This too obviously isn't anything special, but it's great and easy to dress up or down. Wore it with casual jeans and sandals in the summer!

This top is so flattering and so cute! The material is a good inbetween so it's not so thick it feels heavy, but it's not so lightweight that you don't feel secure. Super stylish and cute!

This top was fantastic! Was tempted to buy it! I wore it tucked into a maxi skirt, but it could have been worn with pants or jeans as well! The fit was tight enough so you didn't have to wear a bra, but was still breathable. Will definitely rent again.

Goes with everything - wore with skirts, jeans, shorts, very versatile Sized up

Didn't like the sleeves, too short. But cute and comfortable.

This top was so cute! I will definitely rent it again this summer. I paired it with white jean shorts to wear out to lunch and changed into cheetah biker shorts later in the day for a more comfortable outfit. Would also go great with white jeans in a casual work environment! The material was fitted and thick enough for me to comfortably wear without a bra, which was a plus but wasn't too hot.

This too was so cute! I wore it multiple times while I had it and would definitely recommend! It was a little tight in the arms but didnt bother me too much.

LOVED THIS TOP, super cute with high waisted jeans or shorts and very comfy. Stretchy & forgiving, but didn't need a bra. RENT THIS!!

This top was so comfortable, easy, and stunning. It dressed up a simple concept: jeans and a black t shirt in spectacular fashion. I will rent this again.

I love that I don't have to wear a bra with it and I still feel secure. Perfect for day or casual night out.

Liked this shirt a lot. Even wore it to work once (with a tank underneath so my tummy didn't show if I raised my arms). Wished it was just a smidge longer, but overall loved it. Cute and comfy:)

Can dress it up or down! Beautiful fit, love the square top and the sleeves. The ruffle at the bottom is also very flattering.

Nice stretch and cute black shirt for everyday wear.

Great for everyday, super comfy but cute!

Cute, good fit. A bit constricting in the chest area if you want to wear a bra, but you don't have to.

Fit was a little small but overall cute top That could be dressed up Or down

I really like this top. I'm a tall girl and if this was longer, I would have kept it.

This top was cute but it didn't WOW me. I wore it, the hem was a little short and it reminded me of back in the days of wearing a tube top because of the same "feeling" (stretchy) but it was just OK and I swapped it for another.

This is a cropped peplum top. I can't think of anything less flattering. At first I got a small and it was awful but I thought I just needed a bigger size. Tried a large and it's just as cropped and awful. Not a good look.

I thought I'd like this more but the fabric isn't as sturdy as I expect from madewell.

I'm 5'8" and this came barely to my bellybutton. It was cute but definitely not for me. I had a medium for reference.

Weird fit

The smocked bodice fit nicely, but the puff sleeves looked horrible on me. The combination of the puff sleeve and flared bottom (which would be better if it's an inch longer) made this top unwearable.

if you have side fat, it looks a little awkward