Love this one! The fit is a bit relaxed and the colors are really pretty together -- blue, purple and black. I will rent this one again.

A bit on the tighter end but I loved this dress. It was so flattering and I ended up buying it bc the price was so great.

Classier than you might think from photos. Quality piece!

Great fit very comfortable

This dress is great quality and the perfect weight. Would be great for WFH since it's super comfortable

Loved this sweater dress - very flattering- warm!

Did amazing things for my body. I'm a 4 top 8 bottom and while the medium was a little big, I did not want it tighter on my stomach. Will rent again.

Out of the bag, I thought this was nice but "just" a sweater dress. It totally grew on me! The fit was lovely: not tight through the waist and a soft A-line skirt. Very flattering and my husband said it was sexy. I love the purple-blue color of the stripes, subtle sparkle on the wrists and the soft knit. I wore it with tights and ankle booties to work. Then with knee high leather boots + black velvet blazer for class. I found this versatile to style. I would def rent again.

Love this cosy sweater dress almost as much as the PS one RTR had last year which was one of my top rentals. I've gained some weight since then but this knit is forgiving and does not cling to the body. Can dress this up or just wear casually w boots or even sneakers. Love!

This is such a great dress! Fits tts and falls just right. The fabric is soft (not scratchy) with just a touch of stretch, and the dress retained shape throughout the day. I wore it for an industry event, and it is just the right mix of conservative yet modern. It has both black and navy colors, so it goes with basically any color shoes/bag, and I think it would look great with a belt as well. Not rushing to return this one :)

I used it a lot on vacation when I needed to use a dress for my meetings. It's cute, warm, doesn't wrinkle and easy to pack.

Maybe it’s my shape, but this was a weird fit. Started off tight in the arms (fine as the day went on) and was weirdly loose in the tummy. Not flattering but maybe would be perfect if you’re pregnant. It was comfortable.

Wore multiple times. Loved this dress, which fits perfectly and doesn't hug too tight the way some sweater dresses do. Looked great with a leather jacket and heeled boot.

i loved this dress! it fit a little tight on top, but not in an uncomfortable way. i wore to work multiple times and got tons of compliments! perfect dress for the fall

This dress hangs beautifully and creates the illusion of a slender waistline. Love it!

Hits mid calf. Pairs well with boots. Larger bust size may be a little tight. Just enough room for a C cup.

This is a great dress for everyday. It is definitely a bit more casual in person, though I am sure you could pep it up a bit with the right shoes and accessories.

Easy comfortable

The dress is great quality and very flattering and comfortable. I wore it with tall brown boots.

The dress is a nice heavy knit. And the middle has great swing to it and starts to flow into the skirt beautifully, concealing a tummy really well and avoiding the need for Spanx! My only issue is this: the sleeves are incredibly tight. I wore the xs and struggled to move the sleeve seam into position due to the tightness. Everywhere else fit perfect. I do recommend the dress, as it’s lovely.

Perfectly fine dress but not as cool or interesting as you expect from Proenza. The ribbed material honestly skews a little Old Navy. It's warm but VERY statick-y, so just watch for that as you move. I wore it out to a dinner with friends.

liked it

Fit well and was warm and soft, easy to wear over my 3rd trimester belly!

This was lovely fabric and flattering styling. Only sweater dress where I haven't needed shapewear, and it was nicely warm without being heavy too. However, the overall look was just a bit too old for me.

This is a great dress, but the arms are abnormally smaller than others. There is no stretch in the arms. The fit of the dress is fantastic otherwise, fit and flare great for pear shapes. If you have tiny upper arms, go for it! if you don’t, pass. For reference, I am a 34B, 31” waist, 41” hips, 145lbs.

Weirdly tight on the arms but a little too long on bottom ? Fine besides that. Arms were kinda uncomfortable

The dress was a pretty forgiving material. The colors were nice, but the dress was really underwhelming. It reminded me of the ribbed, striped dresses from the 90s. Nothing particularly interesting about the cut and fabric was basically the quality you'd find at something from target. Definitely easy to wear on work from home days though.

Did not where

This was another item I tried on and sent back the stripes hit me on strange places

I love a good sweater dress and this one is exceptional. I have held on to it for ages and worn it at least 6 times. The fabric is light and it's warm without being heavy, and the shape is lovely, with the flare at the bottom making it very easy to move in. The sleeves are on the snugger side if that it something that bothers you. I would totally buy it if it were a less expensive!

Wore this for a meeting- everyone recognized it as a Proenza dress. Great deal!

Slimming. Sleek. Wonderful all around.

Love this, fit perfectly. Would buy if not for the price!

I rented this dress in a similar style last Fall and loooooved it! Happy to report the latest incarnation is just as fab. Heel, No heel, boot ... you can do any of it with this perfect Fall look!

This dress was like wearing a blanket all day! It was flattering and very cute, but so soft and comfortable. I am usually between a M and L, but even the medium was loose on me. It is a stretchy knit. If you want it fitted, size down.