I LOVED this top! I wore it for Christmas this year and it was perfect, cute and just nice enough for the holiday. It is pretty thin so definitely not warm but it would be so easy to wear it under a coat. It definitely runs small, I usually wear XS and the small fit perfectly.

I wore this sweater out to dinner and out on some cool hikes in the desert. It was a light weight sweater that was great under a puffer coat. Beautiful color.

It fit me so perfectly. The length is perfect. Not too long and not too cropped.

The other reviewers had warned that the fit was small. I was going for a more fitted look to pair with high waisted jeans or pants so the small size worked for me. As for the brand and price point, I expected a better quality (it was great for a rental but I wouldn't buy it.)

Seriously with this child-sized “sweater”? The model is either wearing a large or customers are shrinking this in the dryer. I quite literally laughed when I pulled it out of the bag. As luck would have it, mine actually had a hole in the seam so I was able to send it back and it didn’t feel like a total waste of a rental.

I sized up from a XS to a Small and this sweater is basically still made for a doll. Or someone washed it. Unwearable

Comfy, great material, soft. Can be worn so many ways. Just love it!

Shorter length, looked good with higher waisted jeans. Material isn't that forgiving so it you feel self conscious around the belly area this may not be the best choice. Nicely made. Wouldn't buy for $200 but. Great rental. Received compliments.

This definitely runs small and REQUIRES high waisted pants. The color is great though and it is super comfortable! It's very thin but very warm too! I loved this I wore it several times!

Very comfortable, fits like a glove and great colour. Everyone should own this!

This light wool sweater has cute piping on the hem and cuffs. It has a general sporty feel to it. Would make a great layer for a ski trip.

The length was too short for a winter sweater

Wore this on my ski vacation. Very tight turtle!!

No joke, could barely get my head through the turtleneck opening. And cropped doesn't begin to describe the length. It was just, like, barely below my armpits. Had a good chuckle and put it right back in the bag.

Cute but runs small and very see through.

Really short. Not for me. Retuned.

This is unacceptable that they are renting this. It's like it's made for a child. Either someone shrunk it or the sizing is WAY off. I normally wear an XS, and sized up to a S after reading the comments. It's microscopic! Totally unwearable.

This runs very small. I am usually a 4, and often a 2, and I could barely fit into size M.

Rented in December. The red was perfect color for season. Can layer if wearing in colder weather or alone. Dress up or down, it is ideal staple piece for wardrobe.

Loved this but wasn't as versatile as I hoped as It was very short and could only be worn with high waisted pants. I usually wear a small or xs but needed a medium in this one and It was still Very fitted.

I loved it

Fit is tight but looked great under a sleeveless black dress.

Love this turtleneck - great soft fabric, lightweight, beautiful color. Would rent again! I sized up after reading the reviews and the large fit perfectly.

Love this, but the small was too small for me. Will get it again in the medium.

I read previous reviews and thankfully sized up two sizes. Perfect fit though sleeves are long. Note this is also extremely short - you will need to wear w high waisted bottom. The fabric is wonderfully soft and comfortable and the stitching at the neck makes the sweater. Received complements at work for the beautiful color.

There is black ribbing on the neck and stitch detail at the waist which make it really interesting. Smooth soft wool. A little short and slim - I often wear a 4 in Theory but would have been better with a 6

Loved the color. The tone to this elevated its style. It is very short in waist.

I don't normally wear tight tops, but I didn't mind in this one! The color is gorgeous, and there is some really lovely stitching on the hem and wrists that only I noticed but appreciated.

This sweater is beautiful and soft, but it runs small. For me it was too short in the torso to wear, but lovely for a more petite person.

Beautiful but tight (and slightly thin) sweater. I ordered a medium - usually wear a 4 - and I probably could have ordered a large!

see above

Good quality, but run small.

So tiny. It fit my 14 year old so she wore it, but I did not.

This sweater fit well and is soft. I liked it but did not think it was extra special. I wasn't a huge fan of the black in the turtle neck.

Great sweater but size up, tight around the neck

This is the sweater you run to social media to tell everyone about, but it's soft, polished, and looks great under a blazer.

Nice color, muted red that was a good neutral. Ran small. I can often wear a small, but the medium was snug. The collar is really itchy, so if you're sensitive to that, this may be difficult to wear.

This sweater was really short on me! I ended up not wearing it due to the fit.

As other reviewers have commented, the sweater is very short on the torso. You really need something high waisted to pull this off. One more thing - although the material is somewhat thin, I was very warm in this sweater. For those who "run hot" like me, this may not be the sweater for you.