Luxury warm sweater. I loved the detail of the buttons on the back. Slim fit through the body and the arms and the neck, but I was still able to wear a layering T-shirt under although I did not feel itchy.

Loved the sleeves and buttons up the back - such a cute twist on a sweater. Got lots of compliments on it as well. Warm too! Definitely considering buying this one!

I got a lot of compliments with this one. I found it to be soft and cozy, but not suffocating. Suitable for the coldest temps in mid-winter, except for maybe that it is pretty short. I’m also short (5’2”) so it was not cropped on me, but hit just below the top of my jean’s waistband. I can see that on someone taller that might be a risk. This is the most tailored sweater I’ve found lately in RTR, since many sweater styles are boxy and baggy right now. It was a nice change.

Looks like an ordinary sweater, but the back is the showstopper

I sized up per reviews and the medium was a perfect fit! It’s made of wool so if you don’t lie how wool feels be prepared to layer. Very cute look! Enjoyed wearing it for the cold streak we had down south.

Wore this casually with jeans and flats, and dressed up a bit with satin pants. Form fitted so size up if between, on cropped size so wore with body suit for the office to ensure no skin. Button details on back are adorable and turtleneck lays nicely. Loved it!

It was too cropped for my longer torso. Nice fit otherwise, and the style is very cute.

She's cute but only wore once as it was just OK. The material isn't itchy per se but not soft and comfortable. The backward cardi feature / look is cool but again, nothing too crazy.

Super stylish. Crop fit. Looked great with jeans and with pencil skirt.

Loved this top, it fit true to size and I wore it multiple times while I was home for the holidays

True to size. Cropped but not too short. A little bit itchy.

I think I should have gone with the XL, as the 2X is a little bit too large for me, so I lost a bit of my waist/shapeliness when I wore it. I love the buttons down the back! They are functional, too, so that was a neat detail. I love this sweater so much, it’s not too thick, but feels very well made and substantial.

hits at waist, very warm

It had a nice rear style, very warm

Fits perfect

What a great sweater. Looks like a boring turtleneck from the front but then the buttons on the back! The cool extra long black cuff thingies! A tiny bit itchy but not enough to make it uncomfortable (and I'm sensitive to itchy fabric). Totally worth it for how great this sweater fits and looks. Wore it to a work event and also out to brunch, will definitely wear again before I send it back. My husband saw it from the back and said, "That's cool, people won't know if you're coming or going" haha.

Loved the backwards look

Loved this one and even contemplated keeping

Fun elevated winter sweater

Very cute. A little itchy but not too bad.

This sweater is SO cute. I loved the buttons in the back and the black on the arms. I am so happy I sized up because it runs small and short. Other then that it is soft and super easy to thrown on with jeans.

Has the cropped fit that's popular right now. It's cute, but was a little uncomfortable and itchy.

This is so cute but I should have sized up. The ribbing hit in an odd spot on my bust so I did not wear. It was a little tight, but if the ribbing was different, I would have. Will rent again in a larger size

I thought sweater ran a bit small and cropped. It qas warm and gorgeous and the back button detail was perfect

The buttons on the back garnered a lot of comments. A little short for me

A little itchy but fit well. Wish it was less cropped but with the right pants I was able to make it work.

Love the idea of this sweater but didn't wear it much since of how cropped it was. The ribbing starts at a weird place too which makes it look even shorter. Also a tad itchy.

A few people said it was itchy. Drove my neck crazy. A bit on the small side.

If you aren't looking for a very cropped look, I would size up. Nice quality

This fit fine, but was stiffer and more cropped than I hoped. I liked the button detail in the back, but my daughter kept asking me why my sweater was on backwards. It was fine, nothing special.

Ran a little small and a bit itchy material

It's a great sweater, worth your rental. I personally would have preferred it a little more baggy, a little longer. I'm not a crop top gal in winter. But love the high neck!!

The neck was so tight. This sweater might have been the most uncomfortable thing I've ever put on.