I tried this in a small in black and i prefer wearing the medium. Its about the same length but gives me a little more rooms in the shoulders and to wear an undershirt. The color is a darker red than I expected more like a rust.

Cute! Wanted to wear with tights but day turned out warmer than expected.

Wore this dress with dark stockings to my 10 year reunion. Was cute and simple. Would definitely rent again to wear to work.

I ordered a size down based in reviews, SM fit perfectly. A bit itchy but not terrible.

I loved the color of this dress and got lots of compliments on it! The sleeves were a great touch to set it apart from other dresses. I felt like it made me look a little bulky because it was slightly oversized, but it was super comfortable to wear for a family event.

Fit well for a 34 week bump, very cute and comfy with leggings and boots. A little too itchy, had to wear a long sleeve shirt under and I still wanted it off ASAP.

I'm between a 4 and a 6 and the same was way too big. I know big is trendy right now but it just made me look shapeless. The material is soft amd the color is great. Maybe size down?!?

I bought for a shower, but then didn't love it enough. I just wore it to church.

I liked the color and the fit of the M was flattering, but this was a little too itchy for my sensitive skin. Couldn't wear.

Great dress. I'm 16 weeks pregnant, so not yet far enough along for maternity clothes, but not able to squeeze into my normal clothes. This dress was a perfect dress for late 1st trimester/early 2nd trimester, as it is nice and fitted in the shoulders and bust, but loose enough around the mid-section that it covers up a small bump, etc. For reference, I'm 5'6" and currently about a size 6. The length is perfect for the office with flats (only a couple of inches above the knee) and the sleeve length is just right.

Sized up to a medium to accommodate being 6 months pregnant. Loose fitting and very flattering. Highly recommend.

This is a great sweater dress that isn't too tight on the bottom, which is nice. Sometimes a form fitting sweater dress is too tight to wear to work - but this was perfect and I felt cute all day! The sleeves are a little short, but I got over it.

on the shorter side, semi itchy but great fit and wore on a casual dinner date

Wore this for thanksgiving, comfortable for that. The sleeves seemed a bit short.

Got a few compliments. Super scratchy material which I did not like. Color is really pretty. Perfect for a family party this time of year.

Sleeves were a little short - not sure if its meant to be like that or I have long arms? I have sensitive skin so it was a little itchy. If I lived in a colder climate I would totally buy this - it would look awesome with tall boots.

This dress is mire causal than I expected but i loved it. Warm, long enough to feel covered. Would look great with or without tights.

I do agree it is slightly itchy like most reviews warned, but it's very flattering and the bow tie detail on the sleeves is my favorite part!

The dress fit well and was comfortable. I was worried about the long ties on the sleeves, but they didn't bother me during the day. If I sat long, it would wrinkle in the front, but they came out immediately with a quick brush of the hand. The dress was a little itchy because of the wool (?)

It's a very cute and loose fitting dress. It's very cute for everyday winter wear with tights and boots. The fabric is a bit itchy but it might be because I received a new one (the tags were still on it) and it needed to be washed to soften up the fabric.

This dress is a very nice feeling sweater dress that I was very happy to receive for New York winters. It is quite loose fitting but I belted it and it looked great

I wore this for a work event while 4 months pregnant. it fit the bump well but it's starting to show wear and is itchy. I'd recommend wearing tights or a slip under otherwise the material is uncomfortable. There is pilling on the sides and on the front. Overall it's ok but not the best rental.

I rented this with my Update subscription as an option for casual engagement photos and/or for everyday wear with boots. I didn't end up wearing it much -- I just found it didn't look all that good on. It's quite thin. The color is gorgeous, and the sleeves are a nice touch, but overall it is underwhelming.

The bell sleeves are short, the tie attached is too long, and the fabric was itchy. I wore it and felt pretty in it but i wouldnt rent it again

The color in person is a little more washed out than the photos. Construction is not the best, as one of the wrist bows completely fell off after wearing the dress for 3 hours. It was warm and comfortable, but not as great as I'd have expected.

Fit well, flattering cut and style. Versatile. My only con was that the dress was itchy. I loved how it looked, but couldn't wait to take it off after a day of wearing it.

I absolutely loved the fit, color and style of the dress, however, the merino wool is incredibly itchy and I had to take it off after about a minute so I never wore it out. If you have sensitive skin, this is not the dress for you.