The sweater was as expected, but I couldn’t quite tell what to do with the slit near the wrist. It wouldn’t stayed rolled up, but it looked cute that way. Great color.

I find most sweaters itchy and this wasn't. The sleeve detail was cute. It was very warm.

Sweater is very warm. It is a thick wool material, I had little to no itchiness from it but if your sensitive to wool it might bother you

Very cozy and comfortable. Not itchy. Nice detail on the sleeves. Wore a basic tee under it since there are some gaps in the knit. It does hit a bit higher on the hip, but I liked that change from the usual butt-length sweaters. Great, versatile, easy piece.

This sweater is super warm, with a thick yarn and raised Bayern. The color is great. Overall the fit is true to size, with a slim fit, but the sleeves are super long.

The overall fit of the sweater was on the slender side.

The fit was just right for me with no room to spare. Loved the slit cuffs. Easy to fold back when washing hands or typing. Hem hit right at the waist. Fabric is soft. Got some lovely compliments on it.

Loved wearing this sweater to work with a black pencil skirt. It kept me very warm. I love the slit end sleeve detail.

Just not a great fit

Fantastic sweater. Many complements. Would have purchased if I could have afforded it.

Exactly what you'd expect from the photo. It's warm, true to size, attractive, not a show stopper.

Great for a weekend conference.

Pretty slim / fitted, not usually what I do for in a cable knit but cute. Slightly loose knit so you need something under it. Not itchy.

True to size, beautiful color.

Perfect color for winter. Nice and warm. Wasn't itchy. Neckline is flattering. I didn't live the sleeves that have slits in the wrist area as it just made it feel like the sleeves were too long and I wanted to push/roll them up. I found them annoying.

n/a

Color is pretty but it's very thick and tight so not super comfortable. The sleeve detail made the sleeves feel too short for me.

This runs incredibly small. Normally a S or M and would have sized up to a L, and even then it would be a slim fit I think.

Wish I could afford to buy this. It's warm, not too cropped and a great color that seems to go with everything. Love the chunky knit and the cut out detail on the sleeve.

True to size - if you don't want a fitted look, I recommend going one size up. Great attention to details. Truly a winner!

I was a little nervous about the fit of this sweater being short, however it fit perfect. I was comfy, sporty, and cute all at the same time. I received non-stop compliments on the color complimenting my skin, etc. The only thing is it smell like coffee or something when I got it. I didn't realize this until I had left home.

Fits well and the color is rich and pretty

For very well. Great material and very warm.

nice, thick sweater. runs a little small. lovely color with some blue undertones

100% wool but somehow not itchy. Super warm. Medium hit me mid hip bone. Seemed very old school J Crew to me except for the funky sleeves.

Fit here was TTS. I wish the sweater was slightly more cropped, but I just folded up the front when needed. I paired this with a skirt for work and then with Spanx faux leather leggings on New Years Day. Sweater was cozy and warm without being itchy. I really liked the wrist detail, which I wore both long and folded up.

Very cute, on-trend burgundy popcorn sweater. The fabric was slightly itchy but I wore a long-sleeved shirt underneath and was fine. I liked the style of this sweater and its has a heavier weight which is great for winter. Would rent again!

I loved the color and the texture of this sweater. For what I was wearing it for I didn't mind the added volume to my shoulders and torso, but I wouldn't use when I am trying to look slimmer.

Gorgeous everyday sweater. Lovely colour

Cute sweater. Cropped fit - I sized up for a little more coverage. Great color and interesting detail with the slit sleeve. Would rent again.

The perfect sweater to wear to work. I love the slits in the sleeves and the popcorn details

I loved the color. Basic sweater with a little flair to the sleeves.

This sweater is so thick and cozy - I wore it with a long sleeved shirt underneath and was very warm outside on a 40 degree day. Beware, though, that the arms are long and you have to roll it up a couple of times to fit. It's not the most flattering given it's thick and a crew neck; given I have boobs, I definitely looked way wider than I am. Still a good sweater, though, and S hit me at hip (I'm 5'2").

I didn't love this sweater and ended up not wearing it.

This sweater was fine. It was comfortable and kept me warm. As with all Phillip Lim tops, the sleeves were a bit long on me. Nothing spectacular about this piece. Certainly wouldn't consider spending over $100 to buy it.

liked the sleeves, but the fit was a bit bulky.

This sweater is very high quality and has a beautiful rich color but I wasn't super excited about wearing it, maybe because the knit is so heavy. It's fine - but nothing to get super excited about. The popcorn texture elevates it beyond your typical sweater.

It hit me right at my waist and was not my favorite sweater.

not a great for big busted women