This Nicholas sweater is a stunner. It's thick yet not chunky, stylish, and comfortable. I love the oversized sleeves and the general shape that the sweater takes on while wearing. It gives 'effortless chic' if you ask me. I wore it pretty much everyday when I rented it and decided to give it a go in my permanent closet. This neutral color sweater is a must-rent in anyone's cycle. Totally give it a try!

Lovely cardigan great for a day on the town. Also great for work too. Perfect for transitional fall weather. Only draw back is it's itchy but you forget about it pretty quick

This was so easy to throw on over fall outfits. Loved it the most buttoned up as a shirt but the California weather meant I had to wear a layer under just in case it got too hot. Would highly recommend a tiny cream colored crop top underneath as an option. Loved it!

Other reviewers aren’t wrong about this being itchy but it’s so cute it’s worth it! Also super warm! I wore it a few times and a few different ways, but liked it the most without another top under, with the top buttons buttoned and the bottom ones undone. Went well with slouchy, low-waisted pants.

This cropped sweater I paired with my straight leg leather pants. Itch was tolerable, long sleeve underneath would solve. Soooooo good! Sleeves nice and long

Such a gorgeous and soft sweater! Perfect for winter dates! Fits true to size

While this sweater technically fit, it was awkward. The photo shows the nice detail on the sleeve, but it looked big in the arms and small in the chest. Maybe try it if you have a larger chest. It’s also scratchy, not soft.

I was planning to wear this buttoned up without a top, or just a cami, underneath. However, it turned out to be too low of a V neck and too thick and fuzzy to wear that way. It was nice and warm for WFM purposes over a t-shirt instead.

I like the longer sleeves and the changing knit sequence. Overall fine, also probably won't rerent.

Great fit, a little itchy

Did not know I had short arms until this sweater. Maybe it's just me

I wore it several times over a dress and tank tops. It's a bit itchy but mostly I didn't mind. It's a very casual shape.

Purchased. Goes cute over a tank and buttoned, or over a summery dress. The arms are extra long, which I love. Detailing and fuzzy yard is a cute way to dress up a simple cardigan that goes with everything.

It wasn't too itchy, too warm, too big of a knit. Just right all the way around

I loved this sweater paired with some high waisted wide leg pants but as everyone else described it is a bit itchy.

Warmer than it looks and so comfortable. Easy to wear to elevate any casual outfit. True to size. Arms are designed to be full.

As a random item I threw in my membership, this one was a pleasant surprise! It’s actually thick and kept me super warm in place of a jacket. Can dressed up or down, buttoned as a top or unbuttoned as a cardigan. Like the reviews say, it’s somewhat itchy but def bearable.

This is actually quite warm so I only paired it with a tank top. Looked very cute.

Flattering and I wouldn’t say very itchy

Cute and casual!

The arms were really long and a bit baggy, while slightly small in the chest. I left it unbuttoned so it was fine but would have looked a little stretched if I had it buttoned.

it is an awkward fit and very itchy

I saw that others had remarked this sweater was itchy. Some had said it wasn't, so I decided to take a chance and order it. As soon as I put it on I knew it was a no-go for me. Even with a thick long sleeve shirt on I felt the dreaded itch. I had to take it off. Not for me, but if you aren't sensitive to itchy fabrics like me, it is super cute and nicely made.

This sweater is thick and warm. The sleeves were so much longer than necessary I had to roll them up, which is funny given this sweater is cropped.

Long sleeves but loved that look. Itchy but worn over a dress or top, I didn’t notice. Cute layer when weather is unknown!

I put this sweater back in the bag after trying it on. It was so fuzzy and itchy.

Very ichy and oversized