I loved wearing this top. Great fit and the details are nice. It sat just right so I could wear over jeans or skirts.

The fit of this was spot on size-wise but boxy by nature. Petites with curves beware. The eyelet means it's very light with "ax", and a unique option for hot weather.

Pretty top, cute tie in back, but on the shorter side.

Fits well although was a little tight around the arms for me. A lightweight eyelet top- not too short.

fit was slim but loved it

I loved this shirt so much I wanted to buy it. Adds some flair to a casual outfit.

I loved this top! As some others said, the material wasn't as see through as I expected. I wore it 3 times, once with a light green cami underneath (which I didn't feel like others could notice) and twice with a black cami. It was great for work and casual wear, I paired it with blue jeans and a variety of shoes that dressed it up/down. I will note that there is no give in the material and since it's boxy this might hug you where you're widest! I was glad I went up a size, but I don't think it was absolutely necessary.

Super fun and cute top. The shirt is on the looser side; however, if I size down the arm holes may have been too tight. Loved this shirt. Will rent again.

A little short but super cute

No complaints!

Fits true to size.

I really liked this shirt and I got lots of compliments on it! It was a little tight in the shoulders and arms, so if you have a more athletic build I would recommend sizing up.

Almost too tight in the sleeves, but I've noticed that to be the case with this brand.

A little tight on my arms but it worked out.

This was just ok. It was overall small fit in the shoulders and arm holes. I did wish it was a bit longer. Not that flattering. I did easily wear it with no cami underneath but I am not shy about that.

The top is adorable and versatile. Made of soft cotton, it has a sexy yet demure appeal due to the cutouts. However, the arms were too tight for me to wear, which is surprising because I requested an XXL and I usually have no problems with Madewell clothing.

This shirt was okay but not special enough that I bothered to wear it. It fit a bit snug but that could be a me problem and I'm just so fatigued by sizing. I'm an average size 6 so if a medium is snug on me I can't imagine how more voluptuous women even fit into this stuff. The top just wasn't special and I don't know. It was "meh." I had much more exciting tops in my order so those were what I chose to wear instead. Every time I needed something fun.

Really cute top but as a lot of reviewers said it's a bit snug in the arms. And for me it was a little to boxy and not super flattering.

Very flattering, and surprisingly.. not very see through despite all the holes! Loved it so much I bought it.

I felt too much like Wednesday Addams in this top (and I like a little Wednesday Addams in my look). It doesn't come with a tank or top to wear beneath FYI. Nothing wrong with it, just not my style up close and personal. Seems like it was true to size.