fit TTS in hips/waist.

Unfortunately these jeans were too snug and had no stretch whatsoever to them. Very uncomfortable and flattened my already small butt. Would not recommend if you're looking for a comfy pant.

Way too small, couldn't pull over my thighs.

I wear 27 in AG denim and citizens for humanity denim. I got a 27R in these and they were so small- never made it past my knees! Nice quality, not a ton of stretch- so definitely size up!

I normally wear a 24/25 in Ref jeans and couldn't even get these past my knees. Definitely size up

It was way to small. I went up a size. You have to go up about two or three sizes.

very stiff and thick jean fabric...size at least 2 sizes up

Literally not an ounce of stretch in these jeans. I'm a usual 29/28 and I couldn't even get these above my butt let alone button them. Size up maybe two sizes if you get these!

Got my usual size in every jean and wouldn't even close. It was as if it was 2 sizes smaller.