Yes, it doesn't fit off the shoulder like the photo. But I loved it anyway. The boatneck neckline looked great on me, and I liked the hemline because it was long enough to cover/flatter problem areas. The deep green color brought out my green eyes and reddish hair. (I think in my photo the color looks brown but it's actually green) Considering buying.

In my third trimester, probably could have made it work, but wasn't as comfortable to move around as I would like.

Comfy not itchy, wearing during 3rd trimester. Nice length and color is olive green

Yes, it's not as loose as the photo on the model. I rented the XS, my usual size, and I would need to size up for the slouchy cold shoulder look. The neck opening is not wide enough unless I pull it down on one side. However, it's a cute sweater otherwise. Soft and a good length on me.

I thought this was going to come really big so I sized down. It was tighter than I pictured it and the cold shoulder kept riding up. If I got a bigger size it would have been perfect. Overall it did not disappoint. Great for every day.

Read all the reviews, they all advise to size up otherwise this is more of a boat neck than off the shoulder.

Fit was okay... not roomy enough in the neckline to be off-the-shoulder. Arms were tight. Torso was flared. Color was blah. Looks brown in most light. Didn't love it and didn't wear it.

Soft and roomy.

Perfect for early fall

This was so comfortable to wear both around the house and out for the rest of the day. I got several compliments on it too!

Comfy material, great color, good loose fit. More of a boatneck than off shoulder.

LOVED this sweater! It was perfectly roomy in the torso but doesn't look like a tent, so it was perfect for Thanksgiving with my boyfriend's family. I wore it a few times during the month I had it but would have worn it every day if I could have. The perfect dark olive color for fall/winter!

It ran a bit small for me. I was looking for a slouch look like on the model but this just fit like a normal boat neck sweater. I'd size up next time to try to achieve the off the shoulder look.

Perfect for a winter day! I think if I had sized up I would have had to cute off the shoulder look shown on the model, mine sit more like a cowl neck, but I don't care. It is so warn, pretty color. I love it. Wish I owned it!!

Runs really small. If you want it to slouch off your shoulders, size up!

This sweater does not hang at suggested and is a bit snug on the arms

runs small!

As one review said, it definitely did not fall off the shoulder nicely. It was, however, cute with dark jeans and booties. Nothing special though!

Fit is small, doesn't cover like a tunic and like is shown

I was expecting an off the shoulder slouchy look and this top was very tight in the arms. The neckline was off and looked strange when I tried to make it off the shoulder.

I don't think this sweater is meant to be off the shoulder - I had to really tug to get it to drape the way the model is wearing it but it just looked forced. The material was pretty itchy, I don't think it's something you should rent if you're going to an event where you'll be wearing it all day!

It was quite small and I'll fitting, not off shoulder.

Ended up not wearing it.

I ordered the large but was unable to wear it, it ran extremely small and the off the shoulder look would have been impossible to wear.

This neckline on this sweater does not go off the shoulder. It doesn't fit at all like the model in the picture. Very disappointing.

The top does not fit as pictured.