I wasn’t expecting this cardigan to be cropped but it ended up working perfectly on me. I also rented the size Medium, as it was the only one in stock, and was prepared for it to be a bit oversized but it wasn’t at all - I did note that the size was “just right” on me but it might be on the smaller side for anyone who regularly wears a size Medium (the other Antonoff pieces I rented were XS/S). I paired this cardi with a matching Rachel Antonoff set from my own closet and it was an amazing finishing touch for the look. The pop of color was perfection and it provided the right amount of coziness for an outdoor concert. The only thing is… I need it in my own closet now!!

I loved this sweater. I had to size down due to availability, and it fit perfectly (it is cropped) — so I imagine it would be oversized if you go TTS!

I love this cardigan and I am highly considering purchasing it! I have rented another one in a different pattern I love it so much!

This is such a fun cardigan- rented it for a vacation to the Pacific Northwest and got compliments everywhere I wore it. Will definitely rent it again when the weather cools off!

I love this! This was not what I wore it with and it was a little heavy for what ended up being an unseasonably warm time of year, but I would definitely rent it again!

I love this sweater so much. I literally got so many compliments!

I wore this with a RTR dress and received so many compliments. People would notice the different colors and like it even more.

my sister wore this to a sushi dinner & hockey game & got sooo many compliments at both! wanna buy it for her when it goes down a little in price. She LOVED.

Wore multiple times and for several compliments

Love this!

Wore both buttoned up as a shirt and as a cardigan over a tee and jeans as well as with a dress. Had strangers stopping me to compliment me.

Sending this one back was hard! This is such a fun little sweater, especially for the end of summer. So many compliments! And comfortable, too!

I had so much fun with this one. Was great for wearing to class or walking around with friends in like ~60 degree weather. Definitely a head turner but super cute if you wear it confidently!

This sweater is adorable. I have a shorter torso and larger chest, so the cropped yet oversized look worked really well for me. The bottom hit me at the smallest part of my waist and my chest was fully covered. I wore it for a casual Friday at work and got lots of compliments from co-workers and students alike. Definitely a great rental :-)

A cute sweater to throw in your bag to brave summer air conditioning when you wear a sleeveless top. I wore it on the subway and in the coffee shop while remote working an got a few compliments. Comfy and fun!

Even cuter in person. Fit isn't my favorite (oversized yet cropped) but I made it work. Color and overall happiness effect made up for it. Compliments galore.

Great rental! Easy to thrown on, nice mid weight material, and a cheerful lighthearted print. The shape is a bit blah / matronly but you can't have it all I guess. Fit TTS for me.

Baggy fit, so I would size down. The sleeves are particularly large and I had a hard time keeping them rolled up because the fabric is so heavy and nice. super cute and comfortable tho.

True to size. Fun sweater!

Cute! Good, not quite cropped length. Will consider renting again in the fall.

One of my fave Rachel Antonoff pieces. Definitely a loose fit

I will regret not purchasing this. It's super cropped, but really so cute.

So cute!

Fun sweater. Perfect for vacation, everyday

I wore this sweater every chance I got. I loved the fun print and it was just right cropped for me. It is pretty warm, but it helped to unbutton it. Highly recommend for an early spring pick me up.

The cardigan is a little cropped and fitted. The material is soft and I love the print/design. Every time I wore it I received compliments. I would rent this again.

Cheerful and fun cardigan, very soft, and a great conversation starter. Kind of goes with everything. A perfect italian adventure wardrobe piece!

Tomato sweater is my whole personality. I love it and it loves me. Bought it because I did not wear it a single time without getting compliments on it

Fit great, heavy cotton material, got tons of compliments!

Cropped fit, great with high waisted pants and form fitting tank underneath

I am NOT on the cropped bandwagon and generally avoid it here on RTR (which is a bummer since so many things are cropped!) but I made an exception for this adorable sweater. Loved it!

I love quirky things and this sweater is adorable

Great sweater, I wore it over tanks and as a top alone and got so many compliments.

i sized down & wore this over a cropped white tank with high rise black jeans and white cowboy boots. so fun!! I def prefer this piece styled open, buttoned up was a lil meh

XS was perfect for a more “fitted” look (it’s still a sweater), but S would be good for layering in the winter. Wore it mostly alone as a top but also open with a white tank. Would totally rent again

Last time I rented I got a medium and even though it was a little snug it looked better because the material is pretty thick so the size that fit correctly made me look bigger

My whole family loved this sweater on me. That's a new one!