I'm between small and medium tops because while I'm a small person, I have a bigger chest (C cup) and so buttons near the chest tend to be an issue. The medium was great! I wore no bra and had no gapping between buttons. The trick was to button the top and bottom buttons first and then fill in the rest. Worked great with high wasted jeans. Honestly I almost bought the top because it was so flattering.

Highly recommend

My first ever RTR purchase! I really tried to send it back but it's just too cute and versatile. Obviously very well made and the cut is divinely flattering. A bit busty, but in a classy way without needing a bra. Definitely size up! Works great with high waisted pants or cute as a true crop top.

I really loved this too. Perfect for a fun night out. The only downside is that the straps are too long if you’re petite so you have to constantly adjust.

I'm petite and small busted and liked how this fit. However, I had to be really conscious all night about not exposing myself. The shirt stretched out so after the second wear I felt like the fit wasn't secure enough to wear anymore.

Cute top

Super cute and comfy, went braless, wore around site seeing for the day and never was uncomfortable!

Very cute top that is somewhat cropped. I wore it a few times with jeans and a high waisted skirt . Material is thick and great quality.

I wore this shirt with a dark wash denim skirt and loved the fabric and ruffles. The shirt was snug in the chest (32C) but I wore it without a bra and it was still very flattering! You have to button up the front, there is no zipper, so it's tricky getting on especially if it's too small!

Loved this top. Typically wear a 2-4 but the medium was the best fit. Very cropped - need high waist denim. Wore without a bra and fit great. I have a 3 month old so when holding him had to be on cleavage duty but otherwise stayed in place well.

This may be my favorite top I have rented. It's such good quality and a beautiful design that is very flattering. My only complaint with this top is the sizing is strange. I ordered a small originally and could not button a single button on the front. I loved it so much, I snagged it in a large next time I saw it available. The large was a little big, but I went with it anyway. I recommend going up a size if you have a chest. I am a 34C with a fairly narrow upper body, and I think the medium would of fit best.

if this fits, you're going to love it. Was super tight on me and showed a lot of cleavage. Very well made. Was tempted to purchase. Very sexy.

Definitely runs a little small but I wore it with shorts once and then high waisted jeans a second time. Cute with both on very hot days. It's structured but if you are smaller chested you don't need to wear a bra with it.

Fit so perfectly - I bought it!

runs a little snug in ribcage area

Teensy

This top is very cute, I love the structure and cut of it. I'm usually between XS and S so I went for the S, but I need a medium. The small BARELY closes even without a bra.

Rented by mistake - I was trying to match the skirt. But got lots of compliments! Pretty short on me so if you're not into showing midriff make sure you have some super high waist bottoms

I loved this shirt on the hanger, but it actually took four hands to get it buttoned! Runs quite small. It looked good on but was so tight that I could only wear it for a few hours.

A bit low cut and tight, but really flattering and fun!

I rented this hoping to wear it with shorts as a cute summer look. It was just too low cut to wear out. My husband liked it when I wore it around the house though. It was well made and cute if you are comfortable showing a lot of cleavage.

Would be really cute Wirral high waisted shorts!

I wish I could have worn this top. It's adorable. I'm usually a small in most tops (34 C/32D) and this was TINY. I couldn't even button the buttons. I'm not sure even one size up would work. Might have needed a large. VERY cute though and would have looked great with high waisted jeans.

It ran so small I couldn't wear it. I would definitely size up.

I have a larger bust but can usually do small tops - this one is definitely for a smaller bust because I couldn't even button it!

Was super excited for the top. However when it arrived, I couldn't button it over my chest! I have. Relatively small frame with a slightly above average chest so I was a little surprised that it wouldn't button at all. The quality was great however and super cute for hot summer days. Will think about renting again.

Make sure you order up by 2 sizes. Most of the tops I own are XS, but I've gained 10 lbs over Covid so I ordered a size small. I couldn't button ANY of the buttons. The small didn't wrap around my rib cage. The top is super cute, but not at all true to size.

This top is so cute and the material is thick and beautiful, but unfortunately it was just too small to wear.

i sized up because everyone said it ran small. I usually wear size small. so i grab a medium and it wouldn't even come close to buttoning.

I am normally a size small and could not button this. I tried even without a bra but no way it could even close! Sending back without wearing this.

Wayyyyy to small. I ordered a medium but it wasn’t made for big boobs. What a waste

I was so bummed! I sized up to medium and still couldnt get it to fit. Sadly there was no place I wanted to wear a shirt that barely buttoned so it was a wasted slot. I do have broad shoulders and a wider rib cage and this shirt has zero give- so maybe that was my problem.

Even after sizing up so that I could button the buttons I found the sizing to be so off that the cut was not flattering at all

I have zero up there and normally wear a small or extra small. I can't even close this top. Waste of a rental.

I couldn't even button the top. Returning without wearing

This looked like a sports bra! So thight and small, should be posted as a crop top! I got medium cause of some reviews when I'm usually small or 2-4! I couldn't fit in the medium, probably wouldn't fit even in a large. Just avoooid it or get XL!!

Not food for my body type

I'm usually a small and sized up to a medium and still couldn't get this to button up!

Huge

Too small for a petite 32C like me. I couldn't even button. Also just didn't seem like high quality fabric. Very cute style though